News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by panpanna on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:54PM (#21252125)
Consider this next time you have a good idea and everyone in the room very loudly questions you.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by PhasmaFelis on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:15PM (#21252361)
Hindsight is 20/20, but I suspect that for every revolutionary idea that's initially dismissed as crackpot nonsense, there's a thousand dismissed ideas that actually are crackpot nonsense. It's hard to draw strong general conclusions from looking at outliers.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by panpanna on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:50PM (#21252742)
Sure but looking back, I can also tell you that almost all great ideas I have ever had were initially rejected.

For a long time I thought this was due to poor presentation. Then one day it hit me: the reason boss/coworker doesn't get it is the same reason why he could not come up with the idea himself.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by gamblor956 on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:41PM (#21253192)
A lot of truly terrible ideas are also initially rejected.

Rejection is not an indicator for the merit of an idea.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by mantap on Monday October 14, 2019 @10:52PM (#21255169)
The point is the contrapositive: if your idea is not initially rejected, it's probably quite pedestrian.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by arkitaip on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:23AM (#21256004)
Or maybe you're in a position of great power and people don't dare to question your terrible ideas.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by jjaredsimpson on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:57PM (#21252811)
But how do you know the ideas were/are great? Rejection isn't evidence of quality.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by panpanna on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:19PM (#21253019)
Well, that's a very valid question.

My point is that with time, you can look back at ideas that turned out to be great and recall how they were initially received.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by jacques_chester on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:35AM (#21257446)
Personal recollection is highly unreliable. Especially if you have a mental schema that correlates idea quality with social rejection.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by avip on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:32PM (#21253116)
What's the rejection rate of your poor ideas?
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by btilly on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:04PM (#21252875)
The problem is that impossible seeming results tend to get rejected out of hand no matter how carefully they were done, or how easy to replicate.

This is an extreme example of that, and should stand as a cautionary tale that data should be believed especially when it is in conflict with theory. Rather than being rejected and ignored.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by cauthon on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:41PM (#21253196)
> This is an extreme example of that, and should stand as a cautionary tale that data should be believed especially when it is in conflict with theory. Rather than being rejected and ignored.

This is a terrible sentiment and it needs to stop spreading with these articles about Nobel rejections.

Noticing that your data is in conflict with theory is the best way of realizing that you have made a mistake. Go back to your analysis and work through it until you realize what you did wrong. If you can't find the mistake, then share it with your colleagues/PI, and get them to tell you what you did wrong. If all of their ideas don't explain your result, then you may have found an interesting finding, but you should probably triple check your work and then try to reproduce the finding in new data.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by btilly on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:55PM (#21253302)
It is true that most impossible results are experimental error of one sort or another.

But it is a systemic failure that biologists broadly rejected a result out of hand that had been successfully replicated many times, at multiple labs, over decades. And the attitude that you describe is part of why it happened.

Data that does not fit in existing paradigms should be scrutinized with extra care, not rejected out of hand.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by lonelappde on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @12:11PM (#21260070)
All data should be scrutinized. If you are going to blindly accept data that matches prediction, than don't waste resources collecting the data you aren't going to use -- just use the theory and don't lie about verifyit it.
Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by lonelappde on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @12:08PM (#21260028)
The charge of electron was incorrectly reported in many studies for many years because scientists refused to publish results that contradicted Millikan's incorrect result, and happily published incorrect results because they matched the accepted theori of the time. This is one of Feynman's favorite stories to illustrate Cargo Cult science.

http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by jacques_chester on Monday October 14, 2019 @08:23PM (#21254346)
> But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.

Carl Sagan.

Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ... by BurningFrog on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @01:06AM (#21255713)
Another version of this is "I struggle in school, much like Einstein, therefore etc..."