News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by qwerty456127 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:08PM (#21479676)
Looks nice yet I feel like reading the Bible or whatever alike in a single translation makes little sense. IMHO viewing the originals + all the possible translations for every word + a number of translations to a number of languages in parallel is a must if you want to know what was actually written there. G-d bless.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by Karunamon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:43PM (#21479801)
Agreed. Interlinears are essential to get the full sense of any given passage. That's one of the reason there are so many bible translations, it's half written in a language that demands a reader of the native language insert letters contextually to arrive at the correct word (Aramaic) and half written in a language that's the colloquial example for something hard to understand (Greek).

I bought a subscription to Logos (Faithlife) a while back - it's some amazing software, and the books they sell have a, frankly, jaw-dropping amount of cross-references linked both into most any bible translation you could imagine, but other books as well.

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by irrational on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:36AM (#21482494)
There isn't very much Aramaic in the bible (parts of the book of Daniel and a smattering of verses in a few other books), I think you mean Hebrew. And no letters are inserted. You are thinking of the vowels, but the vowels are not letters, they are represented by a point system. And the Hebrew Bible if fully pointed. It is just modern Hebrew for adult readers that is not pointed (things like the newspaper and novels).
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by steve19 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:11PM (#21479693)
A translation is basically offloading all that to a team of scholars.

Other religious books may have been standardized so you can't compare different versions, but that does not diminish the versions studied today.

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by jorangreef on Friday November 08, 2019 @05:49AM (#21481198)
"A translation is basically offloading all that to a team of scholars."

Especially a brilliant translation like the ESV.

For example, Peter J. Williams (https://www.crossway.org/authors/peter-j-williams/) is just one of the PHDs who worked on the ESV Translation Oversight Committee. I once listened to a talk Peter gave at St Helens' Bishopsgate (https://www.st-helens.org.uk/resources/talk/51892/audio/) on how translating has improved his confidence in the textual reliability of the manuscripts. I've never heard someone speak so well before.

It's true that reading more than one translation helps, but I find that even just reading a formal equivalence translation such as the ESV, together with a dynamic equivalence transalation such as the old NIV, will get you 98% of the way there, and there are commentaries to help with the rest.

It would be a real shame to never read the Bible in your mother tongue, when so many translators have sacrificed so much to make that possible, simply because one feels it can't be understood unless "you read it in a 100 languages". I think the question then becomes, well, do I want to read and truly understand, am I open-minded or am I just filibustering?

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by flounders on Sunday November 10, 2019 @08:16AM (#21497833)
I took a year of Biblical Greek and Hebrew in college. The main reason I think it is required for Theology majors is to show that the translators did a really good job most of the time. There are times knowing both languages has helped clear up a passage, but comparing various translations and reading what other translators have to say about the passage would probably be just as good for that.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by bluGill on Friday November 08, 2019 @08:21AM (#21481917)
Best is reading the originals directly. As I recall the bible is written in 5 languages, so learn those 5 to fluency and read that. Since most of us don't have the time to learn 5 languages well enough to understand subtle details we rely on translations.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by speeder on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:26AM (#21482410)
Problem is... we DON'T have the originals.

Something few people know:

The greek translation of the old testament, might be more accurate than the hebrew version.

The reason is that the complete hebrew version we have (I mean, ignoring fragments found in archeological digs recently), was written about 700 years after Jesus, by a group of people that were strongly biased against the idea that Jesus was the Messiah, also their version has explicit editor notes, and commentary, and obvious errors (for example "alphabetic" psalms that are missing letters, while the greek translation still have them).

Some of my favourite translations are ones that did research to find what was probably closest to originals, instead of reliance on the language of manuscripts, there are even some ethiopian texts (in ethiopian language!) that are reputed to be more reliable than more recent texts that are supposed to be copies of originals in original language.

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by jorangreef on Friday November 08, 2019 @03:59PM (#21486681)
"Problem is... we DON'T have the originals."

That's a common misunderstanding of textual criticism, when it comes to the Bible, often peddled by pop-scholars writing for the masses, who make out that the sheer number of minor textual variants is a major stumbling block in getting back to the original text.

On the contrary, the more copies you have, the better. It's the same with Google, you hope they make thousands of backups, and at different points in time.

With textual criticism, you don't need the originals if you have thousands of copies to compare, in different languages.

Likewise with ancient history, you don't need to have been there, to know that an event happened in the past.

I would encourage you to read people like Bruce M. Metzger, F.F. Bruce, or Paul Barnett if you want to understand the logic of ancient history and textual criticism, or if you want to balance your perspective.

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by flounders on Sunday November 10, 2019 @07:59AM (#21497796)
I found this paper by Maurice A. Robinson very informative on the subject, but he does advocate for Byzantine priority. http://rosetta.reltech.org/TC/vol06/Robinson2001.html At the very least it's a good introduction to New Testament textual criticism, and it goes further in depth on your points.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by irrational on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:27AM (#21482421)
What are the five language? There is Hebrew and Aramaic in the OT (though Aramaic is a close to Biblical Hebrew as Spanish is to Portuguese, so it's not very hard to pick up one when you know the other). In the NT we have Greek and a smattering of Aramaic/Hebrew words. What are the other two languages?
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by bluGill on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:26AM (#21505043)
Good question. I do not know, I jut recall someone telling me that 5 once. It seems like it is in the right range.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by ars on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:51AM (#21480229)
> A translation is basically offloading all that to a team of scholars.

Those same scholars would say the same thing: You can not understand the original intent from a single translation. (For example some words have multiple meanings, and all the meanings are intended.)

Translations have different purposes, some are intended for smooth reading, or poetic language, or literal direct translation (never mind if it's hard to understand), or easy comprehension.

And ALL of them are valuable! If you have a specific need, pick the translation that matches your need.

But, for study, to really understand the material you need more than one, and in particular you need notes and explanation.

Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by steve19 on Friday November 08, 2019 @03:34AM (#21480729)
Of course, but no theologians are telling laypeople to learn Greek, ancient Hebrew, Aramaic and vulgar Latin before reading a translation in their first language! Or at least not since post counter reformation.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by irrational on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:32AM (#21482455)
A team of scholars who have a (perhaps unconscious) doctrinal bent that influences their translation. If a word can be translated 10 different ways into English, of course you are going to choose the English word that matches your concept of doctrine. This is inevitable. By reading many different translations from scholars from different belief systems (catholic, protestant, orthodox, restoration, etc.) you will get a more rounded sense of possible meanings.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by pcmonk on Friday November 08, 2019 @02:13AM (#21480478)
If you're interested in tools for this, Logos Bible Software is quite good.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:27AM (#21481604)
Yeah, I'm using "And Bible" on Android, and one of the big killer features for me is that it can easily show a selected verse in every translation that it has downloaded.
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by RedComet on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:56PM (#21489265)
Why did you use a hyphen in place of the letter o?
Re:Show HN: Minimal Reader for the ESV Bible, Written in Janet by jonstaab on Sunday November 10, 2019 @03:27PM (#21499993)