News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by kobasa on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:53AM (#21442153)
Thankfully your circle of acquaintances isn't even remotely close to representing the wider world out there and the plethora of legitimate use cases that it presents for all sorts of people in this world.

Just last week a friend of mine from another country was suppose to send me a few hundred bucks. He could have sent it 'traditionally' but he would have been harassed about why he was sending money abroad and wasted considerable time and effort going to a physical bank branch. Instead in under a minute he sent me some Ethereum and we both were able to confirm the transaction near immediately. I'm now able to use that in the way I see fit directly within a Chrome extension within the browser I'm typing this on. I can take this money and start earning interest higher than any bank will give me within a few minutes. And this is just the beginning of cutting out middleman and processes that feel as cumbersome as sending a letter vs an email.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by maeln on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:41AM (#21443331)
Yes but you don't end up with the few hundred bucks, you end up with Ethereum. If you need to pay for something using euro, dollar, ... you going to need to convert it which will include fees.

Plus, I don't want to defend the banking industry, but there is often two reason why transferring money is a bit cumbersome with banks: Scam and terrorism/money laundring.

The first thing is, the average Joe cannot help himself but get scammed. Because of this banks have to try to check has much has possible that you are doing what you think you are doing and make you jump through some hoop. Because had the end of the day, its probably the bank that will have to pay for your idiocy. They have insurance but insurance are not free. Crypto-currency usually don't care about this, if you send BTC to one address, you send BTC to one address, and if it was a scam, you have no way to get anything back. Being able to transfer money at just the click of a button also has its problem, lets be honest.

And terrorism / money-laundering. There is a lot of regulation about it, none that crypto-currency care about. You could be sending BTC to Daesh, nobody can stop you. Banks have to stop you. Just like they have to check that the money you are sending / receiving is legitimate and not from some illegal operation. That is why international money transfer takes more time and cost a lot more.

Now granted, a lot of banks are still awful at preventing scam even though they are extremely cumbersome to use. Just like a lot don't want to be bother with the whole money-laundering process and will try to discourage you to do anything that would require them to follow the process. And yes, some of them abuse their dominance to put ludicrous fess, etc. But the fact is that crypto-currencies live in a dream world where they don't have to put up with the rules that banks do. And that is why they will either never see widespread use, or they will have to find a way to comply with country regulation, which will need the third party that they tried so hard to remove.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by damon_c on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:59PM (#21445071)
>Yes but you don't end up with the few hundred bucks, you end up with Ethereum. If you need to pay for something using euro, dollar, ... you going to need to convert it which will include fees.

I one has dollars and wants to pay for something using Euro or anything else, one will need to convert it which will include fees.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:01AM (#21442224)
> my friend sent me $300

> Oh wait, now it's $310

> Damn, now it's $200

The other downside, as you mention, is that the only main use for Eth is speculating on experimental lending platforms.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by kobasa on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:08AM (#21442282)
You can send a stablecoin if you have a problem with volatility. There's even a native one called Dai which is outside the traditional banking system.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:19AM (#21442377)
And how is it pegged? Someone asked the various exchanges very nicely if they could only trade it for $1?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Geee on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:03PM (#21443663)
It's backed by collateral locked in Ethereum smart contracts.

https://makerdao.com/en/whitepaper#overview-of-the-dai-stabl...

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:05PM (#21443699)
That doesn't explain how it's pegged to the dollar.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Legogris on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:06PM (#21444412)
It is laid out pretty well in the link you got how it is not pegged to the US dollar (which I don't think anyone claimed either).
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @04:14AM (#21450850)
>You can send a stablecoin if you have a problem with volatility

Yes, they did. I'm aware that Dai is not well pegged to the dollar, but then I'm not a crypto-fan.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Legogris on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:31AM (#21451163)
"Stablecoin" != "hard peg to USD"
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:57AM (#21451262)
I'm fully aware of that. What I would like to know is the mechanism that links Dai in any way to USD. So far, I've been told the onus on me is to research it, and then that my conclusions from that research are wrong.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Legogris on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:26AM (#21451385)
If you spent as much time reading and internalizing the whitepaper as you did arguing about it online you'd be there already. I know I'm being snarky, but you're coming of as trollier and trollier. This is not Reddit.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:55AM (#21451538)
I read the materials, and I still can't figure it out. You have also done your research, and apparently do know why Dai is stable to the USD. I'm just curious what that mechanism is, and why you can't explain it. I did read your very long answer elsewhere, but that's an overview of the entire Maker system, and at no point does it explain which part does the "stabilizing", apart from a vague reference to "incentives". What are they?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Legogris on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:12AM (#21451653)
Oversimplifying a bit here at the price of accuracy and completeness, but mainly arbitrage. Ceiling is easy; if the market price is > 1$, it is free money to create new CDPs and sell the DAI off for ETH on the market.

