News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by tom_mellior on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:59AM (#21427413)
At some point cryptocurrencies felt like they could get us most of the way to working micropayments. Unfortunately Bitcoin's huge transaction fees and still unreliable service made that impossible. I still hope this will change at some point, but I can't imagine how a sufficiently dominant cryptocurrency could ever emerge again.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by cnasc on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:54AM (#21428323)
I work at a startup trying to do this (Ethereum rather than Bitcoin): https://unlock-protocol.com/about/

Transaction fees are there, but don't have to be enormous. Our code can also optimistically unlock the page under the assumption that pending transactions will eventually go through, so block time is also less of a concern.

Right now the tricky thing is that it requires a browser extension if you want to transact directly with crypto (or use one of the few browsers that come with a built-in web3 wallet).

We also have a managed crypto wallet service that allows people to pay with credit cards, but it isn't widespread because it can only be used to buy keys for locks we have approved.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by zozbot234 on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:09AM (#21427789)
> Unfortunately Bitcoin's huge transaction fees and still unreliable service made that impossible

The cost of crypto transactions has always been known, it just used to be paid for by the userbase as a whole when the block reward was more substantial, whereas right now the user pays for their own transactions.

I actually think the Lightning network is a semi-viable solution, it essentially overlays a "credits" system onto the original network that's especially appropriate for micro-transactions.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by pjc50 on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:45AM (#21427666)
I can't see how a system in which every node has a copy of every transaction forever could ever be suitable for micropayments, which if they took off would be of the order of millions a day.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by tom_mellior on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:02AM (#21427756)
You're assuming that no innovation is possible in this space.

Besides, "every node" is not true of Bitcoin even today. Neither my desktop nor my mobile Bitcoin client save a complete history. Miners need history, but maybe there can be a different model of mining. I'm not a customer at all the credit card companies out there, only one. Maybe I could also be only be a customer of only one fixed "miner" in some future system? Possibly a new but fixed one I can pick per transaction, rather than today's essentially random assignment of who gets my fees? Yes, this wouldn't be Bitcoin anymore, but as I wrote above, I don't think Bitcoin is what we need anyway.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by wruza on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:08AM (#21427786)
>Miners need history

I’m pretty sure that last time I repaired an ASIC it had just one crappy 256MB sd card (which was the reason it needed a repair). Maybe pool coordinators still need history, idk.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by gwern on Saturday November 02, 2019 @04:01PM (#21429715)
You don't need a copy of every transaction forever. Look at MimbleWimble.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by DennisP on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:28AM (#21427878)
The second-largest cryptocurrency is about a year away from a sharding system that multiplies scale by a factor of 512, with room to grow as hardware improves.

That's for purely on-chain transactions. There's also a partly-offchain solution called "zkrollups" that uses zero-knowledge proofs to reduce the storage for a simple value transfer to 11 bytes, without introducing any unpleasant security assumptions like requiring the user to be online to receive payment or prevent cheating. Combining that with sharding gets to about a quarter million tx/sec.

If that's not sufficient for micropayments, it's fairly straightforward to extend zkrollups to make payments probabilistic: e.g. to pay one penny, send a 1% chance of paying a dollar. There are some potential doublespending issues here but for voluntary tips that's not a problem.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by cft on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:33PM (#21429542)
Not only transaction fees, but IRS decision to tax it as property
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by teh_infallible on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:50PM (#21431245)
Bitcoin Cash solved those problems and works flawlessly today.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by buboard on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:09AM (#21427472)
Bitcoin is your cash reserve, its like tour bank account and you dont go to the bank every day. There are multiple solutions to the speed issues. The real issue is that crypto is incompatible with any taxation system everywhere
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by tom_mellior on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:41AM (#21427650)
I don't know what you mean by the bank account analogy. I don't go to the bank everyday, but I can interact with my bank account several times per day. I can make free money transfers to any SEPA account, so this is also part of what micropayments should be. It's just tedious, and the money takes two to three days to arrive.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Saturday November 02, 2019 @02:06PM (#21429086)
That's sort-of not true anymore, SCT Inst is a thing and allows transfers between participating banks within seconds around the clock, every day of the year. It's just that some banks don't seem to see the need, and some think it's somehow a premium feature that you can charge for, some even multiple EUR per transaction (outbound, I don't think anyone charges extra for receiving SCT Inst transfers). But then, many banks seem to understand that that is bullshit and offer it at the same price as regular transfers, which for many banks means free of charge for non-businesses.

