News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by jacquesm on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:21AM (#2142920)
Don't do this without very good guarantees that your data is not going to be tied to your identity somehow, you could be a in a lot of hot water for disclosing this stuff.

Sorry to rain on the parade but this is not a good idea.

If you do decide to go through with it use a proxy and a throwaway email address.

downmodders: you're clueless.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by rdl on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:35AM (#2142951)
As an employer, I wouldn't be particularly displeased by an employee revealing information like this anonymously (although I agree you should definitely not do so in a way which can be tied to you, just in case).

There is (some) justification in not identifying salary data within a specific company, to avoid jealousy and unproductive behaviors. At this level, it's not much more detailed than "how much do you make" on a loan application.

I don't think an employer has much right to try to pay the same people differential salaries based on their negotiating skill (at least for engineering/non-sales positions). There is a good argument for being 100% open with salaries and equity internally, at least in terms of ranges for given positions with given levels of experience. Joel on Software, http://www.inc.com/magazine/20090401/how-hard-could-it-be-em... I'm seriously considering doing "opt in to having your salary/equity public within the company", and Strongly Encouraging any senior person to do this; I think seeing a CEO making ~$60k and early engineers making $80k or so would help avoid runaway $140k for junior developers salary inflation, and I'd value my equity a lot more highly at a company where I saw the founders were still mainly motivated by equity upside vs. cash compensation.

Even at the granularity of per-employer salary stats (which Glassdoor type sites do), there is a net benefit to everyone in knowing that e.g. Netflix pays a 30-50% cash salary premium over Facebook, and that Twitter is particularly stingy with equity (relative to valuation) compared to other tech companies. If I were trying to hire people at Twitter, I'd be annoyed to be wasting my time with candidates who wanted >0.1% equity for anything but super-senior engineering positions, and I'd be sad if I were hiring at Netflix and people didn't know about the great cash component in deciding to apply.

If your first interaction with a company is them trying to mislead and/or fuck you through inaccurate perceptions and lack of information, this does not bode well.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by jacquesm on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:40AM (#2142958)
Agreed in general. But: this form asks for your email address, if you post from your corporate IP the company is known, if you add in all the rest of the data then the company might identifiable as well, if you have posted stuff in fora from your email account and tied it in to your corporate identity then that can be put together. After all, how many companies with between 'x' and 'y' employers in such and such an area making profit with a market cap of 'z' have active members on HN.

You're not nearly as anonymous as you think you are and this is very juicy data.

On the whole transparency is a good thing but this is probably not the best way to go about achieving it.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by rdl on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:46AM (#2142961)
A lot of university hiring offices collect this level of stats (although in less useful form) from recent graduates, and often republish.

Post from home, use a throwaway email address or at least a gmail-type address vs. @palantir.net work address, is probably enough. The most personally detrimental leak would probably be "I work for Yahoo and am currently interviewing with Google and Facebook" vs. that Google and Facebook extended specific offers, and in that case, you're already trusting the HR departments, recruiters, etc.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by alttab on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @08:40AM (#2143213)
I put my information in there and before I submitted I realized that with a little Googling and homework you could find out exactly who I was. No thanks.
Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by phlux on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @01:20PM (#2144283)
Let me test your theory - PM me your details.
Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by brc on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @09:21PM (#2146303)
It's the eternal salary-data conundrum.

Any salary data that is not supplied anonymously will be an incomplete data set for privacy reasons, and will have title and salary inflation.

Any salary data that is supplied anonymously wil be full of both title and salary inflation, and will still be an incomplete data set.

The end result either way is that the datasets can be seriously flawed.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by lsc on Thursday January 27, 2011 @12:03AM (#2146655)
clueless here: (I mean, I didn't downmod you; If it's worth responding it's worth not downmoding, but I am 'clueless')

what would be the consequences of disclosing your salary data? I've always been pretty open about what I've made personally, and while being open with the wrong people or the wrong situation can make you look pretty crass, what are the real consequences? Are people often fired for disclosing what they make? are they sued?

I mean, I have a hard time imagining a large company taking the time to sue some $100K/year lackey over bragging about his salary, or even firing the guy.

I guess I can imagine a small company firing over something like that, but again, anything more? seems unlikely.

I mean, the quotes I get for co-location or bandwidth all claim they are 'proprietary data' and not to be disclosed, but people still pass numbers around, and nothing comes of it besides an annoyed salesperson.

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by phlux on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @01:16PM (#2144263)
clearly the first line is a groupon exec