Though to be fair, it's not like people down the org chart are usually much better at it.
I think it’s a bit unfair to point the finger at “C-level management” in particular though. The same kind of thinking can be observed in government agencies, in the legal system, even in academia. Statistics is just hard, and a lot of people are simply not interested and cognitively capable enough to get it right, sadly.
This is how executives discredit engineers. Someone who believes themself to be intellectually superior to others and is socially inept enough to say so is an easy target to discredit. This is how you become a code monkey.
People love to set social norms that limit how much use others can make of their talents and abilities. But that’s usually not in the company’s best interest, and those norms seldom have the backing of senior management.
With that said, of course you should be tactful and show your coworkers respect. People deserve respect not because they are smart, but because they are people.
(1) Long periods of success lead to raises for the incumbent CEO and then the long period of success ends
(2) The company is failing and needs a turnaround. No external person is willing to take the job for normal CEO pay for the company’s size because they know they’ll likely fail and that makes getting another CEO job substantially harder.
https://www.amazon.com/Cambridge-Expertise-Performance-Handb...
https://www.cato-unbound.org/2011/07/13/robin-hanson/who-car...
For example:
> Furthermore, research using our CEO database found that the top decile of high performing CEOs are 35 percent more likely to dynamically reallocate capital than average performers.
Maybe they stumbled into an opportunity that the rest didn't. That's luck.
> To move “boldly” is to shift at least 30 percent more than the industry median. Making one or two bold moves more than doubles the likelihood of rising from the middle quintiles of economic profit to the top quintile, and making three or more bold moves makes such a rise six times more likely.
So if your random walk takes you upwards, you wind up having walked upwards. Brilliant.
> In the largest research effort of its kind, McKinsey found that CEOs who insist on rigorously measuring and managing all cultural elements that drive performance more than double the odds that their strategies will be executed.
Measured number rises, unmeasured number remains unmeasured. Scientists baffled.
Remember: these are the best and the brightest. They are taken extremely seriously.
Edit: they do give a source for their 45%-explained-by-CEO claim ... and it's a pop-business book written by the same authors. Oh well.