News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by nabla9 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @12:11PM (#21399261)
Sparta was like North Korea of Ancient Greece.

- Isolationist country.

- Young are indoctrinated in rigid militant ideology (agoge).

- Weak economy. Little to no valuable goods were produced. People not allowed to have valuable money, just worthless tokens.

- The main job of the spartan army was to suppress helots and protect the old rulers. People serve the military and the state, not the other way around.

- No creativity in warfare. Incompetents and arrogant leaders just attack with hoplites until they run out of food and have to retreat.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by HenryBemis on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:06PM (#21400644)
> North Korea

You cannot simply make a comparison of X democracy today (or dictatorship in this case) to a city-state of Ancient Greece. Back then it was do or die. Wars were in the daily menu. For a state that was isolated geographically (in comparison to other powerful/richer city-states like Athens or Messina, the only way to stay alive is brute force, be the ultimate killing machine. The landscape also didn't help much. Stuck between two mountains, path to the north lead nowhere, sea to the south was 30-40km away. Perfect place to make it difficult to be invaded but poor enough to not thrive.

Also.. creativity? I would need creativity to beat a MMA pro in a fight. On his side, he would just throw a punch. Creativity is for the weak! (like me)

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by vkou on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:28PM (#21403575)
North Korea is actually a very apt analogy, because ~85% of people living in Sparta were chattel slaves... Who were, as part of a Spartan citizen's right of passage into manhood (And, in addition to that, as a fun annual holiday), were hunted, and killed for sport.

Actually, even North Korea sounds like the worker's paradise, in comparison.

(And no, this state of affairs was not common among Mediterranean city states. Athens and later Rome had a ~50% slave population, and (legally) considered killing a slave to be murder.)

As for staying alive through brute force, I may observe that your city-state may be able to stay alive more successfully, if it didn't spend most of its time warring against its own enslaved people. Which is what the Spartans did. (Hint: Hunting your slaves for sport does not endear you to them... In a state where 6 out of 7 men are enslaved, and two thirds of the freedmen hate the guts of the ruling class.)

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by jcranmer on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:39PM (#21402412)
Except Sparta doesn't seem to have actually been particularly successful militarily, instead relying more on a reputation for military success, according to this analysis.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by yongjik on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @07:27PM (#21404132)
...so, more like North Korea? :)

"Get out of my way! I'm a crazy madman who may start war at the slightest provocation, and I don't care that it will also kill me!" has been NK's signature shtick for decades. Other than a few nukes and a crapton of grunt soldiers, their military power is actually rather underwhelming.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by nabla9 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:07PM (#21403365)
"Was like North Korea of Ancient Greece" was not direct comparison. It's relative analogy like chicken:egg :: tree:seed.

Sparta:Athens :: North Korea:South Korea

Sparta was to Athens like North Korea is to South Korea.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by scott_s on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:33PM (#21402340)
That's the author's conclusion in the final paragraph of the final entry.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by friendlybus on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:48PM (#21402519)
Your descriptive points are closer to Pakistan than NK.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by friendlybus on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @09:13PM (#21404756)
I'm serious. Pakistan relies on it's military state more than you would think. Nk is actively corrupt and all-worshipping of the diety-leader kim jong in a way both Sparta and Pakistan are not. Nk actively seeks to control and suppress domestic traders with power where it can and enslaves people into work camp gulags. Those are unique distinctions from Sparta and Pakistan.
[dead]
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by dang on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:28PM (#21402257)
Please don't post flamebait to Hacker News. When this kind of thing starts a flamewar, if it isn't arson it's certainly negligence.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by shantly on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:37PM (#21401648)
More like a company town paying in scrip. Dollars trade just fine outside the borders of the US, for non-US goods and services. Or at least trade readily for other things that do, in the worst case.