News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by StavrosK on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:20AM (#21441813)
Similarly, I try to add it to all my side-projects that accept payment. I looked at a few payment providers and settled on OpenNode, as they had the right mix of an easy API, quick support and good documentation, though I would like it if they supported more cryptocurrencies.

If you want cryptocurrencies to succeed, you need to make them widespread as a form of payment. I already lament Steam and Stripe removing Bitcoin support because of the rampant speculating, let's not do more of that.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:29AM (#21442493)
Unfortunately, Bitcoin as designed is technically incapable of being in widespread use for payment, due to a severe lack of network capacity, and a complete lack of interest in ever changing this.

Instead, all effort is going into a building a flawed second layer that is theoretically unsound and a usability nightmare.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by repomies691 on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:06AM (#21442875)
> Instead, all effort is going into a building a flawed second layer that is theoretically unsound and a usability nightmare.

I don't know much about LN and actually I'm quite sceptical about it. However I have tried it now couple of times with different wallets and it seems to work very fluently from user perspective. And saying this as a very old bitcoin user, so I'm used to sending bitcoin payments a lot, LN payments don't seem to differ that much from usability perspective. You scan the QR code/invoice and press send.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:02PM (#21445118)
LN requires an on-chain transaction to open a channel and another to close a channel which means it'll take 70 years to open a channel for everyone on earth and then close it once, assuming the blockchain does nothing else. If an intermediate node loses power all your channel money is locked for over 48 hours. It's also not even Bitcoin and could work just as well with any other cryptocurrency or probably even dollars honestly.

Then of course there's the features people actually want like dispute resolution, the ability to charge back, and so on.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by xorcist on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:56PM (#21447562)
Is the argument here that Lightning, or Bitcoin, is useless because everyone on earth can not use it at the same time? Isn't that moving the goalposts, even a little?

Even if only a couple of thousand people could use it, as long as it is useful to them it has a niche. It might not be enough to justify insane valuations, of course, but that's another discussion entirely.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by mamon on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:31PM (#21447907)
Traditional banking serves pretty much everyone on earth, without running into performance issues, so if Bitcoin is going to replace those banks then yes, it must do the same. And it was Bitcoin fanboys who declared that Bitcoin is here to replace fiat money, so you set that goalpost yourself.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:20PM (#21448689)
No. Traditional banking doesn’t even serve everyone in the United States, with 55 million people unbanked or underbanked: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:12PM (#21448970)
This is the biggest misconception in the space (and that's saying a lot). They're un-banked and under-banked because they don't have money, not because the services don't exist. You want to solve this problem, solve wealth inequality and income inequality, don't pretend magic beans that cost $1-3 to transact will solve the problem for you. That's more than it costs you to use an Amex Bluebird or even a Green Dot card at an ATM, let alone a T-Mobile prepaid visa. And it's dropped half its value in the last two years (generously). Those are the people you want to disadvantage with a massively fluctuating currency?

Not to mention the low-income folks are most likely to have smartphones and therefore access to online banking with Ally or Schwab, which require $0 minimum balances and refund all ATM fees. You need a phone to use BTC, which means those same people can access Ally or Schwab and be objectively better off.

This is again a social problem in need of a social solution.

Postal banking is a great way to solve the access problem where it exists, too, like is done in the UK, and was in the US until the 1970s.

Sorry, this talking point is debunked, unless there's something I'm missing here.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by perl4ever on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:31PM (#21449354)
Not having a bank account doesn't mean that the financial system isn't being used. If I get a paycheck and take it to a check cashing place, I'm still relying on the financial infrastructure and the banks and crypto isn't a viable alternative.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by girvo on Monday November 04, 2019 @07:59PM (#21448561)
I think you'd be surprised by how large a proportion of the human population doesn't use traditional banking
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @07:18PM (#21448277)
There's a lot of FUD here.

It's kind of a straw man to talk about opening LN channels for 7.5 billion people, as if that's something to be concerned about today. Not every man, woman and child has a cell phone or computer right now, so that's not really a concern in 2019.

Dispute resolution is built into the protocol: it's a two-way channel; both parties have to agree that the transaction in question took place and either party can close the channel if they wish.

And because LN is under heavy development, there are all kinds of new features being developed, like watchtowers that can monitor the channel on your behalf, etc.

You don't need chargeback if you can claim your money and close the channel if thing you want to happen isn't happening, right?

