News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by prepend on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:13PM (#21329422)
Surveilling your kids is not the complete answer, but it is certainly part of the answer.

I think there’s a false assumption that these kinds of apps are used by parents to replace communication and other methods, but it’s part of strong communication between kids and parents.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:41PM (#21329942)
Lots of people believe there is a certain right way and a certain wrong way to parent. When really what it is is every kid, every parent, and every relationship is different. What works for one may not work for others. The same way as every other relationship on the planet works.

There are some constants that almost always apply. Don't hit, don't steal, don't abandon, try not to yell. But outside of those, I'm convinced that a lot of what you see as parenting advice out there is just survivorship masquerading as wisdom. Some people get really easy kids, and they confusedly believe that they were awesome parents. Some people get really tough kids and have to try strategies parents with easy kids never had to reach for. Even this is an oversimplification, since there are actually many different dimensions to parenting, not a simple easy to hard continuum.

I can absolutely believe there are some parent-child relationships that would not tolerate phone surveillance. There are also parents who would use the capability unwisely. On the other hand, there are children who are not very responsible, and there are plenty of things on the internet and out in the world that can prey on these kids. Only you know your relationship with your kids. "Don't surveil" as a commandment does not fit with the three I mentioned earlier. It's certainly not an absolute.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by notzuck on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:27PM (#21329518)
Another reasonable point downvoted on HN as this comment will be too I'm sure.

Some parents will abuse this ability and there's nothing to government should do about that. Good parenting is hard and some form of tracking is important.

My daughter had a phone from the age of 10, she uses it for google and email at school (it's part of their classes), texting me when her bus is near the bus stop so I can drive to collect her and for texting her friends. She is not allowed to use her phone to install apps that can communicate with people that she does not already know and this is something I periodically check on with the view that I will check less as she gets older. I am actually super impressed that she is not addicted to her phone like you would imagine a young girl would be.

One of her friends does have instagram and other social media, I have checked her pages out and she has many followers that are men and much older than her. I wish her parents would check her phone more often.

Regardless of what some childless anons on the Internet think, it's bloody hard to parent in the age of the iPhone. A simple solution is to not let your kids have anything but I've always believed that giving access to what everyone else has is fine as long as it's controlled with reasonable boundaries put in place.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:05PM (#21329767)
I'm absolutely not childless. I was a full-time wife and mom for a lot of years.

I'm sorry you feel so defensive and feel such a strong need to justify your choices rather than contemplate the possibility that some people who disagree with you have a fine parenting track record, have been at it longer than you and have thought a great deal about some things.

I wish very much that I had a means to educate more parents. But I am no longer a full-time wife. I have bills to pay and I still support my adult special needs sons and the world has made it abundantly clear that the things I know and wish to share are not worth money.

But in a nutshell, there are hidden costs to the kind of approach you are taking. It is akin to the saying "Going to war to preserve the peace is like fucking to preserve virginity."

I chose to not tell my children "There are bad people out there that will want to do unspeakable things to you, so you should be afraid, very afraid." because I felt that would rob them of the very innocence I desired to protect and preserve. Instead, I taught them by example what genuine respect looks and feels like by setting the standard for that with how I treated them.

They were taught they could say "No" to people -- including me -- for things like hugs and kisses. They were taught it was their decision, not mine.

But I would happily play enforcer. If someone didn't respect their decision, "Come get mom."

My oldest inferred based on his experiences that protecting himself from a bully with violent force was completely reasonable when he was at school and getting Mom was not an option. He didn't even feel it was noteworthy and I learned that story years later.

Rumaging through your daughter's phone sets a precedent that future boyfriends or husbands can take advantage of to her detriment. And there are better policies that achieve the same thing without that.

My sons have been online since they were two and five. I arranged kid-friendly menus to help them find things of interest to them easily with little risk of exposure to undesirable parts of the internet.

They were not constrained. They didn't want such exposure. They were happy to stick to the things I helped them access that met their needs without having to be hassled with this other stuff.

I know this is a touchy subject and you will probably be offended. But it's touchy because both sides of the argument are personally invested, not because your personal investment somehow trumps mine.

I was molested and raped as a child. I thought long and hard about how to protect my children not just physically, but also emotionally and psychologically. They are old enough that I've gotten to see the fruits of my labor.

Unfortunately, no one wants to know what I did. I'm just a woman, so I must be stupid or something.

We all have our bag of rocks to carry in this crappy world.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by notzuck on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:15PM (#21329819)
Sorry if I upset you. I'm not sure if our opinions are different or not. I think I mostly agree with you to be honest and I don't see where my comment is massively opposed to yours.

I don't believe I am setting a precedent with my girls that it's ok to be spied upon. If you know a better way, I would love to hear more about it.

"Unfortunately, no one wants to know what I did. I'm just a woman, so I must be stupid or something.'

I want to know!

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:28PM (#21329878)
She is not allowed to use her phone to install apps that can communicate with people that she does not already know and this is something I periodically check on with the view that I will check less as she gets older.

