if you criticize me, it feels personal. who is right, and who is wrong does not matter. we could even be both right. if the communication about work is all we have, and on top of that you are maybe a senior when i am a junior then i may well be intimidated by you, making it very difficult for me to talk to you to resolve the problem.
if on the other hand we also have an experience playing together, and in those times you appear as a very cooperative person, supportive when i make mistakes, etc, then my perception of you as a person as a whole changes, and you will be much less intimidating to me. maybe when i see you in a good mood after the game i find it a good opportunity to ask you about my last pull request.
there is of course no guarantee that that will work. but the point is, there is a chance. without that opening created through that atmosphere there is none.
to put it differently, games can be a team-building exercise. you can put other activities there, but that bonding is a critical part of a team that has difficult work to do where disagreements often need to be resolved. there has to be something that reminds us that we are still friends, and gives us the strength to pull through difficult moments.
so yes, even if you are right, you still need to ask, and not only pretend, you really need to ask and make a serious effort to understand my approach to solve the problem, and then, only then you can try to explain to me, using my own approach, why that is wrong, and why yours is better.
No boardgames needed.
And also, much better strategy is to tell what I think, bease then supervisors personality shows soon and I can figure it out and leave soon. If it takes courage and pretending to disagree, then it is good idea to work elsewhere.
It sounds like horrible way to do code reviews.
the situation i was thinking of applies more to cases where the supervisor is remote and you have no personal contact.
so really the problem here is that in remote communication people come across differently than in person. they may actually act differently than in person, because they may not even be aware how they come across.
in such a situation knowing the supervisor through a different activity (and that could be to play boardgames at the yearly company meet) can make a difference.
i have seen this example from FOSS developers who got a certain reputation online, but came across very differently when i met them in person at a conference.
I realize that by seeing that the reviews are consistent, everybody is hold to the same stable standard and by seeing that differences of opinions are accepted with respect and open discussion.
Code review can be personal, can be about packing order, can be about someones autism, can be wrong and can be none of those things. Boardgame does not changes anything if you do the above, people will figure it out.
> maybe you'll even work up the courage to ask me for advice instead of sulking and giving up, or starting an argument
Why do I need courage to ask you? Why am I expected to be afraid of you? Why would a game cancel my reasons to be afraid and wouldn't it better to not scare me in the first place?
What if I am right, do I have to pretend ask for advice too? Why am I assumed to be the problem and left very little options how to act when we two disagree?