Yes, other cryptocurrencies (such as Ethereum) can create LN as a layer-2 feature.

No, you can't do this with dollars; since there's no cryptocurrency representation of USD with the required blockchain and scripting/smart contracts language required for LN—at least not yet.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:43AM (#21450703)
> You don't need chargeback if you can claim your money and close the channel if thing you want to happen isn't happening, right?

And if the other person disagrees? Crypto falls down at the boundary between humans and the Blockchain every time.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by RustyRussell on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:22PM (#21447814)
Your figures are about right, but 70 years is a long time to assume nothing else changes.

As to "it's not even bitcoin" you're flat wrong. Holding a valid Bitcoin transaction is definitely Bitcoin, and with Lightning you always do. This is why it can't be done without bitcoin.

And from a FOSS development perspective, bitcoin is the only project in the *cryptos" space I consider serious. I wouldn't base a project of mine on any of the other chains, and I think I've earned my graybeard enough in FOSS to make that judgement.

[Disclaimer, I work on Lightning standards and one implementation, since 2015]

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:24PM (#21449018)
There are over 10,000 LN nodes right now, with a capacity of nearly $8 million and growing quickly. The site is called “1ML” because the goal is to get to 1 millions LN nodes: https://1ml.com

You have nodes running on smartphones now; as soon as you launch a LN app, the channel is opened. There are billions of smartphones out there, so the 70 years you quoted is not a thing.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by StavrosK on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:42AM (#21443350)
Eh, there's Stellar, Nano, whatever. There are solutions, the important thing is that cryptocurrencies start having uses other than speculation. It doesn't matter which one is useful as long as one is, and I'd rather use Bitcoin now than use Visa because of a theoretical fear that Bitcoin might not scale to millions of people.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:44AM (#21451467)
And they are all an absolute shitshow. Nano especially is complete and utter garbage that barely holds together under the minimal usage of its tiny user base.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by StavrosK on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:58AM (#21451553)
In what way?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:55PM (#21448121)
Every LN app I’ve used—DropBit, Zap, Bottle Pay, BlueWallet—has totally nailed user experience.

LN will be the standard for micropayments in a year or two.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:35AM (#21442560)
The idea here is that the blockchain model where everyone checks everything that happens doesn't scale to billions of users.

Fortunately for people who disagree, there are hundreds of crypto projects that think this is possible. Including straight up copies of Bitcoin like Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:43AM (#21442642)
It doesn't even scale to millions of users.

And basically every project that tries to claim different is just ignoring the problem and trying to pump their own price.

Everything in cryptocurrencies is a scam.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by icelancer on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:52AM (#21442729)
This is absurd hyperbole. There are people working on legitimate answers to your concerns, such as the Lightning Network and other initiatives.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by jcranmer on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:55AM (#21442763)
Is Lightning usable yet? I recall hearing it's been "imminent" since at least 2017...
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:05AM (#21442862)
You're clearly listening to the wrong people.

It's usable for sure, but that doesn't mean billions of people can (nor want) to use it now. I'm using it just fine.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:25AM (#21443100)
It's less usable than it's parent blockchain!
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:59PM (#21444321)
That's subjective. It's a lot cheaper and fast to send money.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:09PM (#21444458)
What's the most I could send without network liquidity issues?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:27PM (#21444668)
I don't know the answers to this strange question. What's the most you can send to another bank account without compliance issues?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:03PM (#21445131)
Lightning network is limited to the liquidity offered by channel operators. What is the current situation like?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:32PM (#21449619)
Situation is great, note that I operate my own channels and I'm not sending millions around every day.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by scott_s on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:44PM (#21445608)
What do you mean by "compliance" issues? If you meant that the sum of money you send cannot trigger someone, somewhere to check to make sure the transaction is legit, and we're assuming a transfer from a "normal" bank to another, then I would guess on the order of $10,000. But companies and organizations routinely transfer millions and billions between normal banks. Yes, the transactions may cause someone or many someones to investigate, but the transfers still succeed.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:34PM (#21449630)
What does OP mean with "liquidity issues"? Lightning is a routing network, and you can connect directly to your counterparty, circumventing all potential liquidity issues.

