News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by icelancer on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:52AM (#21442729)
This is absurd hyperbole. There are people working on legitimate answers to your concerns, such as the Lightning Network and other initiatives.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by jcranmer on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:55AM (#21442763)
Is Lightning usable yet? I recall hearing it's been "imminent" since at least 2017...
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:05AM (#21442862)
You're clearly listening to the wrong people.

It's usable for sure, but that doesn't mean billions of people can (nor want) to use it now. I'm using it just fine.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:25AM (#21443100)
It's less usable than it's parent blockchain!
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:59PM (#21444321)
That's subjective. It's a lot cheaper and fast to send money.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:09PM (#21444458)
What's the most I could send without network liquidity issues?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:27PM (#21444668)
I don't know the answers to this strange question. What's the most you can send to another bank account without compliance issues?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:03PM (#21445131)
Lightning network is limited to the liquidity offered by channel operators. What is the current situation like?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:32PM (#21449619)
Situation is great, note that I operate my own channels and I'm not sending millions around every day.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by scott_s on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:44PM (#21445608)
What do you mean by "compliance" issues? If you meant that the sum of money you send cannot trigger someone, somewhere to check to make sure the transaction is legit, and we're assuming a transfer from a "normal" bank to another, then I would guess on the order of $10,000. But companies and organizations routinely transfer millions and billions between normal banks. Yes, the transactions may cause someone or many someones to investigate, but the transfers still succeed.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:34PM (#21449630)
What does OP mean with "liquidity issues"? Lightning is a routing network, and you can connect directly to your counterparty, circumventing all potential liquidity issues.

> But companies and organizations routinely transfer millions and billions between normal banks

Just like companies have direct lightning channels between each other, they can send billions of they please.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by ppf on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:39AM (#21450684)
You're being disingenuous. A channel needs to be already funded before a transaction can happen, with an amount at least the size of the transaction. So, to transfer billions, you need billions more to first fund the channel. A quick search shows that most channels currently have less than $100 in them, limiting how much you can send without prior arrangement.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:45AM (#21463039)
> A quick search shows that most channels currently have less than $100 in them, limiting how much you can send without prior arrangement.

Note that not all channels are public, so you won't find all in searches. I'm only saying that you shouldn't be worried about lightning liquidity if you can directly connect to your counterparty - as you can directly transact with that party without relying on any liquidity from anyone else.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:27PM (#21448733)
Most LN apps recommend sending no more than $50 USD over the Lightning Network right now. That will increase over time.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:45AM (#21451486)
For Lightning to work at scale, we need solutions for problems that nobody on earth has solved yet, nor have any idea how to solve.

Sure, it kind of sort of works for small network sizes. It will die a fiery death the second it attempts to become popular with no known way out of the mess.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:25PM (#21448723)
Yes; I use LN more than standard Bitcoin.

There are many apps already and things are just now getting started: https://www.lapps.co/

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by DagAgren on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:46AM (#21451494)
The only reason it works at all is that it is small and barely used by anyone at all.

Scaling Lightning is an unsolved problem. It relies on finding solution to problems people have tried to solve for decades with no success.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by askmike on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:46AM (#21463044)
What problems are you referring to?
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:05PM (#21445160)
Lightning is worthless because it requires an on-chain transaction to open and close, so it inherits all the same scaling issues as Bitcoin.
Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:50PM (#21458213)
Let me further clarify: Lightning is not worthless and has already become the basis of a new industry of apps and services.

Like any low-value transaction using bitcoin, like the proverbial cup of coffee, it’s not necessary to wait for even one confirmation before doing anything.

Plain vanilla lightning uses a UTXO (that’s what a bitcoin on the blockchain is, an unspent transaction) to open a channel. But you don’t have to wait 10 minutes for at least 1 confirmation before using the payment channel.

I’ve received multiple LN transactions with various LN apps and it’s always been instant.

Once the payment channel is opened, it stays open as long as it needs to. But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain; it’s only required once the parties decide to close the channel.

Same thing with multi hop payments.

There are many enhancements being worked on, like loop-in, loop-out and submarine swaps, which handle providing liquidity to enable transactions and the ability to make swaps between chains, like being able to “swap” between bitcoin and light coin if that was desired.

There’s also work happening to enable one on-chain UTXO to fund multiple payment channels in one go.

So tens of thousands of transactions can take place without touching the underlying blockchain.

So there’s no lag when it comes to opening or closing a payment channel.

There are no scalability issues; we’ll have more LN nodes than Bitcoin full nodes (about 55,000 worldwide) by this time next year and it’ll be fine.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:01AM (#21463219)
> But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain.

That describes every single existing payment platform in the world today except Bitcoin.

> There are no scalability issues.

Except a 4tx/sec cap on opening and closing channels.

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:54AM (#21463740)
> But the killer feature is being able to transact without requiring the underlying bitcoin blockchain.

To be clear, you can send and receive bitcoin without the fees or latency of the bitcoin blockchain until you close the channel. And depending on the use case, that could be weeks or months in the future.

And even when opening or closing a payment channel, you don’t have to wait for the blockchain to confirm that transaction.

> Except a 4tx/sec cap on opening and closing channels.

No such cap exists.

Here’s a great video—“10 Myths about Bitcoin's Lightning Network debunked by a Developer”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obRs-WpJ05M

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by alwillis on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:54PM (#21448884)
This is false.

Once a channel is funded, it can stay open for as long as it needs to. I can have a payment channel open with my local coffeeshop and we can transact dozens of times; only the final bill has to be broadcast to the bitcoin blockchain.

Well connected LN nodes can be connected to hundreds of other nodes and route transactions accordingly.

In the short time LN has been available, there are over 10,000 nodes and growing; the network capacity is almost $8 million USD: https://1ml.com/statistics

Re:Lone Bitcoin Whale Likely Fueled 2017 Price Surge, Study ... by arcticbull on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:10PM (#21448967)
So only 35 years?