The consistent theme in all such cases is to make sure that those who have built value get non-forfeitable equity as a reward while those who need to prove themselves going forward get equity that can be forfeited.
If you have built true value, then, of $10M and you take your payment in stock that is 100% forfeitable, you set it up where you can be cheated out of all the value you have built with little or no legal recourse.
This is a HUGE red flag. I have seen founders do such deals and have begged and implored them, at the very least, to insist on 100% acceleration clauses in their employment arrangements should they be terminated without good cause. In the one case where the founders went through anyway without such protection, the company (a prominent public company) wound up terminating one of the main founders within months and all he got was a few crumbs for years worth of effort.
Check with a good M&A lawyer on this and then use your best judgment. It is ultimately your call, whatever the legal risks. But do it with open eyes and that means getting good help in assessing what those risks are.
To me that would be reason enough to make sure I negotiated the deal in such a way that if the company fires us that our stock will vest instantly.
> Any time someone tries to convince you to not consult your advisors, run away immediately.
No, get advisors anyway.
If the deal is good they might be lowballing them anyway and they're scared the other party finds out by how much.
What's good for one party may be great for the other!
There is this joke about the rights to an invention being sold for a relatively low amount, where the buyer confides after the deal to the seller 'we'd have bought it for ten times as much', whereupon the seller answers 'I'd have sold it for ten time less'.
Sure. By "reject the offer" I mean to reject that offer, not that the offer couldn't be revised to become acceptable.
If the deal is good they might be lowballing them anyway and they're scared the other party finds out by how much.
It might be a good deal, but trying to convince someone to not consult advisors indicates to me a certain lack of ethics. As a general rule I don't think it's good to make deals with people you don't trust.
Ok, in that case I would word it as 'we're taking it under consideration' to buy some time to regroup. And then respond after thinking things over with a counter-offer, not with a rejection.
> As a general rule I don't think it's good to make deals with people you don't trust.
As a general rule, I'd agree. But M&A is hardball and typically an acquisition of a 'goldfish' is not going to be done by explain patiently how they're actually worth 4 times as much and by educating them. It may come in very handy that they have not managed to attract advisors savvy enough to guide them through this.
I'm actually a bit confused about how a company could get as far as 7 figure turnover and an 8 figure buy-out offer while still being this green business-wise.
Typically by the time you get that far you've got an excellent relationship with your corporate lawyer and a tax advisor.
We're definitely green as far as this stuff goes but that's because we've existed in our niche bubble for the last 5-10 years and never really had much reason to go speak to anyone besides our general counsel and CPA. None of us have any business training beyond what we've picked up along the way.
Play it careful!
I was in a very similar situation to you recently. Is there any way we can have a chat ?
That's an, er, interesting rule. A big part of modern financial and legal infra-structure is designed so that we can make business with people we don't trust. If you do business only with you people you can trust then you might as well live like a hermit.
For example, if the "losing" party on an options trade can't pay up, the exchange pays for them. The exchanges and brokers set margin requirements to reduce the risk of non-payers.
In most cases, you're absolutely right. With investment bankers, completely different.
Investment bankers will turn this into a process, try to pick up multiple bidders, and add to the complexity of trying to get the deal done. In general, bankers (not lawyers!) can be harmful to a deal.
They could be telling him that they're in for a simple deal, but if it gets complicated, that's not worth it to them.
To me, this would be enough to immediately reject the offer. I don't believe in doing deals which make my worst case worse unless I will be in a position where I can prevent the worst case from happening -- and it doesn't sound like you'd have any way to avoid getting screwed here.
they've expressed to us that involving bankers would 'change the tone' of the discussion, whatever that means
Any time someone tries to convince you to not consult your advisors, run away immediately. If they think they're offering you a good deal, they should be encouraging you to talk to everybody.