Re:Delegated Credentials in TLS
by sudoyear123 on Friday November 01, 2019 @02:46PM
(#21422373)
This is a very good question. We actually did consider proxy certs and name constraints certs first and had a long discussion at the IETF about these different options. At the end the consensus was that it would be much better to have a very minimal structure which could only do 1 thing and nothing else. DCs also have the advantage that they are cryptographically bound to a particular End entity certificate vs a particular public key only, and hence can only be used with their properties, so it really is the minimal possible thing you need and nothing more.
Those proxy credentials were primarily for delegating "limited" client/user credentials, which in turn might be used as either the client or server role for subsequent TLS connections during the lifecycle of a distributed, scientific computing job. As I recall, the practical "limited" characteristic in the Globus GSI system was a single bit flag that was interpreted in the ecosystem to prevent recursive delegation, i.e. out of an abundance of caution about things like batch jobs turning into worms.