(I thought Blu-Ray was an example, but a quick Wikipedia check says Blu-Ray was announced 2 months before the DVD Forum voted to develop HD-DVD.)
They've won a few, too; most notably, 3.5" floppies (where Apple crowned the winner by choosing Sony for Mac).
I can see why they keep playing, the odds are considerably better than in the lottery, even if the price of the tickets is higher.
If Sony had made a cheap PC drive that took minidisk it would have been as popular as floppies and been a real selling point for their PCs.
What mattered is whether it was easy to get pirated MP3s from the PC to the player. Fiddling around with optical digital out compared to the much simpler USB seems backwards.
MiniDisks might well have been superior to cassettes but compared to MP3 players? Ugh.
MiniDisks would have been pretty cool (at least for a short time) if you could have plugged them into a USB port.
You could have a handful of disks with 80mins of HQ music on each whereas the MP3 players of the time were either very expensive (like the first harddisk iPod) or had so little space you had to chose a few songs for each trip.
I can understand how MiniDisk could have looked a bit more attractive a year or two earlier but not really in 2001 or 2002.
The op doesn't mean that iTunes would be used for selling media. Rather it'd be your personal media player for everything like AVI/Mpeg/etc. like VLC is.
I don't know how well iTunes can do this as is, but that's what he's arguing for.
They didn't decide to limit the iPod to 32Kb/s playback to protect sales of their CD players
After the Betamax debacle it decided it would win the next format war by owning studios.
That meant that anything it built for the consumer also had to be good for the studio. So for example it launched the excellent minidisk player (a 76Mb minifloppy) with better than MP3 quality when MP3 players were 32Mb for twice the price.
But it refused to release the minidisk drives for computers, because that would lead to piracy - so the only way to get music on the units was to buy all your albums again on minidisk (the studio's preferred option !) or record them on the microphone in. Then they did the same again with the PSP.
Suppose Apple had decided to ensure the success of the iPhone, not by making it great, but by buying a cell carrier - then limiting your calls to other iPhone users.