> But companies and organizations routinely transfer millions and billions between normal banks

Just like companies have direct lightning channels between each other, they can send billions of they please.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:39AM (#21450684)
You're being disingenuous. A channel needs to be already funded before a transaction can happen, with an amount at least the size of the transaction. So, to transfer billions, you need billions more to first fund the channel. A quick search shows that most channels currently have less than $100 in them, limiting how much you can send without prior arrangement.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:45AM (#21463039)
> A quick search shows that most channels currently have less than $100 in them, limiting how much you can send without prior arrangement.

Note that not all channels are public, so you won't find all in searches. I'm only saying that you shouldn't be worried about lightning liquidity if you can directly connect to your counterparty - as you can directly transact with that party without relying on any liquidity from anyone else.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:27PM (#21448733)
Most LN apps recommend sending no more than $50 USD over the Lightning Network right now. That will increase over time.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:45AM (#21451486)
For Lightning to work at scale, we need solutions for problems that nobody on earth has solved yet, nor have any idea how to solve.

Sure, it kind of sort of works for small network sizes. It will die a fiery death the second it attempts to become popular with no known way out of the mess.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:25PM (#21448723)
Yes; I use LN more than standard Bitcoin.

There are many apps already and things are just now getting started: https://www.lapps.co/

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:46AM (#21451494)
The only reason it works at all is that it is small and barely used by anyone at all.

Scaling Lightning is an unsolved problem. It relies on finding solution to problems people have tried to solve for decades with no success.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:46AM (#21463044)
What problems are you referring to?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:05PM (#21445160)
Lightning is worthless because it requires an on-chain transaction to open and close, so it inherits all the same scaling issues as Bitcoin.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:50PM (#21458213)
Let me further clarify: Lightning is not worthless and has already become the basis of a new industry of apps and services.

Like any low-value transaction using bitcoin, like the proverbial cup of coffee, it’s not necessary to wait for even one confirmation before doing anything.

Plain vanilla lightning uses a UTXO (that’s what a bitcoin on the blockchain is, an unspent transaction) to open a channel. But you don’t have to wait 10 minutes for at least 1 confirmation before using the payment channel.

I’ve received multiple LN transactions with various LN apps and it’s always been instant.

Once the payment channel is opened, it stays open as long as it needs to. But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain; it’s only required once the parties decide to close the channel.

Same thing with multi hop payments.

There are many enhancements being worked on, like loop-in, loop-out and submarine swaps, which handle providing liquidity to enable transactions and the ability to make swaps between chains, like being able to “swap” between bitcoin and light coin if that was desired.

There’s also work happening to enable one on-chain UTXO to fund multiple payment channels in one go.

So tens of thousands of transactions can take place without touching the underlying blockchain.

So there’s no lag when it comes to opening or closing a payment channel.

There are no scalability issues; we’ll have more LN nodes than Bitcoin full nodes (about 55,000 worldwide) by this time next year and it’ll be fine.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:01AM (#21463219)
> But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain.

That describes every single existing payment platform in the world today except Bitcoin.

> There are no scalability issues.

Except a 4tx/sec cap on opening and closing channels.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:54AM (#21463740)
> But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain.

To be clear, you can send and receive bitcoin without the fees or latency of the bitcoin blockchain until you close the channel. And depending on the use case, that could be weeks or months in the future.

And even when opening or closing a payment channel, you don’t have to wait for the blockchain to confirm that transaction.

> Except a 4tx/sec cap on opening and closing channels.

No such cap exists.

Here’s a great video—“10 Myths about Bitcoin's Lightning Network debunked by a Developer”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obRs-WpJ05M

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:54PM (#21448884)
This is false.

Once a channel is funded, it can stay open for as long as it needs to. I can have a payment channel open with my local coffeeshop and we can transact dozens of times; only the final bill has to be broadcast to the bitcoin blockchain.

Well connected LN nodes can be connected to hundreds of other nodes and route transactions accordingly.

In the short time LN has been available, there are over 10,000 nodes and growing; the network capacity is almost $8 million USD: https://1ml.com/statistics

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:10PM (#21448967)
So only 35 years?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:54AM (#21442759)
The internet didn't support millions of users after a decade either. Is the internet a scam?

I'm not sure why you are saying all efforts go into a flawed second layer?

a) Dozens of teams are working on other efforts.

b) Many do not consider lightning flawed.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by anyfoo on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:15PM (#21443796)
The Internet was always at capacity. Until we had the pervasive networking we have today, there were always more people wanting to have Internet access more persistently and with more performance than what was available. Almost everyone who had the opportunity to use the Internet, would. As a result, enormous advances in technology were made to implement today’s pervasive networking. New use cases manifested immediately all the time. Nobody ever said “we implemented this world wide network thing, now we are looking for use cases”, there were, and are, always more use cases to choose from than resources to implement them.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:01PM (#21444348)
> Almost everyone who had the opportunity to use the Internet, would.

