News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by tzs on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:44PM (#2133279)
The arguments the gang "expert" made about similarities between D&D player organization and gang organization would apply equally well to many organized religions, such as Catholicism. I wonder if a prison could get away with banning that?
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by rst on Sunday January 23, 2011 @06:07PM (#2133601)
The only part of the argument which got quoted in the article is that in D&D, some people give orders to other people, and in that way, it "mirrors the structure of a gang". Which is an argument that would encompass not just religion, but all sorts of other things. In a poetry group, one prisoner tells the others that today they'll be writing sonnets. A sure sign of gang activity!

In fairness, there may be more to the argument; all we have is a couple of paraphrased sentences from what was presumably a lot more testimony than that. But it doesn't help that those few sentences are inaccurate. The claim goes that "The Dungeon Master is tasked with giving directions to other players, which ... mimics the organization of a gang." That's not how I ever played D&D. The dungeon master doesn't give orders; he tells the players what happens when they do whatever they do of their own accord. One player character might give orders to another. But a DM that regularly tries to tell the PCs what to do, even through an NPC mouthpiece, is a pretty bad DM...

Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by loup-vaillant on Monday January 24, 2011 @04:08AM (#2134725)
Spot on: the so called "Master" isn't a chief, but a world. A Good DM fades into the background, such that only the deeds of the PCs are remembered. I heard a passionate recall from a Starwars RPG once. The game master wasn't even mentioned.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by metageek on Monday January 24, 2011 @08:11AM (#2135062)
On the other hand, the NPCs would probably agree that the PCs rampaging through their world are pretty ganglike.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by burgerbrain on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:06PM (#2133325)
Leads to the question: if Singer and his fellow players just got a little more "serious" about playing DnD, to the point where they could argue it constituted a religion, would they then be allowed to play?
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by tomjen3 on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:58PM (#2133448)
Unlikely, courts tend to take a dim view on religions that aren't several hundreds if not thousands of years old.

It is a legal hack to prevent situations like the one you described.

Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by endtime on Sunday January 23, 2011 @06:36PM (#2133670)
Doesn't Scientology have the status of an accepted religion in the US?
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by redthrowaway on Sunday January 23, 2011 @08:27PM (#2133905)
They have an army of lawyers, and getting themselves declared a non-taxable religion in every country they operate in is their first priority.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by w1ntermute on Sunday January 23, 2011 @06:40PM (#2133680)
They got an exception because of the all the rich/famous people they have.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by electromagnetic on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:13PM (#2133748)
So the defining characteristic of a religious entity is how much that entity can extort from its followers, and because Scientology extorts from the rich rather than the poor they attained this status faster.

Now where's my chapel in the Apple Store? I suppose the Genius Bar may constitute, but I'm smarter than those people so it doesn't provide me any solace.

Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by w1ntermute on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:49PM (#2133821)
> So the defining characteristic of a religious entity is how much that entity can extort from its followers, and because Scientology extorts from the rich rather than the poor they attained this status faster.

Wrong, the definining characteristic of a governmentally recognized religious entity is a religious entity that has enough wealth to successfully lobby the government into recognizing it.

> Now where's my chapel in the Apple Store? I suppose the Genius Bar may constitute, but I'm smarter than those people so it doesn't provide me any solace.

Believe it or not, the vast majority of Apple users don't consider Apple to be a religious entity or follow its every move with anything approaching religious fervor. They're just riding the technology pop culture wave.

Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by neworbit on Monday January 24, 2011 @12:50AM (#2134409)
Last I checked Catholic dogma, which has been a couple decades now, I think Steve has to actually pass away before he can become a saint.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by rdtsc on Sunday January 23, 2011 @05:38PM (#2133534)
Nah. Prison systems have a much more narrow definition of what constitutes a religion. Some have a pre-defined list of approved religions. Religions usually must be established and organized.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by code_duck on Sunday January 23, 2011 @08:31PM (#2133912)
Oh dear... the groups that were going around in the 80s warning parents that D&D was satanism would have a field day with that.
Re:Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security by wlievens on Monday January 24, 2011 @03:30AM (#2134665)
They've since shifted their focus to Harry Potter.