News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by jiggawatts on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:40AM (#21257197)
The ZFS-equivalent on Windows is meant to be ReFS, which is roughly equivalent to ZFS when layered on top of Storage Spaces.

I'm really keen to give ReFS+SS a go, but I keep hearing horror stories of abysmal parity-spaces performance, which can only be explained by poor coding and testing.

Even if ZFS has better performance, it's never going to have full support, and it wasn't written for the NT kernel IO model, so I'm dubious about it ever working well...

Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by p_l on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:11AM (#21257344)
There is less mismatch between ZFS and WinNT IO model than between ZFS and Linux VFS.

Sincerely, someone who had to port kernel level code from Linux to NT.

Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by fuzzy2 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @08:13AM (#21257617)
I once tried ReFS, back on Windows 8.1 IIRC. Everything was going fine until suddenly, in the middle of the day, Windows decided that the ReFS volume was corrupt. And then you discover there’s virtually no rescue tools. It nearly gave me a heart attack. After rebooting three times it decided everything was okay again.

I quickly moved away my data and never used ReFS since.

Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by xenospn on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @08:44PM (#21265849)
That happened to me with a beta version of APFS. I never got my data back.
Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by e12e on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:15AM (#21257994)
This entirely misses the fact that zfs (open zfs/zfsonlinux) is open and cross platform.

Which is almost more interesting than all the good stuff that comes with zfs (volume management, disk management, software raid-like functionality, encryption, snapshots, send/receive).

Its the first time we truly have a half-modern filesystem with safe write support and sane performance across many different os's. Even if just made dual booting freebsd and Linux this would be a fmgreat win imnho.

If the choice is between zfs and fat32...

Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by pm7 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:58AM (#21258377)
Unfortunately, FreeBSD uses different ZFS then Linux. Yes, it's crazy, but currently I think it is not guaranteed to be able to mount ZFS between these systems. Fortunately, FreeBSD is supposed to base their ZFS on Linux version in future.
Re:A detailed look at Ubuntu’s new experimental ZFS installer by p_l on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:52AM (#21259770)
ZFS is mountable between Linux and FreeBSD so long as optional features are configured in an appropriate way - this is a benefit of OpenZFS "version 5000" scheme.

IIRC, one of the issues involves the layout of extended attributes. FreeBSD keeps to Solaris layout (which is essentially the same in concept to NTFS' one), while Linux for speeding up certain stuff (and because Linux can't use native xattrs to full extent anyway, due to using Irix API which is limited to PAGESIZE xattrs) has an optional feature to pack xattrs more densely.