Re:Hong Kong protests: President Xi warns of 'bodies smashed'
by lm28469 on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:04PM
(#21249734)
Meh, it's like saying New York could fight off the entire US army by using asymmetrical tactics. US invading Vietnam or Afghanistan isn't exactly the same: China is literally surrounding HK and has one of strongest army in the world. They could obliterate HK in a few hours.
The only way I see it ending well is if somehow the military/police side with HK and China decide that it isn't worth the trouble. Even if China goes full berserk on HK I don't see the EU or US doing more than economic sanctions, and we all know this is as bad for US as it is for them.
Re:Hong Kong protests: President Xi warns of 'bodies smashed'
by CharlesColeman on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:15PM
(#21249866)
> They could obliterate HK in a few hours.
If the population of HK was sufficiently armed and motivated, the only way the PLA could do that "in a few hours" is with nukes.
But you make a good point: asymmetric tactics can be countered with indiscriminate extermination. However the diplomatic fallout of such tactics is likely unacceptable, even to the PRC.
Re:Hong Kong protests: President Xi warns of 'bodies smashed'
by chongli on Monday October 14, 2019 @02:10PM
(#21251095)
the only way the PLA could do that "in a few hours" is with nukes
No, they could obliterate HK with conventional artillery. But that would be a huge mistake, to say the least.
Re:Hong Kong protests: President Xi warns of 'bodies smashed'
by toast0 on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:37PM
(#21250109)
Armed resistance escalates the conflict. This can be a win for the resistance because the opponent may not be willing to bring artillery, or to deny the opponent unsullied spoils.
Re:Hong Kong protests: President Xi warns of 'bodies smashed'
by nostrademons on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:50PM
(#21250233)
Afghan guerillas are using a number of modern arms (RPGs, Stingers) as well, plus IEDs. Helicopters don't get downed by rifles.
No, that's wrong. Conflicts like the one in Afghanistan show they can be effective against a well-equipped modern army, you just need to deploy them with the right (asymmetric) tactics.