This isn't an especially productive comment and I should probably delete it before I hit the reply button.
We love to complain about billionaires and hedge fund managers, but 80% of the income in this country accrues to a group of people that has entry-level college graduates at one end and top Google engineers at the other end.
The thing about the WSJ graphic that everybody made fun of: https://franklycurious.com/wp/2013/01/16/pity-the-rich/
...is that whatever people in that income range are really like, and however little sympathy they deserve, they are the golden goose that provides the lion's share of revenue for the government, so politically, there always has to be a game of chicken when tax increases are discussed. That's where the money is, so how much can be taken without harm to the economy?
I would bet that expropriating billionaires would have surprisingly little effect, but most of the people who would like to do it think six figures is rich too.
Folks at the top 30% mark still benefit from income inequality. (That is to say, they earn a larger share of national income than their share of the population.) If you tax the entire top 30% an average of 25% you could increase revenues by double what Warren's proposed wealth tax would bring in. (And you wouldn't risk driving businesses and jobs to Canada.)
This "Atlas will shrug" thing is trite posturing, not to say that there cannot be other drawbacks to populist revolutions.
From Matt Levine's column describing people threatening that Argentina will become "uninvestable" if it doesn't do what bondholders want:
"[Argentina] defaulted in 2001, imposed 70% haircuts in 2005 and 2010 restructurings, was in default on interest payments on the new restructured bonds from 2014 until 2016 due to legal disputes, finally cleaned up its act and returned to the international bond markets in 2016, and then in 2017 issued a hundred-year bond that international investors lined up to buy. Now those bonds trade at about 40 cents on the dollar, and international bond investors have the gall to be like “well if you default nine times we won’t lend to you a tenth time,” come on. They bought 100-year bonds one year after the last default ended! “There is a limit to what they will endure,” sure, but after two centuries of diligent searching Argentina hasn’t found it. "
Taxing away your capital is like selling your furniture for quick cash. You’re not skimming the fat, you’re cutting into muscle and bone.
As to Argentina, it had to offer a 7.9% interest rate to move those bonds in 2017. If we refinanced our national debt at those rates, we’d be paying $1.5 trillion a year on debt service, about what we spend on Medicare/Medicaid and defense out together.
It sounds like you're implying the secret is being nice to the big capitalists so they keep their capital in your country. But I don't think that's the way the world works, and it's precisely because most people think that's the way it works that most of the world cannot catch up.
Big companies in the US are largely owned by Vanguard and Blackrock and so on. They're already collectively owned by the people, despite all the talk about inequality. Prosperity depends on this system, not billionaires.
It's not that the US couldn't wreck things by acting like Argentina, but that people shouldn't pay attention to the super wealthy posturing. And the more they talk nonsense, the more they encourage radical actions, because true things can't be believed.
Clearly not everyone does. A big part of the heterodox economists even denies the existence of the notion of “efficient price” and rejects the concept of equilibrium.
What you call “everyone” is in fact the huge group of “Neoclassical synthesis” economists, which is super dominant nowadays, but it's not at all everyone.
how can this be implemented in a fashion that's non-regressive? income taxes in most countries are progressive, and consumption taxes are regressive.
For example, Exampleville institutes a consumption tax of 15%. Such a tax is regressive because consumption is usually a smaller proportion of a wealthy person's income than a poor person's income. To counteract this, Exampleville pays a monthly cash grant to all citizens and adjusts the payment level so that the cash grant is larger for the poor and smaller (or non-existent) for the wealthy.
See https://tax.purpleplans.org for an example of a real proposal that mimics this scheme.
I don't really see how these can be true given that, as you state, wealthy people spend a smaller portion (a lot smaller) of their income than do poor people.
To toss out some numbers, let's say the wealthy person makes $1M per year at a 35% effective income tax rate and the poor person makes $50K per year at an effective 10% income tax rate. Let's further suppose the wealthy person spends half their after-tax income, and the poor person spends all of it. Total tax revenue in this case would be $355K under the income scheme, but if we switch to a consumption tax, the tax revenue drops to $55,500. There's no amount of benefit allocation you can do to make up the difference. On top of that, the tax burden for the wealthy person (after offsetting for the benefit allocation) is still massively lower than under the income scheme, even if they get $0 in benefits. You'd have to raise the consumption tax ridiculously high (33% !) to get close, which will effectively discourage expenditures and encourage savings, pretty much destroying the US consumption-based economy.
I just can't see a realistic scenario where this setup isn't regressive or generally a bad idea. If you want to keep a progressive system but also eliminate income tax, we need to consider a wealth tax.
I don't think 33% is ridiculously high. VAT is 25% in Norway, Sweden, and Denmark, 27% in Hungary; and their economies are doing well.
Personally I think there is almost no way to make this work without being highly regressive.
However, if you just tried the experiment, then to the extent it redistributed resources, it would be taking more money from those who consumed more at a given level of income, and giving it to those who consumed less.
So it would probably reduce consumer activity, and I don't know if that would be good for the economy in the long run. I don't think it would be a null-op though. It doesn't seem like a logical or mathematical contradiction.
> A direct, personal consumption tax may take the form of an expenditure tax, that is, an income tax that deducts savings and investments, such as the Hall–Rabushka flat tax. A direct consumption tax may be called an expenditure tax, a cash-flow tax, or a consumed-income tax and can be flat or progressive...
