News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by ahartmetz on Sunday October 27, 2019 @08:45AM (#21369363)
Adam Smith is very selectively quoted by "free market" types...
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by NeedMoreTea on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:39AM (#21369962)
Yes, they always seem to neglect his views on corporations for some peculiar reasons.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by dmix on Sunday October 27, 2019 @08:12PM (#21373359)
What free market type supports individual corporations writing laws that benefit themselves over their customers and competition? Boeing is already the only player in town, they aren't writing laws to benefit anyone but themselves, they aren't trying to increase competition or open up the markets.

Markets are built both on corporations openly trading value to customers for money and competition keeping that system alive and healthy as markets/products/technology/organizations naturally grow and die and economies fluctuate. Stasis and one-sided deals are unsustainable, which is what this type of arrangement buys you.

Corporations being allowed to use state power for their own benefit (at the expense of their customers and/or competition) has nothing to do with free markets. All you're left with then are companies who rake in money from customers without trading full value or excluding competition from existing. That's not a market or a useful system for any society.

Regulations to serve some higher public good that markets can't practically account for are very different from individual corporations writing laws to benefit only themselves in the marketplace. Boeing selling more dangerous airplanes (even if that happens through government coordinated processes) and losing Airline customer's trust would be terrible for any real business, assuming there is competition and customers who aren't forced to buy from them.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by sonotathrowaway on Monday October 28, 2019 @02:13PM (#21379811)
They take his ideas and apply them to healthcare markets, then specifically ignore his ideas about healthcare markets.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by LMYahooTFY on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:03AM (#21369452)
How is your comment relevant? Smith's words are extremely apt here, and don't speak to a "free market" ideology at all.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by andrewflnr on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:59AM (#21369710)
Maybe I'm a weirdo, but I think that quote is in general extremely apt for free market ideology. Businesses don't like free markets as much as they like markets tilted in their own favor. If you want an actual free market, you have to watch out for businesses trying to break it through legislation.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by ahartmetz on Sunday October 27, 2019 @11:04AM (#21370148)
I put the scare quotes around "free market" because the usual selective Adam Smith quote is used to support no regulation (selectively) for the benefit of corporations, usually a certain corporation or group of corporations.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by andrewflnr on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:40PM (#21373826)
Um, right. AFAICT Adam Smith was a principled free market thinker (the quote above only confirms it in my view), as opposed to the ones who only claim to be free-marketeers. I think you always have to distinguish between the actual free-market ideas vs the self-motivated people selectively using "free-market" buzzphrases for their own ends, where "free-market" can be substituted with almost any ideology you can think of. I felt the comment I was replying to conflated the two.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by njacobs5074 on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:55AM (#21370086)
I thought that the “free” in “free markets” meant that corporations are free to do what they want.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by marvin on Sunday October 27, 2019 @04:04PM (#21372029)
Not an economist, but I rather figured it means that markets are regulated in a way that properly allows and encourages competition. No monopolies, no anti-competitive practices, no pricing or wage collusion, no regulatory capture etc. I'm sure this can be interpreted in as many ways as there are special interest groups, though.

E.g, radically, labor markets in the absence of a basic income system are not really free, since employees starve and lose their homes if they do not accept the best available offer. Hence companies' competition for paid labor is not really free, and most groups have an existential threat if they do not accept the terms of the employers that are willing to employ them.

There are a million aspects to this that I'm not an expert in, but many of the "free market" principles are considered in the context of contrasting a market economy vs. a planned economy.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by x86_64Ubuntu on Sunday October 27, 2019 @05:17PM (#21372463)
Well, maybe. In common discourse, "free market" is used to downplay the need for government regulation concerning things like labor rights, pollution and anti-consumer/predatory behavior.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by WalterBright on Sunday October 27, 2019 @05:27PM (#21372522)
No. Use of fraud and force is not part of a free market. A free market also requires a disinterested system of contracts and enforcement of those contracts in order to work, which is what the government is needed to provide.

Free market means people can voluntarily engage in transactions without the government interfering in those transactions, such as when the government sets the price of some good.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by stuaxo on Sunday October 27, 2019 @03:43PM (#21371911)
That's how it's interpreted, but of course it is the opposite of a free market as it means they are free to stop new entrants into that very same market.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by ahartmetz on Sunday October 27, 2019 @11:04AM (#21370151)
Yes.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by goatlover on Sunday October 27, 2019 @04:41PM (#21372245)
Which means Adam Smith was not a proponent of "free markets".
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by wmeredith on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:07AM (#21369468)
I think that IS the the point
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by bnegreve on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:09AM (#21369474)
Quotes are made by people and it is often relevant to know who these people were to understand the quote.

