News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by Gnarl on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:04PM (#21315980)
This thread would be much shorter if someone had read this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26151230
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by monomyth on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:36PM (#21318305)
Or not if someone would read this https://www.rrjournal.org/doi/abs/10.1667/RR3251
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by Gnarl on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:29PM (#21325574)
Perhaps you don't appreciate how a review looking at 100 different setups & methods and 93 of those all arriving at the same endpoint (RF leads to oxidative stress) represents FAR stronger evidence than a single study showing the opposite under very specific conditions.
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by vardump on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:38PM (#21317736)
Bad formatting in that paper makes it very hard to read.

Overall it seemed to have pretty strong cherry picking feel. Are you sure this paper is objective?

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by Gnarl on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:11PM (#21316056)
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by doctorpangloss on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:39PM (#21317745)
These are good things to read to understand a consensus that yes, electromagnetic radiation has biological effects.

For people reading this stuff, always search for something called the Odds Ratio (OR), which is a gold standard way of comparing how clinically significant a thing is. For example, smoking has an OR of 60 for lung cancer. A well covered paper on birth control suggested its OR for developing depression is 1.26, and the massive aspirin on heart health study had 0.95 OR of cardiovascular disease in one of the surveyed counties (ie aspirin improved clinical outcome).

If error bars on measured OR contain 1.0 you can’t say if it is helpful or harmful. OR accounts for baseline incidence in a way that RR (relative risk) does not. So it lets you actually choose among behaviors instead of within diseases or outcomes. It informs why it’s possible to tell everyone they shouldn’t smoke (OR is very high), keep taking birth control (because depression outcome is better than unwanted or complicated pregnancy outcomes), and aspirin for cardiovascular disease prophylaxis (very limited side effects, very cheap so even 0.95 is worth it).

I don’t know if there’s a consensus that electromagnetic radiation from electronics has clinical significance. If there is clinical significance it will be a small OR for most outcomes. It won’t be comparable at all to e.g. smoking.

However this is still an imperfect measure. In Japan OR for lung disease from smoking is 15, 4 times better than the US. The researchers speculated this has to do with a specific filter on common Japanese cigarettes but it could be genetics or other things that they didn’t control for (ie BMI and gender matching but not Japanese ancestry). So technology can have huge effects on clinical outcomes but 4x 15 is a much bigger deal than 4x 1.015. My point is that it has its limitations but OR definitely measures something real.

This is a robust framework for evaluating how this research matters to you in a way that does not require conspiracies or investigating the researcher’s backgrounds. Additionally it is widely accepted by legitimate medical practitioners across the world.

Under this framework, the reviews posted here do not document clinical significance, although individual papers cited in them might.

A big limitation is that mice are tested with orders of magnitude higher incidence rate of the disease to quickly find RR (high RR in mice vs placebo is strong research evidence just not strong clinical evidence). So mouse OR isn’t often predicative of human OR. But this applies to chart reviews too. Still a pretty durable framework.

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by godelski on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:53PM (#21318446)
> A big limitation is that mice are tested with orders of magnitude higher incidence rate of the disease to quickly find RR

Do people also assume that EM radiation is a linear no threshold? Because we know it isn't true for ionizing radiation, but it is a great model to use in practice because it overestimates harm (which we'd rather over estimate than under).

I've read a few of those papers on the EM radiation on mice and they seem to assume a LNT model, which doesn't seem all that honest to me. A few of the papers I read didn't have great p-values either and had drastically differing rates of cancer development for radiation levels and sex (IIRC one big one had high cancer rates for low power, nothing for medium, and moderate cancer rates for high power. Which there was no explanation to this. But that might have just been one bad paper).

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by aclarry on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:32PM (#21318757)
Citation for knowing it isn't true for ionizing radiation? LNT is supported by the US NRC, the EPA, and UNSCEAR. Not saying that it supports the papers on EM radiation, but it's definitely not crazy to assume LNT in your research (and given we don't know much about the effects of low radiation doses, it's definitely the more precautionary option).
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by godelski on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:30PM (#21319503)
Sure.