> This form of tax applies to the difference between the income of an individual and the increase/decrease in his savings. Like the other consumption taxes, simple personal consumption taxes tend to be regressive with respect to income. However, because this tax applies on an individual basis, it can be made as progressive as a progressive personal income tax. Just as income tax rates increase with personal income, consumption tax rates increase with personal consumption. Economists from Milton Friedman to Edward Gramlich and Robert H. Frank have supported a progressive consumption tax.
That panel consisted of five American economists (Luigi Zingales is perhaps an immigrant but working in an American university). Two of them appeared to be om the Democrat's side and three aligning with the Republican party. That is not very ideologically diverse.
You lost me here, and revealed much about your thinking. Please explain how a “market” is anything other than steady state if all externalities are accounted for? Profit, by definition, means getting something for nothing. Without externalities, capitalism doesn’t exist.
I took micro-economics in highschool, and when discussing how trade is overall beneficial, they trotted out the old example of two countries, each producing bicycles and bananas.
The purpose of the exercise is to show that if each country focuses on one item and specializes on it, everyone benefits.
I always found that example to be deeply disturbing. If given a choice, who would actually prefer to live the banana country rather than the bicycle country? Even in highschool this silly example demonstrated the absurdity of classical economics.
Profit, I would say, is really the same thing as interest, i.e. return on capital, just with the connotation of being less predictable.
And interest, I would define not as something extra for doing nothing, but as a deferred payment for the labor that created the capital, which serves the important social purpose of rewarding people for deferring the consumption of the fruits of labor.
That's why people have not found a way of eliminating it, even though usury has been criticized for thousands of years.
1. Externalities can be positive. For example, the government builds roads, and doesn't account for the benefit to private industry on their books.
2. You're in a forum with a lot of software engineers; do you really believe that every new piece of software that brings $X in revenue necessarily costs society $X somehow? What mechanism causes this? Saying everything has externalities is far from saying they are always significant, or if significant, they are equal and opposite to the internalized value.
It simply doesn't exist, so it's not considered.
So economic theory is blatantly biased towards the accumulation of profit for shareholders, and blatantly biased against a realistic assessment of the social costs of those profits.
Simple example: AirBnB. Some people - mostly property owners - make money.
Other groups - people who need to rent property at a reasonable price - lose money.
You won't find the latter represented on the balance sheet. What looks like a potentially profitable operation actually turns out to have a huge social cost. Effectively it's moving money from a relatively unprivileged group to a relatively privileged group.
This is not a hypothetical example - it's a real problem in the area I'm living in, where the supply of long-term rental property has almost disappeared because owners can make more money from short-term tourist rentals.
Economics relies exclusively on these kinds of effects. There is no concept of "social profit" which is a guaranteed positive benefit for as many affected parties as possible.
And without that, economic theory becomes a vicious feedback loop that prioritises the redistribution of money over genuine value creation.
There are vast swathes of economic literature and theory dedicated to the study of external and social costs and how to best estimate and adjust for them. Claiming there is no concept of 'social profit' in economics is akin claiming there is no concept of testing in software development...
Also, I've noticed how actual economists speak of "economic profit". Whether you use the word "economic" or "social" or anything else, the modifier implies there is some deeper truth than whatever a given accountant writes down.
What people seem to disagree about is whether everything that is not illegal is permitted, or whether businesses should be expected to adhere to implicit codes of ethics and proper behavior without specific regulation.
It's not surprising that many people want a strict separation of responsibilities, but obviously governments are having an increasingly hard time keeping up, partly because of technology and partly because of politics.
I don't think that a society where people compete with each other and are restrained by laws is fundamentally new; that's been around for thousands of years. It's just that information technology is increasingly enabling the exploitation of discrepancies between actual laws and the common assumptions about what they do.
NPR did a podcast a few years ago on six policies it’s ideologically diverse panel of economists all agreed on: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-...
They are:
1&2) get rid of tax deductions for mortgage interest and healthcare
3) eliminate corporate taxes
4) replace payroll and income taxes with consumption taxes
5) impose carbon taxes
6) Legalize marijuana
Perhaps unsurprisingly, Europe, Canada, and Australia have all been moving in the above direction (at least slowly) over the past 30 years, marking a period of return to growth after decades of economic doldrums where they were uncompetitive with the USA.
There is even less disagreement when it gets into microeconomics. Everyone agrees that markets produce efficient prices so long as you account for externalities. So for example, an EPI study polled economists about the $15 minimum wage (who identified as Democrats 3:1 as compared with Republicans): https://www.johnlocke.org/update/what-do-economists-think-ab.... 75% thought it would negatively affect employment, and 84% agreed it would hurt youth employment.
Similarly, few economists support rent controls: https://www.economist.com/leaders/2019/09/19/rent-control-wi...
Indeed, the consensus on government price controls is so deep that, with the exception of isolated things like rent control and the minimum wage, where people don't perceive it as price regulation, even liberals don't really call for price regulation. That is remarkable, because price regulation was a feature of life until the 1970s. Airline tickets, freight trucking, phone bills--all were priced not based on markets, but based on bureaucrats picking numbers.