Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by JediWing on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @08:54AM
(#21514054)
If the finding of frivolity was separate from the verdict, though, it could work. Set the standard as, on a unanimous verdict for the defendant, the jury may decide the case was frivolous on the standard that "no reasonable jury would find the facts as applied to the law to render a verdict in favor of the plantif". It would cause greater scrutiny but cases that have merit would still go forward.
Edit: Also the lawyer would not being charged money to work, they would be getting fined for wasting the court and jury's time. That's like saying a contingency lawyer is working without pay: well yeah, but it's factored into the cost of business. There are still chances for high payout but now there is also a much needed downside.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by papln on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @01:21PM
(#21516554)
That's how it works today. A party can claim legal expenses.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by lscharen on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @09:33AM
(#21514381)
> If the finding of frivolity was separate from the verdict
Isn't this somewhat handled by awarding "token damages" of $1 or similar? The litigating party "won", but it was determined that they were not actually harmed as claimed.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by mr__y on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @11:48AM
(#21515570)
>If the finding of frivolity was separate from the verdict
this on the other hand further increases costs of those frivolous cases requiring a second trial to test frivolousness of the case
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by JediWing on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @03:10PM
(#21517622)
I would think this could be simply another (probably quick) round of deliberations by the jury, not a whole other trial.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C...
by lawlessone on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @09:10AM
(#21514170)
>the finding of frivolity was separate from the verdict, though,
Oh ok, as long as it isn't applied to every case.
nobody would take jobs then unless the chance of winning was 99%.
The lawyer would also in those case being getting charged money to work.