To give you an intuition though, LNT would suggest that the body has no repair mechanism for healing damage from radiation (should be suspicious about this) and that all effects are accumulative (which makes sense if there is no repair, but doesn't if there is repair). We can heal from other things and have demonstrated in the lab that cells can repair from low radiation dosages.

Basically the thing is that measuring is incredibly difficult because there's a temporal component and effects are very different depending on where that dosage is received (eg. your eyes vs your hands. See equivalent dosage). So what do you do? You overestimate on the side of safety. Failure of modeling is built into the safety standards (I used to work on radiation shielding devices and I fully support the use of the LNT model in practice. Better safe than sorry).

I haven't read all of these and didn't archive what I have read so these are what I came up with quickly (I did read abstracts, of course)

(Short end is that it isn't clear how much cancer risk increases for dosages <100mSv -i.e. "low dosages" -, which is WELL above occupational standards - 5x actually)

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2663584/

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000927971...

not an article but a good high level response (notice the hand waviness) https://hps.org/publicinformation/ate/q12755.html

This part of the wiki page is also good and shows you the contrasting sides https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model#Cont... It also has links to other journal articles.

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by greggman2 on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:29PM (#21319496)
Isn't the answer "Denver"? The city has a higher radiation dosage than average yet no more medical issues. Or at least that's something I heard once. A quick google brought up this site (which I have no idea who is sponcering)

https://atomicinsights.com/science-falsified-no-safe-dose-hy...

Also

https://www.google.com/search?q=denver+radiation

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by godelski on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:31PM (#21319505)
Yes, and an even better example is Ramsar Iran.
Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by longtom on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:07PM (#21318569)
> OR accounts for baseline incidence in a way that RR (relative risk) does not.

Would you mind elaborating on this? As a reminder, odds ratio is

((exposure_unhealthy / exposure_healthy) / (control_unhealthy / control_healthy))

Whereas risk ratio is

((exposure_unhealthy / (exposure_unhealthy + exposure_healthy) / (control_unhealthy / (control_unhealthy + control_healthy))

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by mcguire on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:17PM (#21317493)
Keep in mind that many readers here are involved in these technologies. Any safety issues would directly or indirectly harm their interests. Alternatively, some likely feel they understand radio frequency radiation and know a-priori that it is safe; "why, I have carried a phone for years and I've never been nuked like a microwave burrito."

It's an interesting comparison with the vaping thread last week or the week before, where a similar number of comments came to the conclusion that it should be heavily restricted because we don't have enough data.

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by mc32 on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:09PM (#21319380)
That’s a bit unfair. We do have data pointing to vaping causing direct harm (and leading up to death) to people at regular dosage rates.

That said, caution should be observed when data points to potential issues.

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by Junk_Collector on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:28PM (#21316934)
Your first link was paywalled so I couldn't read it, but the potential issues with meta-analysis papers has been discussed to death already.

The article you linked second, is interesting. He makes some bad claims (The electric fields produced by muscles are strongly polarized contrary to his claim that they are unpolarized) and there is some questionable math, but what I really want to highlight is how he uses the pulse repetition interval in his section on forced oscillation. By his own math, a CW signal at mm-wave frequencies produces no biological effect being to low of intensity. The formula given is proportional to 1/(2pif) so it follows, but he then uses the PRF to set the frequency and displacement and finds that at these low frequencies, the effect is strong enough to be dangerous.

The problem with this though, is that the PRF is how often you activate the transmitter and not the frequency of the transmitted RF signal which leaves us with the perverse conclusion that, mm-wave is fine under normal circumstances but becomes more dangerous the less you are exposed to it.

Re:“We have no reason to believe 5G is safe” by Gnarl on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:37PM (#21317028)
Oops, didn't realize 1st paper had been paywalled. Try here: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279863242_Oxidative...