News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Reedx on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @09:37AM (#21452700)
I suspect we'll see companies starting to avoid hiring people who've made politics their religion. I'd be surprised if Google isn't already trying to take steps in that direction.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Braggadocious on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @04:03PM (#21456663)
Not just google but there's a significant market across silicon valley for employees who don't have so many ethical dilemmas, if any. For instance,there are employers partnering with specific coding bootcamps that develop a complete personality/IQ overview on each of their students before they graduate which can be used later by employers. It also helps bootcamps predict which of their potential graduates will be more likely to remain employed and kick out students who are likely to have problems obtaining or holding jobs BEFORE they graduate and affect their job placement statistics.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by romwell on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:40PM (#21457540)
> For instance,there are employers partnering with specific coding bootcamps that develop a complete personality/IQ overview on each of their students before they graduate which can be used later by employers. It also helps bootcamps predict which of their potential graduates will be more likely to remain employed and kick out students who are likely to have problems obtaining or holding jobs BEFORE they graduate and affect their job placement statistics.

This is such progress, and absolutely a direction we all should move in, and not at all creepy, scary, and disgusting AF.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Teever on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:14PM (#21459658)
I hope that they use spiders that trawl social media sites for political posts by prospective candidates to weed out the ones with erroneous and excessive political points of view.

I bet that they could look to China for ideas in this endeavor.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by faizshah on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @10:10AM (#21453019)
I suspect when companies start doing that you’ll see more people in our industry avoiding these unethical companies. It’s a fact that young people are demanding more ethical workplaces, even finance is adapting to the new labour market.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by georgeburdell on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @10:41AM (#21453325)
Argument from authority. Given student loans and rent increases in the past decade, I imagine “young people” care most about paying their bills. The ones protesting are the privileged few
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by romwell on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:45PM (#21457593)
>The ones protesting are the privileged few

That's why they are protesting, you know. Because "having an opinion", "not being chained by a loan until you are old", and so on should not be a "privileged" position in any sort of environment I personally want to live in.

What is your point exactly anyway? "Not all people can afford to express opinions and influence their employers, so those who can should not be taken into account"?

That's a non-sequitur, if you like attaching fallacy labels to statements.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by faizshah on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:14PM (#21457347)
Citing a logical fallacy doesn’t make a statement false. There’s numerous sources supporting this(note that these are 3 different surveys from 3 different sources from 3 different years all showing the same result):

”Nearly nine out of ten, or 86 percent, of millennials (those between the ages of 22 and 37) would consider taking a pay cut to work at a company whose mission and values align with their own, according to LinkedIn’s latest Workplace Culture report. By comparison, only 9 percent of baby boomers (those between the ages of 54 and 72) would.“

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/27/nearly-9-out-of-10-millennia...

“At least those are the results of a new survey out from insurer MetLife, which found that nine out of 10 people would choose a company with similar values over a job that pays more. And they are willing to take a pretty big pay cut to make sure those values align with their own.

The average pay cut employees were willing to take was 21%. The findings were not limited to high-wage earners: People who made less than $50,000 a year also said they still were willing to part with at least some of their salaries for the right company.”

https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/11/29/money-no-lon...

”Almost half the workforce (42%) now want to work for an organisation that has a positive impact on the world, according to research carried out by consultancy Global Tolerance. The survey of more than 2,000 people in the UK found 44% thought meaningful work that helped others was more important than a high salary and 36% would work harder if their company benefitted society.

The change, it would appear, is being driven by the so-called millennials. Of those born between 1981 and 1996, 62% want to work for a company that makes a positive impact, half prefer purposeful work to a high salary, and 53% would work harder if they were making a difference to others.“

https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2015/may/05...

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by repolfx on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:00AM (#21462042)
They say they would consider it? Sure, such a weak claim is bound to get 90%+ agreeing with it. Who wouldn't say they'd consider it?

Now how many actually do? Not that many, for sure.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by faizshah on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:41AM (#21463003)
> Who wouldn't say they'd consider it?

"By comparison, only 9 percent of baby boomers (those between the ages of 54 and 72) would."

> Now how many actually do? Not that many, for sure.

Conjecture at best.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Iv on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @04:19PM (#21456814)
Students loans are a pretty American thing. Not all engineers come from US. Many of us can afford to have opinions.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by badrabbit on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:17AM (#21453722)
Companies are not supposed to be a way by which you enforce your moral beliefs. You have laws and elections for that. How would you like if businesses turn you away because of your unethical beliefs?
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by pmoriarty on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:01PM (#21454226)
But laws and elections have been singularly ineffective at stopping global warming.

Take a look at the success of the Civil Rights movement. Do you think segregation would have ended as quickly had black activists simply stuck to laws and elections, and not protested and deliberately did things that were actually illegal: like sitting in the front of a bus or disobeyed police orders to disperse while protesting?