Why do you think you need to do this? Why does this need to be a hard constraint dictated and controlled by someone else?

My kids were given some general guidelines from a very early age. I tongue-in-cheek would say "No naked pics and no instructions on how to build bombs." They are my kids, so they understood what I was trying to get at.

They also had it explained to them that as a parent, I had latitude to intercede on their behalf, assuming they stayed within certain boundaries. They understood that crimes like murder or arson would change that fact and put decision making power out of my hands and into the hands of strangers.

My power as a parent served them. It was not weilded in an authoritarian fashion.

If a child is getting their needs adequately met "within the rules," they have no reason to break the rules. When my kids proved consistently incapable of following the rules, I wondered what was wrong with my rules and tried to improve my process.

Is there some reason your child would desire to talk to untrustworthy people she doesn't already know? Is she bored? Is she lonely?

People don't take risks of that sort merely out ignorance. They do so out of desperation. Otherwise, they are quick to go "Nope, I don't need to keep this shitty app for talking to this awful person that I don't even like. Ugh. Moving on."

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by notzuck on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:44PM (#21329970)
"If a child is getting their needs adequately met "within the rules," they have no reason to break the rules."

I'm not sure the above quote is true at all. Sometimes your kids want things that you won't give them. You can't keep 100% content kids 100% of the time.

Everything you said sounds reasonable but I think kids can get themselves into bad situations even if they are happy and well adjusted. Sometimes hormones can kick in and make you talk to people that you would never normally talk to.

It's easy to say that kids that are talking to strange adults online have serious issues in other parts of their lives and fixing those issues will fix everything but I think that's a really simplistic way of viewing the world.

I was a very happy and content kid but still got mixed up with things I should not have just because my personality was adventurous and addictive at the time.

I'm not assuming my kids will follow my behaviour but I've seen the overly sexualised content one of her friends posts and all of her friends just thinks shes cool for doing so now she has the popular girl feedback loop. I doubt her parents know. Maybe she's got some other issues and addressing those will fix everything or maybe she hasn't got issues but she's just addicted to it?

Even if she has got other issues, the first sign might be the crap she does on her phone so it's good if her parents see that sooner rather than later.

Maybe you're a great parent but you also had great kids which is only really partially under your control? Not every piece of undesirable behaviour can be easily traced back to an underlying issue that can be fixed. Sometimes it just is.

The reason why I ban her from talking to strangers online is because I don't want her to be groomed while she's emotionally vulnerable. Girls can get hooked on the idea of older boys sometimes, I don't think this means they are unhappy and even if a kid is unhappy in some part of their lives, that's normal and that's ok. Sometimes being unhappy is fine and you need to teach your kids how to deal with that but I'd like to know if she's 'self medicating' by sending naked pics to older boys because more subtle signs of an issue might be hard to detect. It's a busy world with two working parents and large demands placed upon us by her school so it can be easy to miss something.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:59PM (#21330050)
I did a lot of therapy. I got with the woman in the mirror a whole lot.

I suggest you start a journal, explore your own past experiences and try to figure out what went wrong and why and why you still blame yourself so much all these years later such that you need to project your fears onto your daughter and can't trust her to have better sense than you had.

Kids doing "bad" things are frequently expressing baggage from the subconscious of their parents that the parents aren't even aware they are hanging on their children.

My children were taught from the age of two "It's your body. You can touch it however you want. Just do it in the bathroom or your bedroom with the door shut."

When my youngest hit puberty and became hard to deal with because he was hormonal, I explained that his problem was not called "my bitch mother." It was called testosterone.

I explained that his system was flooded with hormones and this was why he felt so angry. Knowing that explanation caused him to stop looking for someone to blame his anger on.

When he was too ranty, I would say "Ugh, you sound like some hormone soaked teenager." He would say "I am some hormone soaked teenager."

He would try to tone down the ranty bullshit and I would try to have some patience and tolerance for the fact that it wasn't entirely under his control.

The reason why I ban her from talking to strangers online is because I don't want her to be groomed while she's emotionally vulnerable.

What I'm trying to tell you is that you are currently the person doing the kind of grooming that gets girls into bad situations.

I think girls tend to like older boys because boys tend to lag behind girls in social skills. Girls interested in older boys are often just looking for someone who is a good social and emotional match.

I've had relationships with older men who thought they could control me because of the age difference and I've had relationships with older men who were clear they needed to respect me. Men who thought they could control me got quite the shock. I don't react well at all to efforts to control me.

You are teaching her that a man that loves her and wants what is best for her will seek to control her as a normal and caring part of a healthy relationship instead of teaching her "Anyone trying to exert that kind of control is in the wrong and should be told to stuff it."

We probably need to stop here because I have very strong views that sending naked pics to someone via internet is vastly safer than a lot of other activities and our laws and culture should promote such safe practices rather than vilifying them. We should punish people for sharing such pics with others without her permission, but she should be allowed to show anyone her body via photographs if that's what she wants as a safer alternative to showing them her body in person.

