News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by paulddraper on Sunday November 10, 2019 @06:39PM (#21500935)
Correct. It's a matter of semantics. Though "50-year-old internet" could only refer to ARPANET.

As an aside, English style guides formerly required "an internet"/"the Internet" distinction, however that has been changing in recent years to lowercase "internet" in both cases.

In school I was marked down for writing "the internet", and now English professors say that is in fact the right way to do it. Not even English is immune to versioning.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by jimmaswell on Sunday November 10, 2019 @06:54PM (#21501027)
English teachers are generally petulant pedantic crocks anyway. We'd probably have more/better writers without them ruining the subject for people as they do.
Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by aidenn0 on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:38AM (#21502703)
It's interesting that you say this. I find that I had about as many good/great English teachers as I did in other subjects, but there weren't many mediocre English teachers.

I had a math teacher who literally never got up from his desk, visibly counting down the years until he could collect his pension. I had similarly checked out history and science teachers.

The not-good English teachers I had, however, seemed mad at the world and out for blood. The name written on an assignment had a stronger correlation with the grade than the content, so the only path to an A was to stroke the teacher's ego

I even had a pair of friends do a blinded experiment to confirm this. They each would type out their assignment, then would call each other and flip a coin; Heads they write their own name, Tails they write the other person's name.

In another occurrence, I had gotten on a teacher's bad-side and so the grades on my papers had a hard ceiling of a C. I asked my dad for advice, and it was roughly: Talk to the teacher, apologize for "not applying myself" offer to redo back assignments. She didn't even have me redo any back assignments, but suddenly I was getting As and Bs again.

Another occurance: I got my first paper of the class back with the only markings on it "58, almost an A paper." Here was the dialog that ensued:

----

Me: How many points is this out of?

Teacher: 100

Me: Is the class graded on a curve?

Teacher: No, straight 90/80/70

Me: So how is 58 "almost an A paper?"

Teacher: Well, just a few tweaks and it would be great,[encouraging tone] I'm sure you'll do well in my course!

Me: ...

----

To this day I still have not figured out what was going on in that teacher's mind. It was a rare real-world moment where I honestly couldn't tell if I was being trolled or not.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by ianai on Monday November 11, 2019 @06:58AM (#21504058)
You probably needed to stroke her, his, or it’s ego again.

I had a math professor do that to me in undergrad. Fear of his type led me to leave the field entirely after that degree. Just way too much power over me with little to nothing I could do.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by squiggleblaz on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:42AM (#21505173)
it's = it is. You were looking for "its"

gratuitous correction because of the topic. hth hand.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by ianai on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:24AM (#21505534)
autocomplete made me do it.
Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by dijit on Sunday November 10, 2019 @06:52PM (#21501015)
That’s because it was seen as a name of a product. Now it is a common idea/service.

Think “couch” vs Ikea.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by skissane on Sunday November 10, 2019 @09:28PM (#21501667)
I thought it was about proper noun vs common noun.

"an internet" is common noun – an abstract concept of which many particular implementations could exist.

"the Internet" is a proper noun – one specific implementation of that concept. Right now, the only one of any significance, but that may not last forever.

If humans someday colonise Mars – TCP/IP is not suitable for interplanetary use. We'll likely end up with two separate TCP/IP internets, one on Earth and one on Mars, with non-IP protocols used to communicate between them. The Earth-based one would be descendant of "the Internet" we are using right now, the Mars-based one would be a new internet.

(By the time we colonise Mars, I wouldn't be surprised if TCP has been wholly replaced by QUIC, so instead of TCP/IP we'd all be using QUIC/UDP/IP.)

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by jdietrich on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:42PM (#21502202)
>If humans someday colonise Mars – TCP/IP is not suitable for interplanetary use.

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc5325/

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by paulddraper on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:14AM (#21504937)
> TCP/IP is not suitable for interplanetary use.

I'm not sure that's true.

The congestion algorithms/parameters may have to be updated, just like they were when WiFi and cellular came along, but the protocol itself is quite robust.

Re:The Rising Threat of Digital Nationalism by skissane on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:30PM (#21508023)
TCP is unsuitable for interplanetary links, due to the massive round trip times (e.g. Earth-Mars RTT is between 3 minutes and 22 minutes.) Technically TCP could work, but the performance in practice would be atrocious. Wifi and cellular aren't comparable because (when working) they don't have RTTs measured in minutes.

That's why for interplanetary use IETF has been developing an alternative protocol suite called DTN. Unlike TCP/IP, DTN is not real-time, it is based on store-and-forward of messages (conceptually similar to UUCP.)

https://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/dtn/documents/