News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:10AM (#21417893)
Hi, I'm the author of the book.

I believe decentralization in theory could work. But our current situation is so chaotic that there's no clear solution. However, the key here is to understand the full picture.

In the book I argue that there's a big shift going on--not only an economical shift, but also geopolitical and social. And this is going to be a surprise for a lot of people, but this shift is coming from social credit systems and the establishment of a new economic model based on social behavior.

Now, I know this is too complex to explain in a paragraph, but that's why we have books.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by naringas on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:15AM (#21417929)
I think there's also a cultural shift underway.

> a new economic model based on social behavior.

this reminds me of China's social credit scores. It seems to me that this is (in a way) automatic-money. Imagine if instead of having to manage your own balance your "wallet" does it for you. One just shows up at the store and they tell you what you get. No "visible" transaction takes place.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:19AM (#21417962)
Right, and the shift gets even deeper.

Few people know this but money was invented to keep track of debt. In fact, what most economic textbooks say is that money comes from barter. It turns out there's no single evidence that this ever happened in history! (David Graeber has a phenomenal book call Debt that explains all of this.)

Now, the shift we're seeing is that social credit system--or as I call them Social Debt Systems--are going to be "the new money."

Lots of people talk about the data economy and the fact that we need a way to put a dollar value on information.

And what we're seeing with social credit systems is that that value is not 'on' information. It's 'in' information. And that's creating a new economic logic we're not able even to conceive yet

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by pdonis on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:43PM (#21420814)
> money was invented to keep track of debt

I think you're conflating two different usages of the term "money". Wikipedia calls them "money of account" and "money of exchange". Money of account appears to be older, and was, as you say, invented to keep track of debts. But when economics textbooks talk about money being invented to solve the double coincidence of wants problem, which is the main limitation of barter, they are talking about money of exchange.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:59PM (#21421037)
That's the history of coinage, which came after debt.

Debt is older though. It goes back 5,000 years--at least:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt:_The_First_5000_Years

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by pdonis on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:49PM (#21421707)
> That's the history of coinage

"Money of exchange" is, yes. And as I said, that is what economists are talking about when they talk about money replacing barter because it solves the double coincidence of wants problem. Money replacing barter has nothing to do with debt.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by whocanevenremem on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:57AM (#21418188)
I'm not sure they are separable, certainly paper money (and pre-money forms such as hansatsu) are created by issuing a debt, but they were created for the very pragmatic need of bartering without carrying a bunch of gold or rice around.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:05AM (#21418258)
That's what common sense says. But there's no proof that that ever happened. I recommend you to check out Graeber's book. Or you can read my whole explanation in the fourth section of Data Dictatorships.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by mistermann on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:01PM (#21422546)
> In the book I argue that there's a big shift going on--not only an economical shift, but also geopolitical and social. And this is going to be a surprise for a lot of people, but this shift is coming from social credit systems and the establishment of a new economic model based on social behavior.

I'm glad to see you chimed in here with this additional detail, because after reading the overview:

> There’s currently a geopolitical arms race taking place to merge biotech and infotech to hack humankind. Technological disruption is creating an unprecedented realm of opportunities for authoritarian regimes to flourish.

...I got the impression that you thought the main issue with mass data collection was somehow to provide an advantage in biological engineering, when the most obvious advantage seems to me to be analysis of human behavior such that it can understood (to the best of our current but ever improving capabilities) and shaped in various ways. Some of the shaping techniques may be considered (by Westerners) to be nefarious I imagine, but I see no reason why such shaping has to be nefarious, but rather if done properly, may very well be in a way that can be overwhelmingly aggregate net positive to those being shaped.

I've been thinking about how in the long term an authoritarian China with a fully modern technological surveillance state coupled with wise leadership and a (correspondingly) supportive citizenship might have a massive advantage over traditional democracies. The typical thinking on the matter seems to be roughly: because all historic authoritarian states eventually collapsed while democracies tended to flourish, then therefore a completely risk-free assumption can be made that this pattern will persist into the future, always and everywhere, without exception, and therefore there is absolutely no need to consider the possibility that this historic pattern may not materialize. To me, this seems like very dangerous thinking based on extremely poor logic.

I'm curious what your thoughts are on the matter, and whether this is a theme you touch upon in your book.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:34PM (#21422834)
The thing is that you can't make a point in two paragraphs. You can state something, but it leaves room for all sorts of interpretations.

