News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against Economics by gruez on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:55PM (#21550679)
>4) replace payroll and income taxes with consumption taxes

how can this be implemented in a fashion that's non-regressive? income taxes in most countries are progressive, and consumption taxes are regressive.

Re:Against Economics by nwj on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:54PM (#21550903)
Progressiveness is a function of both taxes and benefits. A consumption tax scheme can be made more progressive by paying benefits in a more progressive manner.

For example, Exampleville institutes a consumption tax of 15%. Such a tax is regressive because consumption is usually a smaller proportion of a wealthy person's income than a poor person's income. To counteract this, Exampleville pays a monthly cash grant to all citizens and adjusts the payment level so that the cash grant is larger for the poor and smaller (or non-existent) for the wealthy.

See https://tax.purpleplans.org for an example of a real proposal that mimics this scheme.

Re:Against Economics by mdorazio on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:21AM (#21551165)
But this assumes that the revenue from the consumption tax will 1) be the same as for the income tax, and 2) hit wealthy people enough that the lower benefit payout will balance it.

I don't really see how these can be true given that, as you state, wealthy people spend a smaller portion (a lot smaller) of their income than do poor people.

To toss out some numbers, let's say the wealthy person makes $1M per year at a 35% effective income tax rate and the poor person makes $50K per year at an effective 10% income tax rate. Let's further suppose the wealthy person spends half their after-tax income, and the poor person spends all of it. Total tax revenue in this case would be $355K under the income scheme, but if we switch to a consumption tax, the tax revenue drops to $55,500. There's no amount of benefit allocation you can do to make up the difference. On top of that, the tax burden for the wealthy person (after offsetting for the benefit allocation) is still massively lower than under the income scheme, even if they get $0 in benefits. You'd have to raise the consumption tax ridiculously high (33% !) to get close, which will effectively discourage expenditures and encourage savings, pretty much destroying the US consumption-based economy.

I just can't see a realistic scenario where this setup isn't regressive or generally a bad idea. If you want to keep a progressive system but also eliminate income tax, we need to consider a wealth tax.

Re:Against Economics by smnrchrds on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:51AM (#21551243)
> You'd have to raise the consumption tax ridiculously high (33% !)

I don't think 33% is ridiculously high. VAT is 25% in Norway, Sweden, and Denmark, 27% in Hungary; and their economies are doing well.

Re:Against Economics by burntoutfire on Saturday November 16, 2019 @04:01AM (#21551710)
Interestingly, the Nordics also have super-high income taxes. I wonder what the VAT there would have to be to abolish income taxes. 50%? 60%?
Re:Against Economics by patricius on Saturday November 16, 2019 @05:03AM (#21551891)
Just checked the Danish national budget. Danish VAT brought in (or was estimated to bring in) 212 billion DKK in 2018. In comparison, tax levied on personal income brought in 562 billion.
Re:Against Economics by mdorazio on Saturday November 16, 2019 @05:13PM (#21555298)
That's fair. However, the proposal in the parent comment's link (and other proposals like it) is asking for a 17.5% consumption tax, which would be an absurd gift for the wealthy. Even for not-wealthy people like me, it would be a huge boon, while the middle class would get hosed.
Re:Against Economics by perl4ever on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:57AM (#21551401)
Well, you may not think 33% is ridiculously high, but you just wrote that it is in the second sentence. You say that 33% is 1/3 higher than Sweden, which is proverbial as an example of a highly taxed locale.
Re:Against Economics by Ididntdothis on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:08AM (#21551126)
Where is that money supposed to come from? To make this work people have to pay enough consumption tax so there is money for the payouts. Also, if you make these payments dependent on income level you pretty much have the problem of determining a taxable income which we have now.

Personally I think there is almost no way to make this work without being highly regressive.

Re:Against Economics by perl4ever on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:02AM (#21551422)
I don't think it makes any sense to tax everything and give back the money in the same proportions.

However, if you just tried the experiment, then to the extent it redistributed resources, it would be taking more money from those who consumed more at a given level of income, and giving it to those who consumed less.

So it would probably reduce consumer activity, and I don't know if that would be good for the economy in the long run. I don't think it would be a null-op though. It doesn't seem like a logical or mathematical contradiction.

Re:Against Economics by crazygringo on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:10PM (#21550739)
They can be progressive too: [1]

> A direct, personal consumption tax may take the form of an expenditure tax, that is, an income tax that deducts savings and investments, such as the Hall–Rabushka flat tax. A direct consumption tax may be called an expenditure tax, a cash-flow tax, or a consumed-income tax and can be flat or progressive...

> This form of tax applies to the difference between the income of an individual and the increase/decrease in his savings. Like the other consumption taxes, simple personal consumption taxes tend to be regressive with respect to income. However, because this tax applies on an individual basis, it can be made as progressive as a progressive personal income tax. Just as income tax rates increase with personal income, consumption tax rates increase with personal consumption. Economists from Milton Friedman to Edward Gramlich and Robert H. Frank have supported a progressive consumption tax.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumption_tax