Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security
by loup-vaillant on Monday January 24, 2011 @04:08AM
(#2134725)
Spot on: the so called "Master" isn't a chief, but a world. A Good DM fades into the background, such that only the deeds of the PCs are remembered. I heard a passionate recall from a Starwars RPG once. The game master wasn't even mentioned.
In fairness, there may be more to the argument; all we have is a couple of paraphrased sentences from what was presumably a lot more testimony than that. But it doesn't help that those few sentences are inaccurate. The claim goes that "The Dungeon Master is tasked with giving directions to other players, which ... mimics the organization of a gang." That's not how I ever played D&D. The dungeon master doesn't give orders; he tells the players what happens when they do whatever they do of their own accord. One player character might give orders to another. But a DM that regularly tries to tell the PCs what to do, even through an NPC mouthpiece, is a pretty bad DM...