News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook and Speech by collyw on Friday October 18, 2019 @11:37AM (#21292264)
He doesn't say why it's a trap to think about facebook in terms of publisher versus carrier.

Someone made an insightful comment here the other day saying that they (the tech companies) chose to play publisher and opened themselves up to whole lot of legal battles and complaints, when they should have stayed with the carrier option.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:09PM (#21292560)
I’d like to know why so many people treat the publisher vs. carrier issue as some natural law of speech, when it’s actually a fairly recent concept. To me it seems like a false dichotomy. Arguing from first principles, why should there be a binary choice between those two options?
Re:Facebook and Speech by jerf on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:46PM (#21292871)
We need carriers, because we need people to be able to dedicate themselves to plumbing without having to worry about the terabytes crossing across them. If they did, the Internet would grind to a halt from all the necessary processing and blocking and examination.

We want publishers to carry some responsibility, for various obvious reasons.

It seems to me that once someone is being held a little bit responsible, they're going to be forced to act as being fully responsible and need the power to block a bit of content, which will then come with the full corresponding responsibility for blocking that piece of content. What do you see as a middle ground? (This is an honest question, not an argument.)

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Friday October 18, 2019 @01:13PM (#21293158)
The middle ground to me is something like "people should be free to interact, but if they're going to say something I think is racist they need to do it elsewhere." (Substitute "racist" with whatever you wish in this scenario).

At that point, the publisher vs. carrier crowd goes "well, that racist thing wasn't illegal, so now you have to be responsible for everything someone says." But I don't really care about what most of people say; I just don't want them to be racist.

This isn't a standard we apply to most businesses. If I run a bar, I can generally remove a patron for saying something without the conduct I choose to allow coming under scrutiny.

I agree re: carriers, for the reasons you stated. But to me that's a status mostly reserved for plumbing-type infrastructure, not a choice services have to make when they're deciding what type of content to host.

Re:Facebook and Speech by endtime on Friday October 18, 2019 @02:45PM (#21294017)
> But I don't really care about what most of people say; I just don't want them to be racist.

I hope you're ready to be accused of being a sexist and anti-Semite by many people's definitions. Not to mention that I hope you know that watermelon, dancing, math, and balloons are racist (according to someone with 1000 Tumblr followers, probably), and so have no place on your platform. The point being that determining what is and isn't racist can be a pretty hard problem.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Friday October 18, 2019 @05:06PM (#21295081)
Coming up with an objective and broadly agreeable rubric would indeed be difficult. But this is my hypothetical service, so the only definition of racism that really matters is my own. People are free to disagree and criticize, of course — but ultimately it’s my way or the highway, so to speak.

I’ll also note that this doesn’t really answer my question. What is the reason for the platform vs. publisher dichotomy? If I choose not to host content I don’t want to, why does it follow that I should be liable for any content I host?

Re:Facebook and Speech by stale2002 on Friday October 18, 2019 @07:44PM (#21295912)
> People are free to disagree and criticize, of course — but ultimately it’s my way or the highway

No, it is not your way or the highway, though. Because you, as the platform, are also subject to the opinions of the public, now.

And if you are subject to the opinions of the public, then you might start to decide to censor more and more things, not because you actually think that they are bad, but instead because some vocal minority is clammering for it to be banned.

I don't want you to be subject to that public opinion. Instead, I want to give platforms an excuse to say "sorry! We can't ban anything at all, because we are required to act neutrally!".

That way nobody can complain and try and pressure the network into expanding their definition of bad things more and more.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Friday October 18, 2019 @08:08PM (#21295990)
Every company is subject to the opinions of the public. I avoid Google products because they don't respect my privacy; I know people who don't use Apple products because they're too controlling. That is called "doing business".

And trying to be neutral doesn't even insulate you from those opinions! When I realized my previous webhost's position was to allow e.g. Nazi content as long as it was legal, I switched hosts. What do you think that webhost would do if enough people followed suit?

Re:Facebook and Speech by stale2002 on Friday October 18, 2019 @08:44PM (#21296122)
> Every company is subject to the opinions of the public

When was the last time that the phone company was protested because it refused to censor certain people?

The answer is that this basically never happens.

