Re:How Big Is a Proton?
by omegaworks on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:37AM
(#21439627)
If a proton is a [probability] cloud, what exactly does the size measure? where that cloud's probability goes to zero?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How Big Is a Proton?
by davrosthedalek on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:01AM
(#21442227)
It's defined as the slope of the electric form factor at Q^2=0. Since that is not a very helpful definition, with some hand-waving, you can say it's the root-mean-square radius of the electric charge distribution. The proton has also a magnetic radius, defined via the magnetic form factor. And something called a Zemach radius, which is a combination if them both.
I was thinking more or less of the same question. Our intuition of what a particle "is" has a lot to do with how we perceive macroscopic objects. But particles are not really the same kind of thing. Or are they? Is their size correlated with their mass? Do particles consists of some "fundamental matter" or are they more like little machines?
I suppose that if you measure a probability-cloud long enough, you can arbitrarily bring down the inaccuracy of the size (?)