News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by klipt on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:33AM (#21498657)
> they knew their parents would get them into the union

Ironic that union membership would become just another form of heritable wealth.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by chaostheory on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:21PM (#21500563)
It feels just like rent control. They’re obviously not equivalent, but they’re similar in that you’re just changing the rules for how people are prioritized for access to finite resources; you’re not really increasing availability of said resources
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by shams93 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:28PM (#21499004)
It has in Hollywood especially things like key grip jobs are passed down generation to generation. Having none of this in LA I spent half my working life homeless with a master's degree in Socal the economy is all about what you inherit not what you do the system has treated me Lowe than a dog my entire life despite my skills and education I'm simply someone you hit with cars and leave for dead
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Scoundreller on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:34PM (#21499044)
Yeah, I’m fine with questioning heritable wealth, but it should be across the board.

We shouldn’t chop up the middle class’ heritable tokens while letting the upper class keep theirs.

That just makes things worse.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Nasrudith on Sunday November 10, 2019 @07:02PM (#21501067)
Not all heritability is identical nor are their side effects. A literal caste system is worse than generational wealth transfer.

While one may gave an advantage to their off spring the previous effectively restricts others and is way unhealthier for society.

Just treating it like factions where just whose team is good for isn't a very healthy approach.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by austhrow743 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:47PM (#21501976)
We shouldn't avoid chopping up one form of inheritable wealth just because we can't target all of it effectively or all of it at once though.

It's a great evil that needs to be stomped on viciously.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by jayd16 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @01:36PM (#21499395)
Hollywood is about who you know. That would be the same without the unions.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Gibbon1 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @01:45PM (#21499449)
Basically every industry is like that. Leads to my comment that at a job you get paid in money, experience, and connections. People fret about being underpaid and don't consider how bad it is being chintzed on the others. Especially the last one.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by whiddershins on Sunday November 10, 2019 @01:26PM (#21499324)
I’m sorry to hear that you are feeling so upset about this.

I’m pretty sure it doesn’t seems that way to most of the people, most of the time.

Maybe somehow you can get to a place where your influence on your fate seems more real?

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by closeparen on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:40PM (#21499086)
Is it ironic? Restricting the labor supply is the core of a union's ability to demand higher wages for its members.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by zozbot234 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @02:17PM (#21499607)
Even if we were to accept that, there are many ways of "restricting the labor supply"; and nepotism is just about the least efficient you could think of. If you're going to "restrict" access to something, it should be done by rewarding individual merit and competence.

(At least that would imply a pretty nice improvement in labor conditions - no more workers being flattened by containers! Which is also the kind of thing unions typically care about.)

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by jcims on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:55PM (#21500723)
> If you're going to "restrict" access to something, it should be done by rewarding individual merit and competence.

It should be the case no doubt, but often isn’t because there’s less to leverage. Sometimes you need a favor, you know? But if you give a job to Joe Schmuckus that he could get anywhere, whats the motivation to do you a solid?

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by closeparen on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:31PM (#21502161)
There are at least three propositions in your comment:

- Efficiency is implicitly good.

- Material rewards can/should be allocated according to some measure of individual merit and competence.

- Meritocracy and nepotism are distinct.

I tend to agree, but these statements are at least controversial (if not obviously wrong) within the political consciousness that does labor organizing these days. Read Jacobin sometime, you'll see vehement opposition. Internalizing the violent logic of capitalism, etc.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by clairity on Sunday November 10, 2019 @01:38PM (#21499410)
it's not wealth, it's advantage. once you get the job handed down to you, you still have to do the work to get the money, unlike wealth.

not saying jobs should be doled out that way, but it's quite different to get a chance at future income vs. having it mounded in your lap without lifting a finger.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by zozbot234 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @02:14PM (#21499592)
That's just as true with wealth. Sure, you could spend your wealth down, but that's like eating your seed corn; very few actually do that, because it means you're not wealthy anymore afterwards.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by skybrian on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:34PM (#21501916)
Uh, the money grows by itself if properly invested. Investing in an index fund hardly counts as working.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by dsfyu404ed on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:51PM (#21500399)
I think you're vastly over-estimating how much you actually need to do your job to stick around in a workplace heavy on connections/nepotism. I have stories from state government that are almost beyond belief. Elected officials using backwater departments as a place to give jobs to people they owe favors is a recurring scandal in my state. Said people get a six figure salary just for showing up, sometimes not even that, somebody noticing lots of people paid for not showing up is how the "scandal" often starts. Don't get me wrong, a lot of the people who got their jobs by knowing someone do their jobs but a disturbing number don't.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by drcross on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:24PM (#21500582)
This is why we should be thankful for pure capitalism. Inefficient companies should go bust and overtaken by those who are more efficient.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by goldcd on Sunday November 10, 2019 @07:44PM (#21501271)
Advantage can be pretty synonymous with wealth though. Could be your dad happens to run the "People's Industry X" or simply you inherited a role that "X many people have to hold for the production to be not shut down".
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by klipt on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:07PM (#21500209)
> it's not wealth, it's advantage. once you get the job handed down to you, you still have to do the work to get the money, unlike wealth.

So like a taxi medallion. Which when sold on a free market had (before Uber, in NYC) a market value on the order of a million dollars.

That's a pretty huge advantage to pass down.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by icebraining on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:41PM (#21500352)
No, a taxi medallion could be rented out to drivers. For example, for a period Michael Cohen owned 34 NYC medallions.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by klipt on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:01PM (#21500445)
Right, but the reason it has value is that it's tied to a high paying job where the supply of labor is limited. (Which is why, as soon as Uber flooded the labor side, the value of taxi medallions plummeted.)

If longshoremen were allowed to buy and sell their union memberships (say in the form of "union member medallions") they'd probably have similar value to taxi medallions.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by erik_seaberg on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:46PM (#21500677)
You can’t make a loyal mafia out of just anyone who shows up.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by refurb on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:34AM (#21502687)
It’s not that different than communist systems that result in a class of people who leverage their position to enrich themselves and their families.

The problem isn’t the economic system, the problem is human nature.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by ZhuanXia on Sunday November 10, 2019 @03:53PM (#21500132)
Rents are by their nature exclusionary; it is hardly surprising they became hereditary rights. They are called guilds after all.