The extra-legal actions of the protesters and the brutal response of the authorities (all documented through the mass media) made way more people aware of their cause and gained them many allies.

Or take a look at all the labor activism in the US, back when unions were strong, which brought about things like the 40-hour work week and workplace health regulations: these were not won merely through elections.

Or look at the Suffragettes, who helped win the right for women to vote not by restricting themselves to winning elections but by direct action.

Or India's successful struggle to independence under the leadership of Gandhi. Once again, it was coordinated activism which made the difference.

The list of such successful activism could grow very long.

Which isn't to say elections are useless (though with all the easily hackable electronic voting machines and vote counting machines out there, sometimes I wonder), but to reject activism in favor of elections is to give up a very powerful tool for change.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by sabarn01 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:17PM (#21455034)
Its activism + old fashioned democratic politics. At least in the US. The suffragettes brought attention and then they mobilized a political coalition. Organized labor agitated but it was though the ballot box that the 40 hour week job safety were granted.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by badrabbit on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:34AM (#21462941)
1) those activists,especially civil rights movement exhausted all legal means.

2) illegal does not mean violent and harmful. A peaceful protest is fine, I actually support that. Being loud so you can be heard is fine too. What is not fine is expecting companies to refuse to do business with your opposition in solidarity or any other move that is essentially harming your opponent and does not fall in line with peaceful activism. You shouldn't get someone fired, get businesses to stop offering services to them,exclude them from public events,subject them and their associates to humiliation and social isolation and of course you shouldn't cause them physical harm either.

If someone hires a person who denies climate change or if a person does business or works for big oil they are not responsible for the views and actions of the people/business they associate with and they do not owe anyone solidarity in form of terminating those relationships.

What yoy have these days is "activism" by form of isolating your opponents using anyone in a position of power to sever ties with them and if the pains of isolation are too much they might give way and let you win. To me that is cowardly and in some ways just as bad if not worse than physical violence. If you beat someone up they might heal,if you make them unhirable then they either starve or find more extreme people on their side to support them -- further solidifying their stance. I oppose cruelty as a method of bringing about positive change,ends don't justify means.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by ng12 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:27PM (#21454491)
> But laws and elections have been singularly ineffective at stopping global warming.

And you think removing their access to GCP is going to stop them?

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Analemma_ on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:45PM (#21454671)
The point is to increase the marginal cost of fossil fuels to harm their competitiveness against renewable energy. Denying them access to cost-saving technology is one way to do that.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by ng12 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:15PM (#21454998)
You're also reducing their ability to produce oil safely and effectively, while simultaneously handing more economic power to oppressive OPEC regimes.

Weaning ourselves off of oil is the first step not the last.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Analemma_ on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @02:07PM (#21455543)
I'm a little annoyed you think I'm some kind of simpleton who hasn't considered the tradeoffs of my position and that your comment comes as some kind of shock to me. I have considered your points before, and found that on balance it's worth it.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by ng12 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @02:14PM (#21455610)
Would you care to explain your position rather than expressing shock that someone disagrees with you?
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by komali2 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:51PM (#21457643)
We can't fight a perfect, bloodless war.

If they start producing oil unsafely as a result of thinning margins, we protest that all the same.

That's the form our "baby steps" take, not second guessing whether it's the "right time" to protest oil companies doing bad things.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by ng12 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:53PM (#21458246)
> whether it's the "right time" to protest oil companies doing bad things.

What are the bad thing oil companies do? Extract the oil you and I pay them to extract?

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by komali2 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:43PM (#21458932)
Spill millions of gallons of oil into the ocean.

Spill millions of gallons of oil into the wilderness.

Lobby the government to let them get away with spilling millions of gallons of oil.

Lobby the government to prevent the building of public transit.

Shill against climate change activism.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by adrianN on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:59AM (#21460068)
Pay fortunes to lobby against climate action instead of investing in renewable alternatives.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Iv on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @04:25PM (#21456868)
> But laws and elections have been singularly ineffective at stopping global warming.

...in the US. I am sorry that I keep pointing that out, but global warming is being fought by most elected leaders right now. With some moderate success. The per capita emission in the world has plateaued, despite a positive economic growth. OECD countries have seen a decrease, China seems to come close to plateau as well.

US' leaders are the ones who unilaterally pulled from Kyoto and Paris treaties.

And I mean, even in the US, CO2 emissions are diminishing, in huge parts because of environmental policies.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by komali2 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:49PM (#21457628)
Well, we're talking about a US company right now.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by Analemma_ on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:38AM (#21453954)
> Companies are not supposed to be a way by which you enforce your moral beliefs.

