Re:Books to read before I die
by ericmcer on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:00PM
(#21252197)
This list and others of its kind have always felt a little off to me. If you read the most famous single book of three different authors I feel like you wouldn’t get too much out of it. I would rather die knowing I read Shakespeare and Faulkner than read Othello and As I lay Dying. This kind of list format takes what should be an organic exploration of other humans who are praised for their writing and turns it into a checklist of disconnected pieces. Maybe you read half a play and hate it, maybe you devour Shakespeare’s entire body of work?
I guess that is also why I dislike a lot of contemporary stuff, the aesthetic life of the artist behind the work is harder and harder to connect with. This all sounds super elitist but it’s hard to discuss books without straying into that territory haha. The breadth of genre is so vast as well, Roald Dahl and Richard Feynman on the same list? It just really lacks a depth of focus to feel like more than ticking boxes.
Re:Books to read before I die
by dawg- on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:41PM
(#21252631)
As a hardcore book lover, I have the deepest hatred for all lists of books. They are pretentious wastes of time, usually written to make the author look like an eclectic and well-rounded person and for no other purpose. This is just about my only strong opinion in the world. I would die a thousand deaths on this hill.
Publishing a list of books like this should be in the same category of social bad habits such as name dropping celebrities you have met, or casually mentioning the large amount of money you make per year ($two hundred Kay), or having a PO Box in a rich neighborhood so you can have an address that impresses people.
Ticking boxes is exactly what it is. If I can be a little overdramatic (yes, now is where that starts), it's a betrayal of the very soul of reading.
Re:Books to read before I die
by jamesrcole on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:07PM
(#21252910)
> As a hardcore book lover, I have the deepest hatred for all lists of books. They are pretentious wastes of time
How do you keep track of the books you want to read?
There are many books I've heard of, and heard people recommend, that I would really like to read. The only way I can keep track of them is by noting them down in lists.
Re:Books to read before I die
by jamesrcole on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:30PM
(#21253099)
Then I’d say to them, what is wrong with publishing your own list of books to read? Others might get something from it. Or your list of book recommendations?
Re:Books to read before I die
by el_cujo on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:33PM
(#21253131)
I think it's totally fair to want to take a sampling of a lot of great authors to try out their work and then maybe follow up on more of their stuff if you find it compelling. True, they might not have the same level of appreciation for the book as if they'd been more familiar with all of their work, but if you try and tell people "you're not going to 'get it' without reading the 17 novels and 8 novellas he wrote before this", then if you're right you're going to just turn people off from trying.
Maybe this is the "plebian" opinion, but I see nothing wrong with wanting a taste of Dahl, Feynman, Homer, and Tolstoy rather than devoting your life to just one. He's reading for pleasure, not writing a dissertation.
Re:Books to read before I die
by jamesrcole on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:20PM
(#21252424)
I list like this can be taken as "books I want to read, amongst all those I end up reading" rather than "the books I must read to the last, before I read any others".
Re:Books to read before I die
by marzell on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:21PM
(#21251760)
I definitely relate to this, even if I no longer have a large physical collection of books. I kinda cringe when I see lists like this of recommended reading, and especially dread that a list might be very compelling, because I already have a personal list that I'll never be able to finish before the end of my life.
Re:Books to read before I die
by zwieback on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:40PM
(#21251956)
True, but there's a difference between buying books and letting them pile up and just keeping a list. I keep mine on Goodreads now and usually get my books from the library. Also, I sell my books back to the bookstore if I didn't love them.
Kindle, on the other hand, never could get into it though it seems great to avoid Tsundoku.
Re:Books to read before I die
by ellius on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:55PM
(#21252140)
There's a fine line, though. Even keeping a list may interfere with feelings of clarity and direction if you become swamped by feelings of obligation. I once heard someone refer to Marie Kondo's "Magic of Tidying Up" as a philosophy book, and I think that's true for things like this. If keeping a big list is useful and makes you happy, for sure, go for it. But make sure it doesn't just create feelings of shame or incompleteness.
Re:Books to read before I die
by AdmiralAsshat on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:28PM
(#21251832)
Can't seem to find a publish date, but this list almost certainly has to be a couple years old, considering Christopher Kimball was ousted from Cooks Country/Cooks Illustrated/America's Test Kitchen in 2015.
