News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CleanFlicks by scarface74 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:11AM (#21407491)
Would you want your creative work edited to say something you didn’t intend it to say and still have your name attached to it?
Re:CleanFlicks by beerandt on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:10AM (#21409643)
That's irrelevant. I'd argue, at a minimum, that this falls under fair use, if not by statue/regs, then by principle.

Obviously there's a process in place for when movies are edited for TV. More times than not, nowadays it's not even for censorship, but to cut down time so they can add more commercials. That's more of editing a work specifically for direct financial gain than what we're taking about here.

Re:CleanFlicks by scarface74 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:48AM (#21410048)
So the law as interpreted by the court is “irrelevant” but your interpretation of the “principal” is? There has never been a precedent saying that you could modify a work as you see fit and redistribute it.

Obviously there's a process in place for when movies are edited for TV.

Yes that “process” is that the copyright holder edits the content. Not some random third party.

Re:CleanFlicks by beerandt on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:44PM (#21421661)
1) It's irrelevant because First Sale Doctrine (SCOTUS Bobbs-Merrill Co. v. Straus 1908 and 17 U.S.C. 109) extinguishes any distribution rights a copyright owner might have to a copy which has been (legally) sold.

2) The "principles" aren't my interpretation, they are derived from common-law and codified under "Fair Use" (17USC107). Additionally (108-112) adds specific cases which are automatically deemed Fair Use. More Fair Use cases may be determined by some administrative actions, including determinations by the US Library of Congress.

I'm merely arguing CleanFlicks falls under the principles general Fair Use (107) if not already covered by one of the specified use exemptions (108-112 et al).

>There has never been a precedent saying that you could modify a work as you see fit and redistribute it.

Sony Corp. v. Universal City Studios (464 U.S. 417) (1984) is the infamous betamax case, which legalized time-shifted viewing, even when the viewer had to make an "unauthorized copy" of up to and including 100% of the content in order to accomplish it, as it involved content freely broadcast over-the-air. As one of the codified principles of Fair Use takes into account the proportion of the work copied, this and their language in the case text implies a less than 100% copy would be permissible as well.

The CleanFlicks technology is simply an automated version of the betamax time-shifting.

>Yes that “process” is that the copyright holder edits the content. Not some random third party

Sometimes they might sell/license a censored version, but certainly not always. And not some random third party, but a party that has legally licensed use of the work (including broadcasters, DVD purchasers, or broadcast viewers).

For example, South Park refused to edit their Mohammed episode, but Comedy Central edited it themselves before broadcast. And I seriously doubt copyright owners edit their works for time-compression; it's TBS-TNT-etc that are trying to cram-in more commercials and have rigid scheduling to accommodate. Also, it's now standard practice for broadcasters to edit, time-compress, or completely re-create the credits of TV shows, which are certainly considered to be part of the copyrighted work, as they are typically overlaid earlier in the episode.

Re:CleanFlicks by wodenokoto on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:49AM (#21408682)
No, but on the other hand I also don't want copyright holders to decide if and what parts of a video I am allowed to fast-forward in, or if I am allowed to skip chapters or paragraphs in a book.
Re:CleanFlicks by scarface74 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:57AM (#21408786)
They were actually modifying the original content and distributing it.
Re:CleanFlicks by beatgammit on Friday November 01, 2019 @11:36PM (#21425734)
And it was clearly marked as being edited.

Should I be restricted from modifying products for my personal use? If not, what if I choose to pay someone to make the edits for me? If that's okay, what about purchasing an already edited version? If it's clearly marked as an edited version and I'm purchasing the original as well, I really don't see the problem with a value added product like this.

If I produce some content and people choose to edit it, I really don't care as long as they give me the proper credit (as in, they pay my retail price) and clearly indicate that changes have been made (as well as a list of changes). Something like "X by Y with modifications made by Z (detailed list of changes inside)", where X is the work, Y is the copyright holder, and Z is the retailer.