I can only hope the former will notice that offering ancient technology is not a good way to keep customers.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by pmarreck on Sunday November 03, 2019 @03:01PM (#21436190)
> It's just tedious, and the money takes two to three days to arrive

So then it's not free. Instead of charging you a transaction fee, they charge you "time", since time is money, and they can make money off the in-flight money (via interest, ostensibly).

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by buboard on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:38AM (#21427930)
i mean that bitcoin has de facto become a store of cash rather than cash at hand. It's indeed not like a bank since there are no chargebacks, no insurance nothing. It's different. But there are also multiple solutions to the speed issue, so speed is not really what s holding back widespread adoption.

SEPA is bank transfers with delays of entire days - that makes them completely unfit for micropayments.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by Scarblac on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:29PM (#21428880)
For much of Europe, SEPA transfers are already as good as instantaneous and I think the other countries will follow.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by stephen_g on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:54AM (#21427711)
Two to three days to arrive? Why?

In Australia, our regular banking system lets you register your mobile phone number (or business/company number or email) as a 'PayID' and then that's all the info you need to send somebody an instant payment... Even our older system usually only takes until the next afternoon or morning on a business day (I believe the older inter-bank payments are settled in two batches per business day).

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by tom_mellior on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:04AM (#21427771)
There is certainly no technical reason for the delay, a transfer should just be a transfer of a few bytes of information.

I think the usual explanation is that this system gives banks a pool of money that they are always free to invest in the time that it's neither in the original owner's nor the recipient's account.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by kalleboo on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:18AM (#21427825)
In some countries, it is common to make even tiny payments (down to 10 cents) directly between bank accounts, instantly, for free. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swish_(payment)
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by tom_mellior on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:21AM (#21433242)
> some countries

The Wikipedia page says "Area served: Sweden" and points out that even Norway and Denmark use similar systems. So this is quite limited. But sure, would be good to have something like this globally.

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by kalleboo on Sunday November 03, 2019 @10:09AM (#21434265)
A sibling comment says there's a similar system in Australia - I don't think the Wikipedia "see also" section is anywhere near exhaustive on this topic, so no idea how many countries are covered.

I agree it would be great to have something like this globally. Or at least to begin with inside of the SEPA (which recently introduced international instant payments)

Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by buboard on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:49AM (#21427986)
it's not cash though (and not global). the promise of cryptocs is that we 're getting back the versatility and anonymity that we had with physical cash
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by chabes on Saturday November 02, 2019 @12:28PM (#21428524)
What about people without bank accounts?
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by Scarblac on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:31PM (#21428892)
I don't actually know if that is feasible in, say, the Netherlands. I've never heard of paying taxes cash, for instance. And jobs pay wages to bank accounts.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by kalleboo on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:23PM (#21431652)
Why would someone not have a bank account? Having a large unbanked population seems like one of those U.S.-centric problems which is rooted in something deeper.
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by coldtea on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:27PM (#21429506)
Those people are usually not the demographic artists and content creators promoting micropayments have in mind in the first place...
Re:Micropayment Barriers (1998) by ryukafalz on Saturday November 02, 2019 @10:50AM (#21427994)
I've been interested in GNU Taler for that reason; it feels like it could be a useful tool for online payments while still being taxable. (Still feels pretty early in development though.)