If the ETH/USD price goes down, so does the capitalization ratio of CDPs. If a CDP goes low enough, users have to either repay their DAI debt (removing DAI supply from market) or rebalance by depositing additional ETH collateral. Otherwise, their position will be liquidated (which means the CDP owner loses their collateral) and their ETH collateral is put up for public sale for DAI on-chain. The DAI used to pay at these sales is destroyed. This creates an incentive for people to burn DAI to acquire ETH below market price (thus creating demand for DAI).

Also in general I advise you to ask clarifying questions rather than post scoffy dismissals if you know that your understanding might be incomplete.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by robcohen on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:23AM (#21442438)
[dead]
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Legogris on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:36PM (#21444039)
If you have an adversarial mindset (which is absolutely healthy) and want to understand it well enough to not immediately come up with counterarguments whose only valid reply is "RTFM", yes, it takes at least 20 minutes. But regardless, I'll bite.

DAI has a couple of intended use-cases. I will focus here on the "stable coin" asset, meaning you should be able to expect it's value to not go up or down over time. It is inherently debt.

The main component of DAI is "CDPs", Collateralized Debt Positions. There is a smart contract on the ETH blockchain. Smart contracts are computer code on the blockchain that are "open trustless execution", meaning you can inspect the source code, verify that it matches the deployed bytecode, and be certain that any transaction follows the rules. In DAI, there is no entity that can even theoretically exit-scam you.

The configuration parameters of this smart contract is set by votes by the holders of the MKR token. This token is traded on public markets and is the speculative token of the ecosystem.

You can deposit assets into this smart contract. The current version of DAI only takes ETH, but the intention is that MKR holders will consider any significant asset representable on the ETH blockchain. This includes other stablecoins (think fiat-backed tokens), tokenized equity or government bonds (which have already been issued on the ETH blockchain), tokens backed by commodities like gold, etc.

When you deposit assets into the smart contract, you get DAI in return, representing a loan backed by the deposited assets. How much DAI you get in return is determined by an oracle (meaning a smart contract providing data external to the blockchain). This oracle is aggregated from several other oracles, similarly public and approved by the MKR governance. In general, the system is over-collateralized at any point in time.

There is an incentive and liquidation system around the whole things that goes a bit further to ensure that the price remains stable despite fluctuations - and so far the DAI/USD price has remained really close to 1 throughout the ETH/USD long bleed of 2018, including short periods of high volatility.

There is some degree of risk involved of course, most notably including the oracle price feeds. There is a road map to both increase transparency and decrease the possibility of collusion between oracle providers.

There is also the "emergency shutdown", which involves freezing and instant liquidation, but this comes at a big cost to the MKR holders who have to approve it.

Despite having been running for several years and having dozens of people (I think over 100 now?) it is, of course, still to a large part an experiment that is still evolving. But so far it has been performing better than I thought. And there is no way you could call it a scam.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:33PM (#21444771)
So in short, a price feed from several crypto exchanges. Thanks!
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Acrobatic_Road on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:55PM (#21445742)
No, did you even read what he wrote? Price feeds are used in the system, but the whole system does not boil down to "price feeds". I am not even sure what that could mean.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:35AM (#21449921)
I asked how is the Dai pegged to the dollar, and that is the answer.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Acrobatic_Road on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:26AM (#21450165)
Price feeds are the answer? The price feeds in question don't even track the price of Dai - so I am not even sure what mechanism you have thought up to explain to yourself how Maker works.

If you are still having trouble understanding the system there is no shortage of resources available. Of course if you dismiss the resources because of an anti-cryptocurrency bias as you have then you will end up clueless since this is a realm with low-coverage in the mainstream.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:31AM (#21450640)
I've read the previous, very long, answer. Yes, it explains how the Maker system works, but it does not explain which parts constitute the Dai to USD peg. The price feeds track the price of Eth, which is used to set the price of Dai if automatic settlement is needed (something I learned from the resources you describe!). If that doesn't set the price of Dai, then what does? Are you suggesting it's an emergent behavior of the system as a whole?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Acrobatic_Road on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:13AM (#21453657)
When someone's ethereum CDP is liquidated onto the market it is auctioned off for Dai before the collateral no longer backs the Dai. The price feed determines when a CDP is in need of liquidation. This mechanism is important because it keeps the system overcollateralized.

There is also something called global settlement. This is for major upgrades (they are doing one on the 16th) and also in case of emergencies. The price feeds in this case are used to determine Dai holder's proportional claims to the collateral (using the target price 1 Dai = 1 USD). It may happen happen Dai holders get less or more depending on the circumstance. In addition Maker is a major Ethereum application so if it failed the price of Ether would tumble. That is part of the reason they are expanding to support more collateral types in the update slated for the 16th.

So every Dai is a rough promise for one dollar but that does not answer why Dai is stable day to day. It works like this: When the price of Dai falls under 1 dollar, CDP owners will buy it up and close their positions at a discount which will put upward pressure on the price. Likewise, if the price of Dai goes above one dollar then fresh CDPs will be opened and fresh Dai will be sold on to the market, putting downward pressure on the price. If that isn't enough, the interest rate is manually adjusted to fine-tune the supply.

