Re:Show HN: k3sup – get Kubernetes and helm apps in
by sandGorgon on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:31AM
(#21491412)
This is so cool. Two requests:
1. Can you make k3sup available in a docker image ? Shell script based installation is a bit iffy for most people (cannot version, lock, update easily). It may also make it possible to use Fargate to run k3s..which would be awesome.
2. Can you bake in metrics and setup HPA by default ? This is the most confusing part for most people. If you bake in advanced scaling stuff like AWS k8s node termination handler (https://twitter.com/schmutze/status/1192869032262684672?s=19) you will have my everlasting gratitude !
Re:Show HN: k3sup – get Kubernetes and helm apps in
by gatherhunterer on Saturday November 09, 2019 @06:24PM
(#21495232)
Kind (Kubernetes-in-Docker) is already around and it is somewhat of a niche use case. Minikube also exists to satisfy most of the use cases for single-node clusters on a development machine.
Docker does not automatically make software safe. If you do not know what is in the image you should assume that it is malicious as Docker images can gain root access to the host machine. I don’t see how a Docker image would be less “iffy” in terms of security or ease-of-use.
This is just a think wrapper for K3s, which already has a one-step installation and immediately provides a kubeconfig. Relying on this seems like unnecessary tech debt. It is simpler to just go straight to Rancher for K3s.
Re:Show HN: k3sup – get Kubernetes and helm apps in
by ypcx on Saturday November 09, 2019 @06:04AM
(#21490807)
Nice project. A related plug: For locally-run VMs, I can do `./hyperctl.sh install net dhcp hosts image master node1 node2` and be on local multi-node k8s on Hyperkit, in, I don't know, 5 minutes. Similarly for Windows, `.\hyperctl.ps1 install net hosts image master node1 node2` for Hyper-V. This would create 3 local machines, but you can also just only specify `master` which will then be auto-tainted for normal scheduling.
Then you can do `hyperctl.[sh/ps1] docker helm3 repo` and you have a local docker build & k8s helm deploy system for testing. (*docker w/o the docker desktop app!)
Re:Show HN: k3sup – get Kubernetes and helm apps in
by outime on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:04AM
(#21491273)
A basic install isn’t that difficult nowadays as there’s some good tooling around. The big problem is the subsequent maintenance and that’s why managed K8s is so popular.
Re:Show HN: k3sup – get Kubernetes and helm apps in
by atmosx on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:28PM
(#21493707)
I used k3sup last week to setup a 5 node RPi3 cluster. Thanks for the nice tool! Worked like a charm! I wanted to write a tutorial on what’s needed for a proper setup, since I am using buster and arm64v8, but not time.
1. Can you make k3sup available in a docker image ? Shell script based installation is a bit iffy for most people (cannot version, lock, update easily). It may also make it possible to use Fargate to run k3s..which would be awesome.
2. Can you bake in metrics and setup HPA by default ? This is the most confusing part for most people. If you bake in advanced scaling stuff like AWS k8s node termination handler (https://twitter.com/schmutze/status/1192869032262684672?s=19) you will have my everlasting gratitude !
Docker does not automatically make software safe. If you do not know what is in the image you should assume that it is malicious as Docker images can gain root access to the host machine. I don’t see how a Docker image would be less “iffy” in terms of security or ease-of-use.
This is just a think wrapper for K3s, which already has a one-step installation and immediately provides a kubeconfig. Relying on this seems like unnecessary tech debt. It is simpler to just go straight to Rancher for K3s.
Then you can do `hyperctl.[sh/ps1] docker helm3 repo` and you have a local docker build & k8s helm deploy system for testing. (*docker w/o the docker desktop app!)
Worked flawlessly for me so far. https://github.com/youurayy/hyperctl