I'm too young to have experienced this. But I've seen countless of clips and interviews of people claiming they would never use the internet because they can send post and use a telephone instead. "Computers are for geeks", etc.

> New use cases manifested immediately all the time. Nobody ever said “we implemented this world wide network thing, now we are looking for use cases”, there were, and are, always more use cases to choose from than resources to implement them.

It took a dotcom bubble to find the use cases we actually use today. Would you have not said the exact same thing back then about the internet?

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Nursie on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:25PM (#21444654)
Nobody said that back then, no. They said there had been an over-exuberant market with people throwing stupid money at any old idea, but nobody was saying "the internet is a bust" or even "we don't know the use-cases" because there were a ton of other useful, successful things going on with it.

You said it yourself - you're too young to actually know a lot about that, but you use it to bolster your arguments anyway.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#21444730)
> but nobody was saying "the internet is a bust"

Many people were saying this, Paul Krugman (one of the leading economists) went as far as comparing the internet to the fax machine:

"The growth of the Internet will slow drastically, as the flaw in 'Metcalfe's law'–which states that the number of potential connections in a network is proportional to the square of the number of participants–becomes apparent: most people have nothing to say to each other! By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the Internet's impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine's."

> You said it yourself - you're too young to actually know a lot about that, but you use it to bolster your arguments anyway.

I'm too young to live through it, but luckily I studied it in university :-) Many people claim to know many things about history prior to their birth. I guess I'm one of these people.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Chlorus on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:47PM (#21445646)
> Many people were saying this, Paul Krugman (one of the leading economists) went as far as comparing the internet to the fax machine:

And he caught a bunch of shit for it, even at the time. You keep trying to conflate critics of Bitcoin, many of whom have technical & finance backgrounds, with the largely non-technical crowd that didn't understand the web back in the 90s.

> I'm too young to live through it, but luckily I studied it in university :-)

What's the name of this "history of the internet" course(s) you took? The most historical context I ever got consisted of maybe a few intro paragraphs on Arpanet in my networking 101 class.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:43PM (#21449666)
"Media history" would be the English translation. It wasn't about the technical origins of the internet which are irrelevant in this discussion.

They studied the impact on a few big media inventions (printing press, TV and the internet) on (western) culture. It seems you don't believe I had this in University? You can find some information here: https://docplayer.nl/2209094-Studiegids-2013-2014-communicat...

The subject is called "Mediageschiedenis" and you can find it on page 37. This document is unfortunately in Dutch.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by vkhorikov on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:53PM (#21449450)
> You keep trying to conflate critics of Bitcoin, many of whom have technical & finance backgrounds, with the largely non-technical crowd that didn't understand the web back in the 90s.

People today are as illiterate about economics as they were about the Internet back in the 90s. Just look around and see how many people know what Austrian econ is.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by anyfoo on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:26PM (#21454473)
I was there. By the time the dotcom bubble burst, the Internet was already everywhere, having steadily grown as a household technology since first introduced to the general populace just a few years earlier.

The dotcom bubble was then precisely a symptom of the Internet's runaway success: Everyone wanted to use it, massive amounts of money were being made with it, and so everyone thought they could make money with it as well. As a result, even the stupidest ideas got funding.

When the bubble burst, it caused a significant economical upset. It did not have any really noticeable effect on the Internet itself, its usage, and the availability of most of the services that were actually in use. I don't think anybody remembers a time where Internet usage "dipped" from its massive momentum since the mid-90s, because the dip was largely economic.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by Nursie on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:07AM (#21450539)
Then he was an idiot, because at the time email was already in heavy use and had been for years, and had had a massive effect on business communication and the economy. Unless for some reason you don't count email as part of 'the internet'?

I was working back then, in 2003. The view on the ground was that SV had blown its head, but the rest of the world was just getting on with it. In fact most of the tech industry didn't even notice or care.

If you want to talk about whether web-based commerce was looking feasible, well even that was healthy enough - amazon was there and people were using it more and more, though clearly it wasn't as big as it is today.

