News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by mirekrusin on Saturday November 16, 2019 @11:07AM (#21553290)
Resonance is natural selection.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by lmilcin on Saturday November 16, 2019 @11:40AM (#21553503)
No, it is not.

It would be if we saw many colliding orbits and only those that had resonance surviving in long run.

But resonances are perfect ratios and no random orbits will ever have perfect ratios of orbit times.

Instead what happens is that collisions seem to be extremely rare occurrence. Once two moons find themselves on close orbits they will tend to exchange energy until they find some kind of resonance that will keep true for a very long time until disturbed.

Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by patcon on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:01PM (#21554290)
It might be more apt a metaphor than it seems...?

Resonant orbits might not be natural selection, but they might participate in a form of thermodynamic selection: two simple forms and structures selecting for and reinforcing one another.

They are both subsets of the same thermodynamic processes of structures/arrangements sticking arouns when they mutually support one another creating persistence in a chaotic system

My understanding is that some folks believe there are similar mechanisms underlying the emergence of both -- a generalized form of selection between mutually reinforcing structures that encode elements of prediction of the chaotic environment they reside in, be that the periodicity of orbits (that "know* a stable path that will reasonably persist) or life itself (that have similar baked in prediction abilities we perceive subjectively as consciousness).

Disclaimer: biochemist, technologist and armchair follower of complexity science

Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by gus_massa on Sunday November 17, 2019 @06:17PM (#21560716)
The idea is that the gravity of a moon affect the trajectory of the other moon and vice versa, until they are in resonance. It's a bad analogy, but it's closer to Lamarckism than Darwinism, but it's still a bad analogy. There are nothing similar to random mutations.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by mirekrusin on Thursday November 21, 2019 @04:01PM (#21599569)
By natural selection I meant that if you have two (or more) bodies on the same orbit they'll crash or they'll find stable orbit (resonance). Of course you see resonating ones because ones that wouldn't would collide millions of years ago.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by mirekrusin on Saturday November 16, 2019 @11:55AM (#21553574)
And what is your (absolute offset and) observation timeframe compered to the lifetime of the system?
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by lmilcin on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:30PM (#21554433)
There are simulations that show great deal of how and what is the likelihood of different systems forming.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by mirekrusin on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:00PM (#21633284)
You simply cannot have long lived, same radius orbiting objects, they must stabilize on resonance to exist.
Re:NASA finds Neptune moons locked in 'dance of avoidance' by Aperocky on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:35PM (#21553802)
I agree that in principal most things are natural selection. The things that are not on a current time (a certain proportion of which bound to exist) frame are behaviors that will eventually be eliminated.