News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by ulkesh on Monday October 28, 2019 @05:59PM (#21382171)
I have been hearing this end-of-the-IPv4 world chatter for 10+ years now. While I understand it is a real problem, I wonder if we’ll still be talking about it in the present tense 10 years from now.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by zenexer on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:40PM (#21382526)
The internet can continue operating and growing without IPv6; it just won't be pretty. More and more endpoints will have to share a single IPv4 address; that's possible, but it can cause a variety of problems. I'm not really qualified to assess their severity on such large scales, but similar scenarios are known for being problematic at small scales.

It might seem like it makes more sense to switch to IPv6 than to deal with the issues of IPv4, but the entities that have to deal with problems that result from IPv4 depletion usually aren't the same entities impeding the adoption of IPv6.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by ATsch on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @12:21AM (#21384225)
Two big reasons that Microsoft says have caused them to start pushing v6 adoption internally from around 2017 are:

a) struggling to implement proper IP based access control with their available address space.

b) as everyone uses the same 16 or so bits of Private IPv4 space, every acquisition likely causes new IPv4 address space collisions which must be worked around.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by mlyle on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:13AM (#21384399)
> b) as everyone uses the same 16 or so bits of Private IPv4 space, every acquisition likely causes new IPv4 address space collisions which must be worked around.

I mostly agree, but this overstates thing some. 10/8 offers 24 bits, 192.168 offers 16 bits, and 172.16-172.31 offers 20 bits.

The latter are particularly frequently unused; if you pick one of 172.20-172.28 to cram into you have a high chance of not crashing into someone else when you integrate networks. Particularly if you use the upper half of the resultant class b.

Of course RFC 4193 for IPv6 is very nice; pick your own random 40 bit prefix, and get to run 65536 subnets of arbitrary size. You need to integrate ~2^20-- a million-- networks before you have a 50% chance of having encountered a collision.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by ATsch on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:51AM (#21384524)
> 172.16-172.31 are particularly frequently unused

haha, I wish. We decided to use them two decades ago exactly because we thought they were less frequently used, but then a decade later docker comes along and uses exactly that as a default NAT subnet. So we get multiple tickets about that a week.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by saurik on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @03:32AM (#21384868)
What kind of issues is this causing you / your users?
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by ATsch on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @04:11AM (#21385035)
Well, the complaint usually goes like this:

"we recently set up service x, and it seems to be working fine. However, when we try to connect from the campus wifi, or a certain department, the service does not respond".

What happens is the server gets a request from a private IP within the range assigned to docker0, and then the container replies, but because the IP is believed to be local, linux correctly tries to find something attached to the docker0 interface with that IP and fails.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by Aperocky on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @02:01AM (#21384559)
And this (continued) idea is called local - Or subnet in cloudspeak. You can have thousands of distinct hosts which are then routed to the internet through a balancer. Frankly, it may have been a more efficient network then everyone having their own 10 IPv6 addresses.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by fortran77 on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:08PM (#21382248)
It's like "peak oil." They keep saying we'll run out, but if we keep drilling or fracking, we keep finding more.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by p1mrx on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:47PM (#21382582)
IPv4 addresses are more like land than oil. We're never going to find any more, but they aren't consumed, and existing ones can be traded.

IPv6 lets us build in the sky, where space is no longer a constraint.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday October 28, 2019 @08:19PM (#21383174)
I'm patiently waiting for the day where someone tries to block usage of IPv4 addresses to increase the value of their own, much in the same way is done with actual land today.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by mysterydip on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:57PM (#21382655)
There are no more, but there are a lot wasted. In the early days when it was assumed everything would be publicly accessible, large organizations were given class A's or more.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by Dagger2 on Monday October 28, 2019 @07:06PM (#21382733)
Not as much as you think. There are only about 20 /8s owned by companies (and those companies are using those /8s for their networks!).

Before IANA runout in 2011 we were going through one /8 every month; given that demand has only gone up since then, 20 /8s would be, what, a 12 month supply or so? v4 is just too small, and no amount of pushing allocations around is going to change that.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by nucleardog on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @03:53AM (#21384949)
While the addresses are largely in use (though I'd wager ham radio operators aren't using much of 44/8), are they really necessary?

Does the UK Ministry of Defense actually have 16 million devices that need publicly routable addresses? Or could they be doing what almost everyone else is doing and using a handful of publicly routable addresses and private IP ranges behind them?

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by Dagger2 on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @09:06AM (#21386639)
No, of course they're not necessary. They could turn off all their computers and then they wouldn't need any address space at all. But there are benefits to having networked computers, and there are benefits to doing that networking correctly and not paying the costs of NAT and overlapped address space.

It would take them years to renumber off of their /8, at great cost and with the result of an increased ongoing operational cost, and for what benefit? That /8 would last the public internet for less than a month. It's not like the people who are yet to deploy v6 are suffering a lack of time, so buying them an extra month which they would then squander isn't going to be very helpful.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by rednixion on Monday October 28, 2019 @07:08PM (#21382748)
Classless networking used to not exist and a lot of universities being early adopters and some companies ended up with with class B's at least. Anyone in the US(who isn't one of the said universities) likely already had the address range taken back due to noteworthy underutilization though. We lost two class C's a few years ago due to this reason but it was hard to complain about since we weren't really using them.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by p1mrx on Monday October 28, 2019 @07:04PM (#21382722)
There's a lot of wasted land too (e.g. single-story buildings in the Bay Area.)

In any case, many of those "wasted" /8s have been resold for $100M+ in the last decade. Grep this page for "formerly" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_assigned_/8_IPv4_addre...

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by kstrauser on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:19PM (#21382349)
That's a great analogy. Like peak oil, we've passed the point of exhausting the cheap, plentiful reserves. Now we're scrounging for harder-to-get, scarcer deposits which means that the prices of both will go up, inevitably.

No, we're not out of oil or IPv4 addresses. It's just getting a lot harder to come by either one, and the writing's on the wall that the invisible hand is able to slap us silly if we don't seriously start migrating to the replacements ASAP.

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by michaelsbradley on Monday October 28, 2019 @07:06PM (#21382732)
I distinctly remembering hearing about it in the late 1990s during my university years (chatter among the computer lab staff). It’s amazing how long it’s dragged on.
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by rolltiide on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:17PM (#21382326)
One company is running out of addresses this time
Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by zenexer on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:35PM (#21382495)
It's not just a "company". Someone has to decide who's in charge of which IP addresses. IANA is the overarching authority; they then delegates large swaths of IP addresses to regional organizations. RIPE is in charge of Europe.

It would be more accurate to say one continent has run out of IPv4 addresses, but even that isn't entirely accurate. As IPv4 addresses have become scarcer and scarcer, it's become common for companies to obtain IP addresses from registries other than the one that handles their region.

In other words: RIPE is in charge of assigning IP addresses. They're running out of IPv4 addresses to assign to other organizations. That's different from a single company running out of IPv4 addresses, which just means they need to buy more addresses (or find an alternative solution).

Re:Ripe NIC: 'In Five Weeks We'll Run Out of IPv4 Internet A... by rsynnott on Monday October 28, 2019 @06:57PM (#21382660)
One _continent_. (Or 1.5, really; RIPE also handles a decent chunk of Asia).