Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by dmos62 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:35PM
(#21493741)
US military tested airships extensively. They proved to have considerable advantages in certain naval operation roles. It all ended with the airship aircraft carriers (you read that right) crashing in separate accidents. They turned out to be extremely difficult to control (not crash) in extreme weather.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by zrail on Saturday November 09, 2019 @03:12PM
(#21494007)
In the 1930s, to be clear. Technology has advanced considerably.
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by TylerE on Saturday November 09, 2019 @05:11PM
(#21494759)
Unfortunately physics has not.
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by CapitalistCartr on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:15PM
(#21495713)
Northrop completed the first flying wing bomber in 1947, the YB-49. But flying wings are inherently unstable and there were two fatal crashes. Ultimately, criminal politics crashed it harder, but the B-2 is a direct version of it.
But now we have computer control stabilizing it in flight, making it vastly easier and safer to fly. Of course Physics hasn't changed, but advances in technology matter.
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by TylerE on Saturday November 09, 2019 @09:08PM
(#21495960)
Yes, but the problem with airships isn't control - it's just that the useful mass fraction is tiny. You need something the size of a container ship to lift a few tons of net payload.
The only way that might ever change is if we develop a form of nanotubes strong enough to allow use of a vacuum rather than gas.
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by dTal on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:49AM
(#21505223)
Nanotubes wouldn't really help much either I'm afraid. Hydrogen is 7% the mass of air, so even with a vacuum the best you can do is 7% more lifting power. Our only real hope is to terraform the Earth to have greater air density at sea level...
Re:Airships could return to our crowded skies
by TylerE on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:07PM
(#21507793)
That's true, but vacuum has one big advantage: You can generate it in flight, whereas with lifting gas if you have to vent it you're NEVER getting it back.
Besides, even at just 7%, if the Hindenburg had been "filled" with vacuum instead of hydrogen, that would have been an additional 37,000lbs of payload capacity, which would have almost tripled it's lift capability (21,000lbs as flown).
Additionally, helium, which is probably the only gas the public will accept, is almost double the density of hydrogen, and we have a limited supply of it.