I cover all these points in the book. But just to be clear this isn't just about China as the bad guy--the US is in the same direction.

I agree on your point about that in the past democracies ended up winning. But today we're seeing that the technological disruption is killing the very essence that makes democratic society democratic. The fact is that liberal democracies have to evolve or Data Dictatorships are going to take over.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by excalibur on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:03AM (#21418910)
> Liberal democracy is going to die. Data is becoming the raw materialization of power, and this is making dictatorships more efficient than ever before.

Why not make the data public? If data is power, you criminalize the hoarding of data, and require it to be shared openly with all. We would still be headed toward a surveillance state, which comes with a high risk of authoritarianism, but at least we would have a shot at keeping it democratic.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:08AM (#21418989)
The thing is that data by itself is useless. You need the right infrastructure to make it work. Data without context is not information.

But the point here is that there's data that shouldn't be collected in the first place. And that data, especially biometric data, is what allows data autocrats hack human beings. And you don't need a lot of data to hack a human being. Just enough to know someone better than that person knows himself or herself.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by naringas on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:20AM (#21419129)
> But the point here is that there's data that shouldn't be collected in the first place

I just don't think that's feasible. The cat cannot be put back in the box (so to speak).

I think the solution goes more in line with open transparency. Yet individual privacy is really important.

The only way through, I think, is to guarantee individual privacy but enforce institutional transparency.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:26AM (#21419194)
The problem of this way of thinking is that it makes “okay” to collect data that is not necessary for the app in order to work.

It's not feasible because there's a huge economic logic behind that data collection. While the truth is that most services (even innovation) would still work with a few data points.

I mean, Google Maps doesn’t need to collect all the data it collects, but it sells us the benefit with an imminent long-tail of problems.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by bilbo0s on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:12AM (#21419032)
>at least we would have a shot at keeping it democratic

If by democratic you mean freedom to form outrage mobs then I'd agree, but I don't think that would be a good thing. Having thousands of people in some community screaming for the head of some kid who said something dumb about his school and his dad's rifle on a Call of Duty discord is not going to end well for the kid.

I'm not sure I believe in completely open data because entire populations with access to it are not completely rational.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by excalibur on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:38AM (#21419307)
Weird that we're having the same discussion on two different threads, I suppose I started it.

> If by democratic you mean freedom to form outrage mobs then I'd agree, but I don't think that would be a good thing.

I don't think it would be an objectively good thing either. I only think it may be better than the alternative. Given a choice between an authoritarian dictatorship and an authoritarian democracy, I lean toward the latter.

Additionally, I think you may not be giving people enough credit. Devolution of democracy to mob rule is certainly a danger, but I don't know that it's a foregone conclusion. I don't how to go about preserving individual liberty without privacy, but as long as the common man has power it should be possible in theory.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by bilbo0s on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:49AM (#21419411)
I mean if you're going into this whole thing with your eyes open and you're saying, "I know that I'm just replacing authoritarian dictatorship with authoritarian democracy." Then we have no debate.

You're fully aware of the danger of what's coming. Just be aware, authoritarian democracy with full open access to the totality of everyone's data is not really authoritarian democracy.

It's totalitarian democracy. Just that small nit pick but other than that, if you know what you're getting into, go for it.

I just disagree with that trade off.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by naringas on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:27AM (#21419199)
> I'm not sure I believe in completely open data because entire populations with access to it are not completely rational.

certainly not. but we are at the beginning of a cultural shift in line with the renaissance and the age of enlightnement which vastly changed the cultural mindset quite a bit. before these previous 'cultural revolutions' what people considered rational was different.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by bilbo0s on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:43AM (#21419340)
I think we agree that we are in the middle of a cultural shift, but I don't think it's going where you think it is.

It's exactly this cultural shift that I'm worried about. What exactly does crowdsourced school security look like in an environment of radically open data?

I just think you're being very optimistic.

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by naringas on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:30PM (#21421457)
no one can tell where will end up.

regardless, I don't think it's optimism because I don't think I will leave long enough to see such a world, at best we will leave through the roughest part of the shift. this level of cultural transformation takes more tha a few of generations.

in any case, I see something else regarding the way in which individual humans are aware of the relationship to their supporting society which translates up to the way in which a distinct society sees itself as a component of a larger system.

where do you think this is going?

Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind by vixen99 on Friday November 01, 2019 @10:38AM (#21419301)
As against the populations which are completely rational as determined by whom?