News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Study: GM corn causes organ failure in mice. Parent comment

Re:Study: GM corn causes organ failure in mice by narrator on Friday January 21, 2011 @08:23AM (#2127270)
>The point was: people are incoherent in their dismissal of argument from authority. E.g. many (most?) in anti-GM movement also acknowledge anthropogenic global warming as true, obviously having no issue with IPCC authority on it.

This is just using an ad hominem to attack people who cite the argument from authority fallacy. Science is also based on careful examination of empirical evidence, not unsubstantiated pronouncements by authority figures.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Study: GM corn causes organ failure in mice by varjag on Friday January 21, 2011 @08:54AM (#2127332)
Oh, if only it was that easy!

Consider how long it took to get rid of phlogiston theory in physics, even when falsified by experiments. The physicists of the day were careful and rigorous, honest scientists, and their opponents did not have (initially) any alternative theory to replace it with.

And perhaps we are giving too much credit to most people involved in public debates for examination of empirical evidence. I can say honestly that I tried to read the whole IPCC report, but got barely 1/4th in (it is incredibly thick and dense with facts). Very few of my peers though even glanced as the cover, yet their opinions on it are not any less strong.

[ Parent | on HN ]