> What do you think that webhost would do if enough people followed suit?

Well, if it was illegal for webhosts to refuse service to groups, then I don't think that these webhosts would be protested, or whatever, for not censoring certain groups.

> trying to be neutral doesn't even insulate you from those opinions

Which is why I want to give networks an excuse, where they can say "Sorry everyone! It is completely out of our hands! We can't censor them even if we wanted to."

> I switched hosts

And if every host is hosting controversial content, then you won't be able to find any that isn't being neutral.

Have you changed your phone provider, because Nazis are using AT&T to make phone calls? I doubt it.

Re:Facebook and Speech by meowface on Friday October 18, 2019 @10:49PM (#21296484)
One important difference is that YouTube carries content to be consumed by the public, while phone companies are more like the postal service: they send things from point A to point B, blindly (except for snooping from intelligence agencies), between private parties. These companies have many common carrier aspects, but they also have many aspects of regular private enterprises.

I agree that perhaps some degree of regulation could be warranted to adddess their unique sort-of-carrier status, but saying that they should be forbidden by the state from disallowing anything that's legal is a slippery slope in the same way biased censorship is. For example, they may not want any risk of people seeing extreme gore videos, since that could cause people to use their service less, even though such videos are typically not illegal to distribute or view. But with total free reign over a behemoth communication monopoly, politically biased content curation and removal is also a huge problem. I think there needs to be a middle ground approach.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Friday October 18, 2019 @09:30PM (#21296273)
Like I said, I think "carriers" are important for plumbing-type infrastructure services. This includes phone companies and ISPs. It strains credulity to say that Facebook or a webhost falls under that same umbrella.

You're assuming that networks are looking for an excuse, but plenty of network operators don't want to serve certain types of content. Making that illegal just means network operators are the ones being censored, rather than their users — except the penalty for disobedience is no longer simply finding another network, but fines and jail time. That does not strike me as an improvement.

This also still doesn't answer my original question: if I as a business owner/network operator don't want to serve certain types of content, why does it then follow that I should be liable for everything I do serve?

Re:Facebook and Speech by meowface on Friday October 18, 2019 @10:39PM (#21296449)
The issue is a bar isn't an embedded monopoly, but Facebook is. Want a social network? Facebook's the only real game in town. Videos? You have to use YouTube. Photos? Instagram (Facebook). Microblogging? Twitter. There's Diaspora, and Vimeo, and Mastodon, but these are basically non-factors statistically, and they serve different, less common niches.

Not to say a company needs to permit all content, no matter how racist or bad, just because it's a monopoly and a sort-of-carrier. But things definitely get trickier. If you're banned from YouTube, you basically can't upload videos anymore, period, at least if you want anyone to look at them. These companies don't fit the classical mode of a carrier, like a telephone provider, because they carry content to be consumed openly by the public. I think Discord is probably the closest thing to a more traditional carrier, though it's still not totally comparable.

There's no good solution here other than debating a reasonable middle ground. These companies probably do need to be more open with what they allow compared to a small business, but they should still also have leeway to make their own decisions.

That's a pretty wishy-washy answer, but I think it's the only alternative to avoid the extremes of either full public utility regulation with government-enforced free speech, or super nitpicky and biased content curation. They can't be treated like either a standard business or a public service. They're in between.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Saturday October 19, 2019 @01:46AM (#21296983)
Let me preface this by saying I am sympathetic to breaking up monopoly-esque companies that amass too much power. That said, I think this sentence is the crux of your comment:

> If you're banned from YouTube, you basically can't upload videos anymore, period, at least if you want anyone to look at them.

There's a pithy statement that applies here: "freedom of speech is not freedom of reach". Because there are plenty of other ways to upload videos — Vimeo and PeerTube and your own server — but none have YouTube's killer feature, which is distribution to a built-in audience.

Let's back up a few decades and say you want to promote Nazism, which is legal. Your options are pretty limited! No major newspaper will publish your article, no major radio station will let you speak and no major TV channel will give you a show. You can distribute your own newsletter, get on public access TV, transmit on unused radio frequencies, or maybe even find a small company that will allow you. But for the most part, you can't distribute to large audiences, and no one has a problem with this.

