News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:11PM (#21502089)
A friend of mine did some freelance Japanese-to-English translation for a video game you've heard of some time ago. Her source material consisted, in entirety, of an Excel spreadsheet with one column called "Japanese" (filled) and another called "English" (empty). That's it: she never even saw the game in question, and wasn't familiar with the series in general either. And then we wonder why the translations are bad...
Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by laurieg on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:26PM (#21502146)
This is maddeningly common, even these days.

Unfortunately, many mono-lingual people don't realise that language does not map perfectly from one word/phrase to another.

When I used to translate people in the office would come up and ask me "What's xxxxx in English?". I would reply "Well, what situation is this?". More often than not they would switch off at this point.

Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by wolf550e on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:28PM (#21507336)
There used to be a requirement that anyone receiving an academic degree has to demonstrate proficiency in a second language. The purpose is not so you could use the second language, instead the purpose is that learning a second language forces you to understand that all the details of your own native language are arbitrary, understand the abstract notion of "language" separately from your native one, and as part of that understand that many parts of your native language encode pieces of your native culture and are not universal, and thus cannot be translated directly. This understanding of how language works was part of what made you a "college educated" person, who has a better understanding of the world.

Has this requirement been dropped, or are diploma mills able to graduate students who can speak a little Spanish but do not understand the important bits about how human languages work?

Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by ljm on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:10PM (#21507134)
I’m not fluently bi-lingual but this is my go-to answer whenever someone’s asked me how to say a certain thing in English, when they’re writing or figuring out how to talk to someone else. My questions usually would be:

1. How would you say it in [original language?]. This is on the off-chance I know what they’re talking about, or can reasonably guess. Sometimes this is good enough that they get what they want out of it. Also, I get to learn a little bit more of their language, if it’s one that I’ve also learned a bit about :)

2. What are you trying to say/what’s the context? This is to get around the X/Y problem, because usually the question isn’t so simple.

It’s rare to have a straight up, correct answer the moment someone asks how to translate. And if it does come up so easily, they were already speaking good English in the first place. Just needed the vocab.

Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by pdpi on Monday November 11, 2019 @07:13AM (#21504159)
I'm more or less bilingual (Portuguese/English), and it annoys me to no end how often I have the exact word I want, but it's in the "wrong" language. Often, the alternatives in the "right" language just lack the appropriate connotation/subtext.
Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by shifto on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:18AM (#21505479)
I feel this about language in general. Sometimes it takes way too many words or sentences to convey what I mean.

I think it's time we develop some cool telepathy tech.

Re:Games with Famous Bad Translations into Japanese by patio11 on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:49AM (#21502479)
This is also far-too-frequently the market standard for translation of "substantially everything else", including for things where incorrect translation does not normally result in fun internet memes as the worst possible consequence.