Re:Books to read before I die
by OJFord on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:31PM
(#21252533)
Seems like as good a place to ask as any - is there an adblock list style solution for stripping not just query parameters (and I suppose they're sometimes needed, can't always strip them) but also e.g. /ref=blah paths that some (Amazon for example) use as well?
Re:Books to read before I die
by dhosek on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:09PM
(#21252922)
Why? I actually make a point of going to an affiliate link before buying anything from the big river. Just doing my part to reduce their profits as much as possible. (My current go-to is kottke.org although I wouldn't object if people wanted to go to http://don.dream-in-color.net/books/ instead)
Re:Books to read before I die
by dhosek on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:13PM
(#21278014)
I don't think that's actually what's happening with that. ref=nosim is an old thing (no longer necessary) for going to the product page directly. I can't see any tracking that they can do with a URL component that they wouldn't have anyway (e.g., knowing the referrer, IP etc.)
Re:Books to read before I die
by diego on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:11PM
(#21251670)
This is the type of title that I considered sensationalized. "Before I die" is a cliche only used to grab attention, because obviously there are no lists of books to read after one dies.
Re:Books to read before I die
by saalweachter on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:38PM
(#21251936)
I wonder how many different types of bucket lists there are. This is a "to-read" bucket list; I've definitely seen or at least heard other people opine on "to-visit" bucket lists. The more traditional "to-do" bucket list sometimes includes places to visit, but also a more wide-ranging list of activities and experiences.
Re:Books to read before I die
by hasbot on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:33PM
(#21252562)
It'd be nice if he explained why he chose to include each book on the list. I think the section where he lists books that he'd like to reread is the most important section.
Re:Books to read before I die
by bitzun on Monday October 14, 2019 @07:07PM
(#21253833)
I love Cormac McCarthy and Blood Meridian is a fine way to get into his work, but it was a hard read for me because of the pacing. NCfOM, The Road or Outer Dark are easier to follow IMO. I hope this comment is considered useful enough to pass the HN guidelines.
Re:Books to read before I die
by ghaff on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:14PM
(#21251698)
Given that this was presumably published when he was still in charge of the business, it would hardly be surprising if a lot of the list were contributed by others.
(Kimball's no longer involved with CI. He left a while back under acrimonious circumstances.)
Re:Books to read before I die
by ghaff on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:09PM
(#21252927)
I admit I haven't watched the show for a while. The new podcast (Proof) is much better than the old ATK one though IMO. It also feels as if they've gotten a bit more adventurous with recipes; they always felt rather conservative mid-American under Kimball.
Re:Books to read before I die
by twirlip on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:22PM
(#21253046)
Xerox PARC alum, main designer of the sequel to the Xerox Alto computer, the Xerox Star, which is the the first modern personal computer (GUI, mouse, Ethernet, print & file servers, etc).
I guess that is also why I dislike a lot of contemporary stuff, the aesthetic life of the artist behind the work is harder and harder to connect with. This all sounds super elitist but it’s hard to discuss books without straying into that territory haha. The breadth of genre is so vast as well, Roald Dahl and Richard Feynman on the same list? It just really lacks a depth of focus to feel like more than ticking boxes.
Publishing a list of books like this should be in the same category of social bad habits such as name dropping celebrities you have met, or casually mentioning the large amount of money you make per year ($two hundred Kay), or having a PO Box in a rich neighborhood so you can have an address that impresses people.
Ticking boxes is exactly what it is. If I can be a little overdramatic (yes, now is where that starts), it's a betrayal of the very soul of reading.
How do you keep track of the books you want to read?
There are many books I've heard of, and heard people recommend, that I would really like to read. The only way I can keep track of them is by noting them down in lists.
Maybe this is the "plebian" opinion, but I see nothing wrong with wanting a taste of Dahl, Feynman, Homer, and Tolstoy rather than devoting your life to just one. He's reading for pleasure, not writing a dissertation.
Kindle, on the other hand, never could get into it though it seems great to avoid Tsundoku.
https://www.cooksillustrated.com/magazines/188-july-slash-au...
https://www.bookofjoe.com/2014/06/cooks-illustrated-editor-c...
I wonder what else warrants a full bucket list.
(Kimball's no longer involved with CI. He left a while back under acrimonious circumstances.)