Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind
by pdonis on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:43PM
(#21420814)
> money was invented to keep track of debt
I think you're conflating two different usages of the term "money". Wikipedia calls them "money of account" and "money of exchange". Money of account appears to be older, and was, as you say, invented to keep track of debts. But when economics textbooks talk about money being invented to solve the double coincidence of wants problem, which is the main limitation of barter, they are talking about money of exchange.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind
by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:59PM
(#21421037)
That's the history of coinage, which came after debt.
Debt is older though. It goes back 5,000 years--at least:
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind
by pdonis on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:49PM
(#21421707)
> That's the history of coinage
"Money of exchange" is, yes. And as I said, that is what economists are talking about when they talk about money replacing barter because it solves the double coincidence of wants problem. Money replacing barter has nothing to do with debt.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind
by whocanevenremem on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:57AM
(#21418188)
I'm not sure they are separable, certainly paper money (and pre-money forms such as hansatsu) are created by issuing a debt, but they were created for the very pragmatic need of bartering without carrying a bunch of gold or rice around.
Re:Data Dictatorships: The Arms Race to Hack Humankind
by borjamoya on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:05AM
(#21418258)
That's what common sense says. But there's no proof that that ever happened. I recommend you to check out Graeber's book. Or you can read my whole explanation in the fourth section of Data Dictatorships.
Few people know this but money was invented to keep track of debt. In fact, what most economic textbooks say is that money comes from barter. It turns out there's no single evidence that this ever happened in history! (David Graeber has a phenomenal book call Debt that explains all of this.)
Now, the shift we're seeing is that social credit system--or as I call them Social Debt Systems--are going to be "the new money."
Lots of people talk about the data economy and the fact that we need a way to put a dollar value on information.
And what we're seeing with social credit systems is that that value is not 'on' information. It's 'in' information. And that's creating a new economic logic we're not able even to conceive yet