Says who? I don't know about your ethical system, but mine certainly doesn't demand that I confine ethics to one sphere and never let it touch the others. Indeed, such an ethical system sounds completely broken to me.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by badrabbit on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:06PM (#21454279)
Your ethical system is impractical and toxic. Your ethical system works by way of forcing your views on others. Perhaps if you were denied access to services,businesses,jobs,etc... Because of your ethical system you can appreciate the problem?

"I can treat you this way but you can't treat me the same way" sounds hypocritical does it not? You're right so you get to discriminate be intoletant and harm others,is that what you're saying? If you're so right let us use established systems of society to codify your beliefs,don't use your influence amd wallet to twist arms like a coward against those who lack your power and influence.

A system where people don't arm-twist and harm each other but use civilized discussion and peaceful discourse to patiently bring about desired change is what I support.

I do not support using your power as an employer, business owner,boss, monopoly(google) and other positions of power and influence to force others to practice your beliefs! I bet you would lose your mind if a religious person enforcef their religious beliefs the same way or if the people you disagree with did the same thing.

With your way,it is not the voice of who is right or of the majority that prevails but the strongest and most powerful win. And with your way phsyical violence and war are inevitable. Like ghandi said,be the change you wish to see. And tell others with your lowdest most peaceful voice,that's peaceful change. If that don't work for you then use violence and arm-twisting like this and let history repeat once more.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by mindslight on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:09PM (#21454928)
> A system where people don't arm-twist and harm each other but use civilized discussion and peaceful discourse to patiently bring about desired change is what I support.

But yet some regressive herd action always ends up carrying the current day, only to be lamented twenty years later, when a different but philosophically-similar goal will carry.

You wouldn't say that an individual choosing to not work at a specific company was "impractical" or "toxic", nor would you say that a small business avoiding a certain type of client was either. The real measure is when it becomes coercive.

Your comment is getting traction because red-flavor-thinking has been put in the position of pushing back against powerful corporations censoring individual speech. One of the justifications from the power-cheerleaders is "voluntary association", completely ignoring the power imbalance. And so the overall concept of voluntary association takes collateral damage despite being valid when applied honestly.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by badrabbit on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:30AM (#21463475)
You wouldn't say that an individual choosing to not work at a specific company was > "impractical" or "toxic", nor would you say that a small business avoiding a certain type of client was either. The real measure is when it becomes coercive.

Voluntary association is a legal right but not associating based on political affiliation I am pretty sure is illegal and if not it should be. It is coercion when employees protest a company's business partners,they are using their high demand skills that got them employed to advance personal political ends. They are using their collective power to coerce business decisions in order to harm their political opposition.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by klyrs on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:27PM (#21455162)
> Perhaps if you were denied access to services,businesses,jobs,etc...

The right to refuse service to customers, and birth control to employees, on the basis of religious belief of business owners, has been confirmed by the US Supreme Court.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by roenxi on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @04:21PM (#21456835)
That is one interpretation of several pages of judicial thought. Although not disagreeable, it throws out a lot of the subtleties about why the decisions were made and what specific circumstances and conflicting rights contributed to that decision.

Looking at the cases you linked, I suspect if GCP were to deny services to gay people or abortion service providers the courts would determine that circumstances were different.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by badrabbit on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:38AM (#21462982)
You have a legal right, that does not mean your way is ethical or correct. I disputed correctness and ethics not legality.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by mieseratte on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @02:41PM (#21455886)
> The right to refuse service to customers, and birth control to employees, on the basis of religious belief of business owners, has been confirmed by the US Supreme Court.

That is not the case at all.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by klyrs on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:28PM (#21456312)
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by int_19h on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:46PM (#21458950)
> Companies are not supposed to be a way by which you enforce your moral beliefs.

Moral beliefs would be a mockery if they were so strictly confined. The whole point of morality is that it's a set of rules on how to live your life by. They always apply, in every interaction with other humans.

Right now, for example, by attacking the OP as "toxic", you are applying your own moral beliefs to them.

And of course this is not "arm-twisting". Refusal to associate with somebody generally isn't - you are not owed anybody's company, labor, or their good disposition towards you.

> How would you like if businesses turn you away because of your unethical beliefs?

I'm perfectly fine with that.

Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by netsharc on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:29PM (#21455177)
Ah, laws and elections. "Dear Mr. Koch, as you know my re-election is coming soon,...".
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by zarkov99 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:12PM (#21458781)
Maybe. Maybe you will see good people gravitating to companies where they can do good work in peace, without being bothered by the self virtuous.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by normalnorm on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:31AM (#21453881)
Then these companies must be stopped by democratic processes, least we lose democracy itself.
Re:Googlers Are Protesting Company’s Deals with Big Oil by softwarefounder on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:39AM (#21453964)
Even zeal is no good without knowledge, and he who hurries his footsteps misses the mark.