I made my peace with my sexuality a long time ago. That isn't always deemed to be an asset by people when such topics come up.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by notzuck on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @09:08PM (#21330103)
Well now it just feels like you're attacking me. I'm not projecting anything onto my daughter. I don't blame myself for anything?

Maybe you're some expert level parent that most other parents just can't be. Maybe it would take me years to gain the parenting skills that you have but by that time I have already pushed my daughter over the edge?

Your one size fits all approach is sad. Why do you feel the need to fix everything by trying to be some sort of perfect parent? Is this because your parents were not perfect?

It would be a criminal offence for her to send nude pic to other people, it would also be an offence to solicit those pics.

I thought we were aligned on our opinions from your first post but sadly I now just feel that you are very lost and somehow got lucky that your kids turned out ok.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @09:16PM (#21330151)
Someone else soliciting nudes from a ten year old is a very different situation from her -- in your words -- 'self medicating' by sending nude photos to boys.
Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by concordDance on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:26AM (#21332034)
> I suggest you start a journal, explore your own past experiences and try to figure out what went wrong and why and why you still blame yourself so much all these years later such that you need to project your fears onto your daughter and can't trust her to have better sense than you had.

I though maybe your previous post was a one-off but nope, you really are coming across as condescending.

Hopefully by pointing out passages people are likely to find condescending and off-putting you can figure out how to tone that down so it doesn't get people's backs up and drown your message.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by dang on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:36AM (#21332099)
Please don't cross into personal attack on HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by concordDance on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:47AM (#21332189)
Hmm...

Took me a second to figure out what the personal attack was.

Editted post. Is it better now?

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by dang on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @04:28AM (#21332466)
I appreciate the good intention, but it's still unsubstantive and needlessly personal. If you get to the point of posting about how condescending someone else is, you've left the path of the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. It's also just off topic and uninteresting.
Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by concordDance on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:22AM (#21332777)
So posts that just point out potential condescension are not welcome here? Do you know if that would also apply if it was part of a larger on-topic post?

It's just irritating to see the condescension and repeated imputing of motives of other commentators go unchallenged. It's rude and disrespectful. Does HN have some other mechanism than peer commentary for dealing with rudeness?

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by dang on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @04:30PM (#21338652)
Sure. We spend days and often also evenings asking users here not to be rude. We can't come close to seeing all the comments, though. If there's a post that you feel particularly deserved moderation and we missed it, the likeliest explanation is that we didn't see it. You can always let us know by flagging the comment (see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#cflag) or by emailing [email protected].

If you're going to react to rudeness and so on by posting replies in the thread, though, it's important to do it in a way that doesn't break the guidelines yourself. Otherwise this place just gets worse.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by pcwalton on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:56PM (#21330911)
I have to say, your comments are always some of the most insightful ones I've ever read on this site. Thanks for writing them.
Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @12:00AM (#21330934)
If only people would pay me to write comments on HN, then my life would suddenly work.

Sadly, that's not a viable career.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:22AM (#21333811)
It would be totally against the spirit of HN, but hypothetically, if you had a Patreon for HN comments, you'd have at least one patron here.

I agree and second 'pcwalton here. I don't always agree with what you write, but I always appreciate seeing it here, you have one of the best insight to comment length ratio.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by DoreenMichele on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @10:23AM (#21334898)
I actually do have a Patreon account. I have no plans whatsoever to describe it as being about posting on HN, but you wouldn't be the first. I already have a Patreon supporter who made it clear they were kicking in money because of my comments on HN, not because of any of my blog writing per se.

I suppose I should say "Thank you." I'm actually quite uncomfortable with public praise. I have moderating experience and my observation is that trying to be well-mannered and say "Thank you" or otherwise acknowledge such praise tends to cause a rebound reaction where someone feels a need to counter it with some kind of personal attack (something that's already happened here in fact). It also seems to do bad things to the group dynamic.

So I've long had a policy of studiously ignoring public praise as the least worst thing I can do. But that seems to make me standoffish, which causes other problems.

Some things seem to have no actually good answer, especially in public spaces. Anything you post publicly will be interpreted differently by different people. When the group is large enough, that easily turns into a push-pull dynamic as the group tries to sort out which side "wins" the argument.

I thoroughly hate that to the depths of my soul.

My background is participating in online support groups. My belief is that if ten people reply to a question, you should have ten different answers that add information, not one that is "For X" and nine more that vehemently argue about being for or against X. X should have little or nothing to do with the other nine answers.

So my writing style is based on shooting for statements that stand on their own and actively seek to avoid that nonsense. No one has to agree with me. I'm not trying to win an argument. I'm just trying to explain a point of view as clearly as possible and put out a piece of information as best I understand it.

Overall, I'm mostly happy with my writing style, though I continue to try to find ways to improve it. "There's always room at the top." You can always find ways to make it better rather than resting on your laurels and stroking your ego.

Re:FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps by jsjohnst on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:45PM (#21329659)
> Another reasonable point downvoted on HN as this comment will be too I'm sure.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html