News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney Is Placing Classic Fox Movies into Its Vault by whateveracct on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:06PM (#21373551)
Some of the movies mentioned are well over 50 years old though, so copyright is a root cause even if it isn't the root cause.
Re:Disney Is Placing Classic Fox Movies into Its Vault by teh_klev on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:37PM (#21373646)
> so copyright is a root cause even if it isn't the root cause.

That assertion makes absolutely no sense. Fifty years isn't a huge amount of time and the bulk of Fox's catalogue (that's actually interesting, well for me anyway) is younger than that so your copyright argument doesn't stand up.

To re-iterate, this article is about restricting access to cinemas to play these movies in their theatres. The distribution format for cinemas and their equipment is, as far as I know, somewhat different from buying a DVD or BluRay off of Amazon. Even a ten year copyright period wouldn't solve the problem of the studios withholding the technical formats that are needed for their content to be played in a theatre. They simply don't have to give that up.

Personally I don't have a problem with studios owning the copyright for say 75 years, that seems like a fair amount of time...provided the studio's play fair with access to their content.

Sure what Disney are doing is a shitty thing, but it's certainly not as simple as claiming that reforming the copyright rules would solve this.

Re:Disney Is Placing Classic Fox Movies into Its Vault by beerandt on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:58PM (#21373883)
Also, just because copyright is up, one still needs physical access to the media to copy it. I'm not sure how that is (or should be) handled with film.