News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by PaulHoule on Friday January 28, 2011 @02:43PM (#2153221)
For one thing, eFreedom.com actually answers your question. This is different from ExpertsExchange (which promises you might get an answer if you fork over $, yeah right) or eHow which only sometimes answers your question, and if it does, does the worst possible job that could possibly be done.

Community sites, at least in their early phases, need to focus on getting people to put content in more than they need to focus on making it easy for people to get it out. Delicious is the classic example: it's a roach motel which makes it very easy to put your bookmarks in, but doesn't provide a useful browsing interface for your and other people's bookmarks (other than having a list of recently hot for various tags.)

Particularly in the semantic age I think there's a lot of room for remixing CC content to improve browsing and discoverability.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by Waywocket on Friday January 28, 2011 @07:39PM (#2154118)
>For one thing, eFreedom.com actually answers your question. This is different from ExpertsExchange (which promises you might get an answer if you fork over $, yeah right)

Not sure if I'm taking you too literally, but Experts Exchange does answer your question without having to pay (scroll down).

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by rhizome on Friday January 28, 2011 @03:05PM (#2153308)
I don't understand this. Are you saying that efreedom adds original content to that which they scrape? I avoid them like the plague, but my exposure has taught me that they are merely reprinting SO content with crappy formatting. Not much of a value-add in my eyes.
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by PaulHoule on Friday January 28, 2011 @05:11PM (#2153736)
No, I'm not really defending eFreedom. However, I think that sites that are ~like~ eFreedom in some ways to be useful. For instance, large scale text mining could create things that are more than the some of their parts.

For example, I think within 10-20 years at the most we'll have systems that can decompose text into facts and then reassemble it into 'original' text.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by rhizome on Friday January 28, 2011 @07:40PM (#2154119)
Actually there are link farms that are doing exactly that in order to appear to robots to be original text. However, it's just chunks of text "mined" into a mass of subject-focussed sentence fragments. That's the thing, the race to the bottom is: original content is scraped without improvement in order to pay someone else via ads, and original content is generated without regard to coherence in order to pay someone via ads.

Two ways to do this: you have good content either left intact (no value-add) or rearranged or otherwised structurally corrupted in order to appear to be a different/better answer (value-minus), or you have advertisers being led to believe their ads are showing on relevant content, when it's really just a jumble of random words loosely oriented around a concept. "The dog was dog walking. Dog food always is in the grocery store. RALEY's. It dogged him for years..." so on and so forth.

On one hand users are being defrauded and on the other, the advertisers/affiliates. There is no defense for eFreedom, nabble, mail-archive, and their ilk. They are bad people, bad for business and bad for the internet. I sincerely believe this.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by logjam on Friday January 28, 2011 @03:09PM (#2153322)
Well, I'm not trying to belabor the point and maybe I haven't looked enough on eFreedom, but I don't see any original content there, it's just a scrape. Even the "related links" is scraped.

I still don't get the value in that. Where is the "content in" (which I take to mean content generation rather than duplication) that you mention?

I agree with you about the other sites.