Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by kuschku on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:17AM
(#21376642)
Identifying people is easy, the much harder part is finding the right path to take as result. In a dense european street you’ll have pedestrians, cyclists, and so on all around you.
Imagine driving slowly through a large gathering of people, slowly having them move around your car, etc. Such situations will necessarily become major issues.
Especially if you imagine a snowy dense downtown street, with pedestrians crossing everywhere and snow all around you making the LIDAR useless.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by acollins1331 on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:07AM
(#21376562)
That's not something you'll find a citation for. As someone who has worked in the industry it's not as simple as "see child; stop". What's also happening behind you? Beside of you? Do you swerve? How quickly do you stop?
You're very right that OD works great, that doesn't mean you can train a neural network to make the right decision though.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by fastball on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:46AM
(#21376909)
You barely even need NN for this - it's basically pathfinding.
Find the path to where you want to go, avoid the parts with negative weights.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by acollins1331 on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:48AM
(#21376929)
Great idea, maybe you should call Waymo.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by fastball on Monday October 28, 2019 @11:22AM
(#21377750)
It's not a great idea because it's already done.
Again, the hard part is not "here is a human, avoid it". That part is done (in Waymo's case).
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by simonh on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:16AM
(#21376637)
I'm afraid asking for a citation for a forward looking speculative statement doesn't come across very well.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by fastball on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:45AM
(#21376900)
But making wild speculation without any evidence comes across better?
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by simonh on Monday October 28, 2019 @12:09PM
(#21378212)
Yes, it's just an opinion stated politely and unagressively. Those are valuable qualities that I appreciate.
Re:Steve Wozniak: 'I've given up' on Level 5
by fastball on Monday October 28, 2019 @09:24PM
(#21383498)
Except OC was stating it more like fact than opinion, which is exactly why I took issue with it.
We can very accurately identify children, pedestrians, cyclists, and street vendors with machine vision. And with the LIDAR that Waymo is using, very accurately tell where they are and more importantly where they're going. Stopping for those things is pretty low on the "problems that need more work for Level 5" agenda.