Philosophically, even if there is no greater effect than transfer of wealth from young to old, pretty much everyone who is now young will one day be old.
"Among the savage nations of hunters and fishers, every individual who is able to work is more or less employed in useful labour, and endeavours to provide, as well as he can, the necessaries and conveniencies of life, for himself, and such of his family or tribe as are either too old, or too young, or too infirm, to go a-hunting and fishing. Such nations, however, are so miserably poor, that, from mere want, they are frequently reduced, or at least think themselves reduced, to the necessity sometimes of directly destroying, and sometimes of abandoning their infants, their old people, and those afflicted with lingering diseases, to perish with hunger, or to be devoured by wild beasts. Among civilized and thriving nations, on the contrary, though a great number of people do not labour at all, many of whom consume the produce of ten times, frequently of a hundred times, more labour than the greater part of those who work; yet the produce of the whole labour of the society is so great, that all are often abundantly supplied; and a workman, even of the lowest and poorest order, if he is frugal and industrious, may enjoy a greater share of the necessaries and conveniencies of life than it is possible for any savage to acquire." [0]
[0] Adam Smith, "An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations", intro.
What we have done is voted in politicians who have promised us SS pensions, but not actually funded those pensions. Instead the debt is going to fall upon young adults who were kids/unborn when said promises were made.
Yes, everyone gets old. That doesn't entitle us to puts debts on people who had no say in the matter. It's really not much different from me borrowing money and promising my child's future earnings to pay it off.
Previously, elderly people would move into small houses in small towns, or into apartments, in order to free up capital and lower ongoing costs.
Social security has reduced poverty in every age group.
https://www.cbpp.org/research/social-security-keeps-22-milli...
Also if you want to go even further, you should redistribute from 40-60 to 0-25 and 65+ to enable people to properly raise children and the like.
The conservative and libertarian trains of thought value individual agency above public welfare, which is a convenient point of view for people with the means to sustain themselves.
The plumber boss in question ran unincorporated, so his business's debts are his personal debt. Were he running an LLC, the debt would be on the company only.
all the profits go to you
Yours and other people’s money that you used to pay for things becomes a tax deductions for you
the worst thing that will happen is that the world’s most prestigious reporters will report that you “lost” a billion dollars and nobody will be the wiser that your personal balance sheet contains free and clear money and assets
That's actually a pretty good situation to be in. Plumbing strikes me as a very easy business to walk away from - just take your contact list with you and you'll be back in business in no time.
That is definitely not the moral of the story.
Aside from that, what exactly do you think a 401k is, if not a vehicle for people to manage their own retirement? The only government involvement in a 401k is non-involvement in the form of allowing you to contribute pre-tax money. And the broker won't be involved either if you're smart and elect to invest in indexes, rather than mutual funds (which can have high fees).
Despite all that I agree that GP’s comment to abolish 401ks is throwing the baby out with the bath water.
From what I hear, lots of employers get royally screwed. Namely school districts and other small-gov employers. There is something about public schools that just love buying into high-fee 403b.
The easiest way to fix this particular problem would be to make the contribution limit for retirement accounts a combined limit for both IRAs and 401k accounts, and to mandate that in-service rollovers be available free of charge.
The real issue is the contribution limit is $5500 a year.
Cant they just transfer the balace to a 401k of their choice with better options?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_S._Truman#Financial_prob...
> The former president told House Majority Leader John McCormack in 1957, "Had it not been for the fact that I was able to sell some property that my brother, sister, and I inherited from our mother, I would practically be on relief, but with the sale of that property I am not financially embarrassed."[264] The following year, Congress passed the Former Presidents Act, offering a $25,000 yearly pension to each former president, and it is likely that Truman's financial status played a role in the law's enactment.[265] The only other living former president at the time, Herbert Hoover, also took the pension, even though he did not need the money; reportedly, he did so to avoid embarrassing Truman.[266]
If a former US president is dumb enough to go bankrupt repeatedly post-presidency, what hope do you think the average Joe Sixpack has?
Big centralized retirement funds are scams and they always will be. Wherever there is a giant pile of other people's money managed by a bunch of bureaucrats, some suits will come along and find a way to profit from that pile of money in the most wasteful way possible.
Now all these retirement funds invest straight into low-yielding corporate stocks; so the money essentially ends up going into the pockets of corporate executives. And the worst part is that the government makes this compulsory.
I know superannuation is a scam but I'm forced to pay it anyway and I can't take the money out until I'm 65... I wouldn't be surprised if by that time, the retirement fund stock bubble will probably have popped and my retirement account will be worth $0... And all the fund managers and corporate executives will be rich.