It applies in this particular case: I'm not very familiar with Smith's work, and I am a bit puzzled that this quote is from him.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by dnautics on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:01AM (#21369725)
It's totally adam smith, also the author of "the theory of moral sentiment" which is a fantastic exposition about why as societies we coordinate our morals and ethics. "Free market type"s are often the first to complain about regulatory capture.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by mpweiher on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:11AM (#21369481)
Guessing: the comment you replied to was referring to those who do not include the words quoted here
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by agumonkey on Sunday October 27, 2019 @09:13AM (#21369491)
All early thinkers are. Curse of applied myopia.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by stuaxo on Sunday October 27, 2019 @03:42PM (#21371898)
Sure, though he has "The Adam Smith Institute" being selective for him.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by ImprovedSilence on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:07AM (#21369759)
Some of us free market types realize there is a difference between the corporatism of today’s world, and the capitalism of where we’d like to be. And that often regulation needs to be in place to protect capitalism from the tyranny of corporatism. Unfortunately the “free market” and “capitalism” are exactly the words corporatists use to get voters on their sides.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by coldtea on Sunday October 27, 2019 @01:19PM (#21371022)
>Some of us free market types realize there is a difference between the corporatism of today’s world, and the capitalism of where we’d like to be

Yes, the difference is one exists and is bad (like "really existing socialism" existed and was bad), and the other is an unrealistic utopia like communism.

A utopian market without sucker consumers, without business people willing to exploit it and without powerful companies taking advantage of it, and somehow, with less government as well...

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by anigbrowl on Sunday October 27, 2019 @04:29PM (#21372178)
Capitalism is by definition the idea of capital as the organizing principle of society. No matter how idealistic a conception of capitalism you hold, it's still the reification of profit over people.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by doyoulikeworms on Sunday October 27, 2019 @07:59PM (#21373292)
This is like describing socialism as being about authoritarian governments and centrally planned economies. Everybody misuses labels to their advantage.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by cle on Sunday October 27, 2019 @05:42PM (#21372612)
My understanding of capitalist arguments is that they think "profits" vs. "people" is a false dichotomy.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by beefield on Sunday October 27, 2019 @12:20PM (#21370651)
I'm quite sure there are communists who realize a difference between the communism of the soviet union and the communism they would like to be in.

Unfortunately you are not allowed to pick only the good side of the people that supports the feasibility of your chosen ideological utopia.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by endtime on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:01AM (#21369719)
As a free market type, I don't see the supposed conflict at all. A free market is more or less orthogonal to the legislative process. Free market types should absolutely want the legislature to be careful not to adopt laws which subtly distort the market in favor of some versus others.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by chongli on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:44AM (#21369996)
Politics itself is part of the market. Politicians participate in the marketplace of ideas, they require money to market their ideas (campaign financing), and they compete with one another for power and influence. Government both regulates and participates in the market through contracts, causing prices to change, just as any other large participant does.

The criticism I offer for all “free market” types is this: it is naïve to ask, let alone hope, for government to act as an impartial referee. Government is a player with its own agenda. It always has been and, for as long as it is made up of self-interested human beings, it always will be.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by endtime on Sunday October 27, 2019 @05:17PM (#21372458)
> Politics itself is part of the market.

This is fudging the word "market" a bit. Free market advocates think that everyone should be able to, say, sell paperclips without the government getting involved. Saying that regulation is "part of the market" suggests some kind of misunderstanding of what a free market is.

> it is naïve to ask, let alone hope, for government to act as an impartial referee.

In practice, I agree. It's also naive to hope for the government to faithfully align with almost any political ideology, e.g. progressivism. I don't see that as a flaw of the ideology itself.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by chongli on Sunday October 27, 2019 @06:55PM (#21373009)
I don't see that as a flaw of the ideology itself.

I have similar quibbles with other ideologies. Really, my strongest criticism is reserved for ideological purists who come in all shapes and sizes. To put it plainly, I believe all ideologies are reductive and lead to absurdities when broadly applied, particularly to other human beings.

Pragmatism is the approach I prefer. What separates it from an ideology is that it doesn't attempt to cram the world into a tiny box. It's a tool that would work even in an unreliable universe and it affords complex human beings the respect they deserve.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by rebuilder on Sunday October 27, 2019 @11:51AM (#21370485)
And, absent government regulation, market participants with the influence and wealth required will provide their own.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by edoceo on Sunday October 27, 2019 @01:26PM (#21371080)
Basically government is the Biggest Company with a strong-arm division for enforcement of EULA.
Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by blotter_paper on Sunday October 27, 2019 @05:42PM (#21372608)
There's already a word for a company with a strong-arm division: gang. The government is the biggest gang -- claiming and enforcing a monopoly of violence in a particular geographic area is the defining feature of a government. If the Sinaloa cartel becomes more powerful than the Mexican government, it will become the Mexican government. It effectively already is in some municipalities: https://www.npr.org/2014/02/24/282123622/ruthless-mexican-dr...

> Because of Guzman, she says, everything is under control — people don't steal, kidnap or extort here. And the partiers say he helped the poor, paved roads, gave people jobs — the list of good deeds goes on.

Re:Before Deadly Crashes, Boeing Pushed for Law That Undercu... by pytester on Sunday October 27, 2019 @10:37AM (#21369949)
I'm pretty sure it'd be impossible to point to any market anywhere and say "that's distortion free". By arguing that congress shouldn't adopt laws that "subtly distort" you're kind of making an appeal to conservatism (small c) rather than economic efficiency.