I'm really keen to give ReFS+SS a go, but I keep hearing horror stories of abysmal parity-spaces performance, which can only be explained by poor coding and testing.
Even if ZFS has better performance, it's never going to have full support, and it wasn't written for the NT kernel IO model, so I'm dubious about it ever working well...
Sincerely, someone who had to port kernel level code from Linux to NT.
I quickly moved away my data and never used ReFS since.
Which is almost more interesting than all the good stuff that comes with zfs (volume management, disk management, software raid-like functionality, encryption, snapshots, send/receive).
Its the first time we truly have a half-modern filesystem with safe write support and sane performance across many different os's. Even if just made dual booting freebsd and Linux this would be a fmgreat win imnho.
If the choice is between zfs and fat32...
IIRC, one of the issues involves the layout of extended attributes. FreeBSD keeps to Solaris layout (which is essentially the same in concept to NTFS' one), while Linux for speeding up certain stuff (and because Linux can't use native xattrs to full extent anyway, due to using Irix API which is limited to PAGESIZE xattrs) has an optional feature to pack xattrs more densely.
Sounds like you probably ran into zfs not being in Debian proper - and buster unlocking dmcrypt, but not being able to mount zfs? Should normally be salvageable via booting previous Jessie kernel and initial ram/root disk (initrd).
At any rate, I gather you've moved on - just sound like an unlucky break - even with root on unsupported zfs.
But then again, the main reason I haven't is because all of my stuff is backed up via Nextcloud, so reinstalling Debian is pretty quick/painless for me.
Zfs encryption was still a bit new, so both boxes uses dmcrypt on full disk plus efi plus /boot (technically redundant, but it works).
Looking forward to hopefully root on encrypted zfs in next Ubuntu lts.
Curious if snapshots can protect you even as far as OS upgrades gone wrong. I'd assume they can, if all filesystems are ZFS + snapshotted.
My issue was that for some reason Linux no longer could find the encrypted partition to decrypt, so I couldn't get it up to a point where I could even work with it.
Your experience has definitely not discouraged me from wanting to ZFS my root partitions though. If only to provide the potential / theoretical ability to roll back a snapshot if necessary!
I can post my "script" when I get home if you want to try it. I use script very liberally, it was my notes of the commands I used in order in order to get ZFS/dmcrypt working.
(open) Zfs now has native encryption:
https://github.com/zfsonlinux/zfs/releases/tag/zfs-0.8.0
(ed: there are some potential benefits to zfs encryption - it's as cross platform as zfs (encrypt an USB drive, use on Linux, os x, windows, freebsd).
Zfs send/receive - receiver can take your encrypted backup - key doesn't have to travel.
Mount drives across dual boot - share encrypted /home between dual boot windows and Linux?
Not sure - but I think volume encryption is supported too. Might simplify encrypted swap (if you already "pay" for zfs). Note: there are apparently some issues with swap on zfs (volumes at least, possibly files too)
If you don't need suspend/resume - suppose you could share one encrypted swap volume across multiboot environments..) )
Why?
One more addition to other replies: ZFS needs access to disks for self-healing (bit-rot detection and repair). It means that in the past if we wanted encryption, same date needed to be encrypted twice (one for every mirror).
Now with encryption in ZFS, date is encrypted before creating redundancy. We can even do a scrub without encryption key.
Encrypted /home/username filesystem with user-owned keys, is one neat trick,for example.
The ZFS specific encryption IIRC is owned by Oracle, and they do not open source it.
"By the numbers: ZFS Performance Results from Six Operating Systems and Their Derivatives" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrUvjocWopI
Slides: https://callfortesting.org/log/vBSDcon-2019-Dexter-BytheNumb...
And was surprised that zfs for windows (and hyper-v core) appear to be alive and comming along.
Anyone using zfs on windows? Are they also going off of zfsonlinux - and if so how's support for encryption comming?
Finally having shared, read write, encrypted home that works on both Linux and windows safely would be great!