Re:The FCC Has Fined Robocallers $208M, Collected $6,790
by dredmorbius on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:25PM
(#21510673)
Thank you.
Trust is one element. Common weal, the sense of acting in the common good, is the more critical element.
Trust here is a mechanism, rather than and end goal itself. Through the undermining of trust in a system for the public benefit, the common good is harmed.
Your counterexample becomes far less difficult when phrased equivalently:
Through the undermining of trust within a system opposed to the public benefit, the common good is increased.
TL;DR: you've confused ends and means.
Though generally, common good is extremely reliant on a strong social trust fabric.
(As to the question of whether or not "common good" / "common weal" is an appropriate goal value of a system, that's another discussion. I've elected to adopt for now the general idea that it is, but there are varying points of view on this point, and cases in which there is no globally beneficial outcome. Most especially where some are disadvantaged such that others, any, might survive. See also: "lifeboat ethics".)
Trust is one element. Common weal, the sense of acting in the common good, is the more critical element.
Trust here is a mechanism, rather than and end goal itself. Through the undermining of trust in a system for the public benefit, the common good is harmed.
Your counterexample becomes far less difficult when phrased equivalently:
Through the undermining of trust within a system opposed to the public benefit, the common good is increased.
TL;DR: you've confused ends and means.
Though generally, common good is extremely reliant on a strong social trust fabric.
(As to the question of whether or not "common good" / "common weal" is an appropriate goal value of a system, that's another discussion. I've elected to adopt for now the general idea that it is, but there are varying points of view on this point, and cases in which there is no globally beneficial outcome. Most especially where some are disadvantaged such that others, any, might survive. See also: "lifeboat ethics".)