Enter the Internet. Now anyone can publish things consumable by anyone in the world… but all of a sudden that's not enough, and it's imperative that it's just as easy for Nazis to reach a huge audience as anyone else? What is so fundamentally different about YouTube vs. TV networks that we need to revisit this?

Granted, Nazism is an extreme example; it's more likely that people are concerned about e.g. alleged censorship of conservative views. But it's difficult for me to really care about this, because these are still mainstream views! Even if you don't think you're welcome on Twitter, you can go to Gab or Voat. You can read about it on Breitbart and The Daily Caller. You can get it delivered in the Wall Street Journal. You can watch it on Fox News. For speech that is being "censored", it sure is easy to find.

I'll finish by reiterating my support for breaking up giant companies that effectively control a large part of discourse. Concentrated power is never a good thing. But I think it's a gross violation of free speech to force networks to distribute content they don't want to — especially when there are always options for people to get their speech out.

Re:Facebook and Speech by meowface on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:03PM (#21300111)
I think there should only be some tiny degree of forcing. A provider like Facebook and YouTube have immense power to influence elections, for example. This is super exaggerated, but if, say, every pro-Republican video is removed or hidden behind an adult/extreme/offensive warning, while most pro-Democrat videos are left untouched, think about what effect that may have on current generations, and generations in 10 and 20 years from now, who grow up on YouTube content essentially. It'll probably influence your thinking.

I definitely don't want them to be classified as public utilities or even broken up. I think very minimal regulation similar to the "equal-time rule" should be used instead, applied only to certain narrow forms of content. I think Steve Huffman of reddit did it right: he's clearly no fan of Trump or his supporters, but he refused all the calls to delete Trump's subreddit. Half the site calls him a Nazi and the other half calls him a libcuck, but I think he made the right move.

I think YouTube should absolutely have a right to remove videos promoting white nationalism or advocating bigotry and such. I just think they shouldn't have absolute free reign to remove anything, due to the fact that they're now kind of more like TV in general, rather than a single TV network.

Re:Facebook and Speech by kofejnik on Friday October 18, 2019 @02:56PM (#21294104)
what if you think it's racist but someone else thinks it's fine? Who gets to decide?
Re:Facebook and Speech by CompanionCuuube on Friday October 18, 2019 @04:36PM (#21294871)
Whoever has the greatest number of followers gets to be the arbiter of truth.
Re:Facebook and Speech by r00fus on Friday October 18, 2019 @07:17PM (#21295823)
Currently that's FB/Twitter (aggregating populations using).

When the arbiter of truth is a profit-oriented, authoritarian regime (ie, any corporation) that's not beholden to anyone - bad things happen.

Just look at Apple's AppStore for an example (at least politics isn't influenced by Apps).

Re:Facebook and Speech by joubert on Friday October 18, 2019 @08:47PM (#21296133)
> at least politics isn't influenced by Apps

Maybe. https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/18/20921300/rebulicans-demo...

Re:Facebook and Speech by lr4444lr on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:41PM (#21292825)
Because of liability. A newspaper or TV station can be sued for false content, not the printing company or the station engineers.
Re:Facebook and Speech by vkou on Friday October 18, 2019 @02:03PM (#21293632)
I can sue a TV station for telling lies on the air? Really? How much am I likely to win from this, because if it's true, I'm ready to start a legal crusade today.

Oh, right... I won't get a penny. Free speech also means the freedom to tell bald-faced lies, without consequence.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jay_kyburz on Friday October 18, 2019 @08:34PM (#21296082)
Actually that's not true in a lot of the world. If you or your society are harmed by the lies, you can seek damages.
Re:Facebook and Speech by greggman2 on Friday October 18, 2019 @10:25PM (#21296420)
Is it a recent concept? The "concept" seems as old as time. If you say it it's your responsibility. If I say it it's mine. Your editing of my speech is your speech therefore if you edit it becomes your responsibility.