So no, there was no feeling that 'the internet' wasn't going to be such a huge thing. There was a pessimism about some aspects of web commerce.

But I guess that's not as catchy a tagline as "It's like the early internet!"

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by briatx on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:43PM (#21444121)
The internet was scalable by design.

Bitcoin is not.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:08PM (#21445192)
> The internet didn't support millions of users after a decade either. Is the internet a scam?

The internet wasn't actively anti-efficient, making itself less efficient the more people wanted to use it haha.

> I'm not sure why you are saying all efforts go into a flawed second layer?

Because Bitcoin is fundamentally incapable of processing more than a laughable number of transactions, barely enough for a small town let alone the world?

> a) Dozens of teams are working on other efforts.

With nothing to show for it that isn't either (a) an objective scam or (b) not true to the fundamentally unachievable objectives underpinning "Bitcoin"

> b) Many do not consider lightning flawed.

Many people are wrong.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:48AM (#21451499)
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by cft on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:28AM (#21443141)
That's not an issue at all, for large transactions. The real issue is each payment being a taxable event, due to IRS treating it as property, rather than currency. You literally have to report each payment on schedule D and calculate its cost basis! This burden kills any legal US adoption.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by marcus_holmes on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:48AM (#21443447)
I thought the Bitcoin community were publicly stating that Bitcoin is optimised as a "Store of value" rather than a currency to be used for transactions? Which is it?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by blotter_paper on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:05PM (#21443701)
It's properties are more in line with a store of value, especially the deflationary aspect, but the line between a store of value and a currency is blurry. Gold also has more properties of a store of value than a currency, and it's used more as a store of value globally, yet some parts of North Africa and the Middle East are using the gold dinar as a currency. It can be both.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by marcus_holmes on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:15PM (#21447754)
not in a modern tax regime, not really. If it's a store of value, like say bonds, then it's property.

You have to report gold transactions, too, after all.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by blotter_paper on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:42PM (#21449110)
If you wanted to know how it's taxed, you could've asked that directly. I didn't see anything in your question about how it was taxed. Short answer specific to the US (IANAL): capital gains on every transaction, counting transactions between different cryptocurrencies as if you'd sold your original currency for USD and then bought the other cryptocurrency using USD. These are just arbitrary laws though, they have nothing to do with the actual properties of a given cryptocurrency.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by marcus_holmes on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:16AM (#21452049)
the comment I was replying to was specifically about tax (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21443141)
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:47PM (#21448850)
According to the Austrian School of economics, a thing has to be valuable or seen as a store of value before it can be used as a medium of exchange. This podcast has a great explanation of this: https://stephanlivera.com/episode/76/.

Why would you spend bitcoin if you didn't have to if you believed it’s going to be a lot more valuable 5 or 10 years from now?

Famously, a guy spent 10,000 BTC to buy two pizzas during the early days; that’s over $94 million USD at today's prices.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by bdcravens on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:12AM (#21442932)
We were one of Stripe’s early Bitcoin integration users. I even got a free T-shirt for finding bugs in their documentation. In the years that it was enabled (until Stripe ended support) we never received a single payment in Bitcoin.

There’s a large portion of the population who have no compelling reason to use Bitcoin.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by StavrosK on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:48AM (#21443450)
I integrated Stripe early on too, and did get some payments in Bitcoin (out of a few per month total). Eternum.io has had a Bitcoin integration for two weeks and already got two payments in Bitcoin.

I think it depends a lot on the audience.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by bdcravens on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:20PM (#21443856)
Of course. There's a subset of the population that is eager for Bitcoin payments, and if you have a service that either targets those users, or is a service they'd already use, you'll see usage. (Even that's a challenge, with the "hodl" mentality that's prevalent)

I think we're still a long way away from general purpose adoption however.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by uncletammy on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:44AM (#21442069)
> If you want cryptocurrencies to succeed, you need to make them widespread as a form of payment.

This! It's unfortunate that the most well known cryptocurrency failed to grasp this and refused to prioritize scaling so that it could accommodate demand.

At the end of the day, if a cryptocurrency can't be used like cash, it has nothing to offer over existing solutions.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by solotronics on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:39AM (#21442017)
btcpay is pretty good too, it's an open source payment processor
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by StavrosK on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:42AM (#21442052)
I looked at that too, but 1% for my low volume isn't worth the hassle of running my own processor (which would have been more expensive even before factoring in the hours I took to set it up).