Re:Peter Ratcliffe's Nobel Prize Winning Study Was Rejected ...
by lonelappde on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @12:11PM
(#21260070)
All data should be scrutinized. If you are going to blindly accept data that matches prediction, than don't waste resources collecting the data you aren't going to use -- just use the theory and don't lie about verifyit it.
But it is a systemic failure that biologists broadly rejected a result out of hand that had been successfully replicated many times, at multiple labs, over decades. And the attitude that you describe is part of why it happened.
Data that does not fit in existing paradigms should be scrutinized with extra care, not rejected out of hand.