In the future part of the interest will be payed in to an optional savings account for Dai holders. The idea is that by adjusting the APR the demand for Dai can be fine-tuned. When rates are high people will buy Dai and lock in in a savings account. If demand is too high rates can be lowered causing an inverse affect.

https://blog.makerdao.com/introduction-to-emergency-shutdown...

I hope that helps.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by zionic on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:58AM (#21442792)
DAI is a complex series of loans, borrowing, and interest that creates incentive to sell your DAI if it goes over $1 and incentive to buy if it goes below $1. DAI has basically maintained $1 for years even as ETH prices have been all over the place. It's battle tested. If you can't be bothered to do a few minutes of research on a complicated topic I don't know what you're doing here.
[dead]
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by robocat on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:29PM (#21443954)
You appear to be very rude to me; you asked:

> And how is [DAI] pegged? Someone asked the various exchanges very nicely if they could only trade it for $1?

This is a forum and people have given you pointers to answers and you are expected to do the work to study on your own. This happens a lot in life.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:33PM (#21444759)
So far, I have a 20-minute video that is clearly mostly not about the Dai peg, and a link to a very wordy "paper". I skimmed both, and the answer is apparently "oracles", or a price feed from several crypto exchanges. That's a really simple answer, that doesn't need burying in layers of cryptobabble and an attitude that I can only describe as condescending.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by robocat on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:46PM (#21444915)
It is very good to be critical about the value of information others provide.

But I find your commenting style abrasive; I wouldn't be surprised to see you flagged if you continue with it (especially with multiple examples in a single thread). Occasional outbursts seem to be tolerated here, although frowned upon as unconstructive. I myself personally tend towards abrasive confrontation of facts; but I really value the rules here since they create good discourse and avoid discord.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by the_gastropod on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:07AM (#21442275)
> He could have sent it 'traditionally' but he would have been harassed about why he was sending money abroad and wasted considerable time and effort going to a physical bank branch. Instead in under a minute he sent me some Ethereum and we both were able to confirm the transaction near immediately

Have you heard of options like TransferWise or OFX? They offer immediate transfers, lower transaction fees than ETH or BTC, etc. Using crypto in this manner is wholly unnecessary.

> I can take this money and start earning interest higher than any bank will give me within a few minutes

Earning interest? Are you talking about "HODLing"? ETH has dropped by nearly 90% since its peak less than 2 years ago. There's massive risk in holding ETH/BTC. You don't get to cherry-pick dates and claim that it's better than holding in a bank—it's not. BTC/ETH are 0-sum games, so on average nobody earns a dime of interest.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by mrep on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:42AM (#21442636)
> BTC/ETH are 0-sum games, so on average nobody earns a dime of interest

I would argue it is actually negative sum as billions of dollars worth is newly minted every year and a lot of that inevitability has to be sold to pay the miners electricity bills. I'm honestly shocked they haven't collapsed due to the never ending supply side pressure requiring billions of dollars worth of capital inflow every year.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by leppr on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:10AM (#21442910)
The supply of Bitcoin is by design not "never ending" [1]. The future inflation rate is known and trending towards 0, eventually turning BTC deflationary.

[1] https://medium.com/@k_schellinger/understanding-bitcoins-21-...

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DennisP on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:05PM (#21443702)
That will change on Ethereum when they finish rolling out proof of stake.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by zionic on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:56AM (#21442771)
> lower transaction fees than ETH or BTC

Citation needed. At the time of this post, a <5m transfer is $0.004. That's not a typo. $0.031 for <2m.

https://ethgasstation.info/

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by kobasa on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:09AM (#21442302)
First of all YOU are the one cherry picking dates (conveniently picking the all-time high price which only lasted for a small timeframe). And now, I'm talking about DeFi (decentralized finance) where you can earn interest on top of your principal.

Also the ETH transaction fee is literally a few cents.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:10AM (#21442303)
>Earning interest

He's talking about "DeFi" ("distributed finance") - the current craze in the Ethereum world. Various groups are offering significant interest rates for loaning out your Eth. It's hard to see how it's not another speculation bubble waiting to burst.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by leppr on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:01AM (#21442834)
DeFi loans are typically very over-collaterized. Due to this, they represent way less of a risk to the economy than traditional credit.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by xur17 on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:25AM (#21443101)
I've looked into using these a few times, and I'm honestly more worried about smart contract bugs.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:12AM (#21442935)
How much collateral do you need for an asset that is as volatile as a cryptocurrency?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by xur17 on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:26AM (#21443121)
I believe makerdao sets it at 150%. If it ever drops under that amount they auction off the underlying asset on the the open market.
[dead]
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by tuesdayrain on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:29PM (#21443963)
Jeez, the quality of HN comments these days is not what it used to be.