A simple example just for clarity. I say "I hate my sister when she doesn't clean up but I love my sister more than anything". If you edit that to "I hate my sister" you've changed the meaning. That edit is your speech and hence your responsibility.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jakelazaroff on Saturday October 19, 2019 @02:49AM (#21297193)
Social networks aren't "editing" anyone's speech, though. They're simply limiting its reach, or not hosting it in the first place.
Re:Facebook and Speech by greggman2 on Friday October 25, 2019 @12:42AM (#21351956)
They are selecting which content to show. That's no different then editing. It's easy to post 2 posts where missing the context of one other the other changes the entire meaning. So by not displaying one or the other they've edited the meaning and are therefore arguably responsible for the new meaning
Re:Facebook and Speech by geggam on Friday October 18, 2019 @09:14PM (#21296228)
Not really new.

Scribes, news reporters, telegrams and telephones all throughout history have enjoyed immunity from the content they didnt generate.

Ever hear "Don't kill the messenger?"

Re:Facebook and Speech by sintaxi on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:37PM (#21292789)
> why should there be a binary choice between those two options?

Because the distinction is binary. You either censor what information people consume beyond what the law requires you to or you don't. publisher vs. carrier is the legal distinction between the two.

Re:Facebook and Speech by akersten on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:39PM (#21292808)
Citation badly needed. Please indicate the law that says "as soon as you moderate, you become responsible for all the other content on your platform."

Because I don't think there is one. And I think that's an extremely strained interpretation of Section 230.

Re:Facebook and Speech by schoen on Friday October 18, 2019 @01:39PM (#21293417)
In fact, §230 was meant to reverse prior legal decisions that pointed in this direction.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communicati...

Re:Facebook and Speech by shkkmo on Friday October 18, 2019 @01:13PM (#21293156)
The argument is not legal, but semantic. Unless the post you are replying to is edited, you are asking for citation for a quote that was not made by the person you are replying to.
Re:Facebook and Speech by akersten on Friday October 18, 2019 @01:43PM (#21293450)
Their post specifically stated a legal argument:

>> publisher vs. carrier is the legal distinction between the two

So I'm curious about the law that provides that.

My quotation marks are to summarize the position being made - I use >> for direct quotes.

Re:Facebook and Speech by shkkmo on Friday October 18, 2019 @01:53PM (#21293546)
Your summary seems rather inaccurate.

The person you are responding to is merely pointing out that there is a binary distinction between those that exert editorial control over their content and those that don't and that "publisher" and "common carrier" are the legal terms that cover those two binary categories (which may not be strictly accurate.)

There is nothing about responsibility, so you are putting words in their mouth.

Re:Facebook and Speech by shkkmo on Friday October 18, 2019 @02:06PM (#21293654)
The legal protections for "common carriers" were established via Case Law in Smith v. California and extended to online platforms in Cubby, Inc. v. CompuServe Inc. this was then limited to not cover online "publishers" who exert editorial control in Stratton Oakmont Inc. v. Prodigy Services Co.

Section 230 was intended to limit this last Case Law decision and extend the protections given to online "common carriers" to online "publishers".

Re:Facebook and Speech by dvtrn on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:37PM (#21292786)
I’d like to know why so many people treat the publisher vs. carrier issue as some natural law of speech

How do you mean, exactly? I feel that I understand your point but am trying not to make any assumptions.

Re:Facebook and Speech by mikedilger on Friday October 18, 2019 @04:25PM (#21294805)
Author makes many dubious and unsubstantiated claims:

* Claims to know what the heart of the matter is, and that it is power

* Claims those recommending antitrust are "mostly stuck in the industrial age"

* Claims publisher vs carrier dichotomy is a "trap" without explanation

Nonetheless, when he started talking about an API I got pretty excited.

Re:Facebook and Speech by jay_kyburz on Friday October 18, 2019 @08:44PM (#21296121)
I don't get the API thing? Who is going to say what functions and data are exposed? Why do these services have to pay to host these extra services? Just because we say so? What businesses does it apply to? Does my business have to have open databases?
Re:Facebook and Speech by throwaway_bad on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:14PM (#21292610)
The comment thread is worth linking to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21275269

In particular the Naval Ravikant interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3qHkcs3kG44&t=3661

Re:Facebook and Speech by dannyr on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:01PM (#21292489)
Carrier option likely means Facebook cannot use algorithms to recommend and rank posts that would drive engagement.

Algorithms are a great factor as to why a Facebook got users hooked into its service and drives up ad revenue.