News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by dr_dshiv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @09:12AM (#21535455)
Really true. We need more examples of people completing PhDs in 1-2 years because they've already done the research and written most of the thesis. It's totally possible.
Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by ISL on Thursday November 14, 2019 @10:06AM (#21535910)
That misses the learning process in a PhD program. A PhD is not just the thesis work, it is also the education and mentorship that is generally necessary to become an expert in both a broad field and a specialty.
Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by pergadad on Thursday November 14, 2019 @10:45AM (#21536282)
Why shouldn't it be easy(ier) to get the PhD when you've already worked and published for 10 years in the field?
Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by diffeomorphism on Thursday November 14, 2019 @11:05AM (#21536496)
That seems like a completely different question.

Suppose somebody does a brilliant Master's thesis and afterwards quickly writes two more good papers. He/She could get a PhD immediately at that point as far as research is concerned, but would benefit from waiting a bit longer and also getting mentorship etc. .

A person who worked and published for 10 years for all purposes already was doing PhD work for 10 years and thus can more or less staple some works together to get PhD whenever they want to.

Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by mygo on Thursday November 14, 2019 @02:06PM (#21538304)
People can go their whole lifetime without making novel contributions to a field. If an arbitrary time limit is required to have a PhD, I feel like it probably discounts the implications of what kind of individual one needs to be to make novel contributions at a young age in less time.
Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by jasonhong on Thursday November 14, 2019 @10:24AM (#21536074)
Part of the reason it typically takes 5-6 years to complete a PhD (in computer science at least) is because it takes a long time to learn the methods, the skills, and the large body of past work, as well as just becoming a member of the research community (via attending workshops and conferences, publishing paper, and reviewing).

It's possible to complete a PhD in 2-3 years, but this also typically leaves no room for exploration or any kinds of errors. At CMU, the only examples I know of were people who were on leave from the military and had a hard stop after 3 years to return.

Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by dr_dshiv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @04:20PM (#21539562)
Also CMU alum. Why anyone would WANT to rush a PhD, I don't know. I had to finish faster than my peers because I started a business half way through -- and I was either going to complete in 6 months or never. So I finished up in a hurry. I am a tenure track professor & CEO -- which works so long as you don't care about anything at all. But that's separate.

My point is, and I'm four beers in, is that my head of data science is so good, he has been mentored by me for years (fwiw), and he has published a lot -- I feel he is the perfect candidate for completing a PhD asap. I think he needs two years for acculturation.

In that paradigm, smart folk in industry could publish papers and then take 2 years to get a doctorate --- and I think the world would be better for it.

Re:Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulenc... by treis on Thursday November 14, 2019 @10:26AM (#21536088)
But where will labs find cheap labor?