The more interesting and relevant question is whether it is right or wrong. The answer to that question is not automatically the same as lawful/unlawful. Even in a democracy.
There is a huge political context around this trial, and I believe that the fact that my parent post was arguing that we should discuss about morality, not just legality, is a way to introduce this context into the evaluation of the trial to assess - and condemn - the result. I think this is mis characterizing the quality of the trial itself. Plenty of people are decrying the trial result because they want independence, which to me is intellectually dishonest. I was thus arguing that the trial itself was right, responding to a direct ask to consider right vs wrong.
>Trying to secede in a country where secession is illegal, is... you know... a crime.
This tone is baffling to me. I don't think anybody is surprised that countries dislike secession.
>Also, please downvote me. Actual statement of facts aren't welcomed here.
I don't claim to speak for "here", but, personally, this pettiness at the end of your comment is what I'd like most to be absent from HN.
Not at all, and failing to do so can be itself a crime.
Ironically, you are patently wrong.
As the other poster mentions, mandatory prosecution exists in many parts of the world, and Spain is indeed one of these places.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2... is the clearest English-language reference I can find. Specifically:
> The Member States’ criminal systems are divided on the issue of mandatory or discretionary prosecution. The discretionary principle is applied in Belgium, France, Denmark, Ireland, the United Kingdom, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. In Germany, Austria, Spain, Finland, Sweden, Greece, Italy and Portugal the mandatory prosecution principle applies.
> The mandatory prosecution principle is that the prosecution authorities must act – even if no complaint has been lodged – where they suspect that an offence has been committed.
Prosecuting this is not optional.
That's not to say the government could not have applied pressure somehow if they wished of course (though in theory that's strongly discouraged), or even attempted to change the law entirely. Doing so publicly in any way though would pretty seriously harm their election changes on a national level (election is coming on November 11th).
I'm from the US and I find the notion of mandatory prosecution nonsensical. There is a limit to the workload a prosecutor can handle and prioritizing crimes is just one way to make sure more serious crimes get the manpower needed to prosecute.
But thank you for pointing out that, also, the laws can always be changed which ultimately is political.
https://law.jrank.org/pages/1870/Prosecution-Prosecutorial-D...
“The legality principle commands that every case in which there is enough evidence and in which no legal hindrances prohibit prosecution has to be brought to court. Adherence to the legality principle in the procedural sense means that the prosecution service cannot exercise any discretion over the prosecutorial decision. Its role is limited to the legal assessment of the sufficiency of the evidence against the suspect. Other considerations – what are known as public interest factors in opportunity systems – are not considered as factors that prosecutors are allowed to deploy in their decisions. Rather, the public interest is regarded as a consideration for the court which might be reflected in the verdict or the penalty imposed.”
http://www.law.gov.cy/law/lawoffice.nsf/0/A5FCDD28D5A9112CC2...
Article 1.2 - Spanish Constitution: 'National sovereignty is vested in the Spanish people, from whom emanate the powers of the State.'
http://www.congreso.es/constitucion/ficheros/c78/cons_ingl.p...
In my opinion there are huge stresses in Spain that will open the can of worms that is redefining the Constitution during the next decades. Republicanism, decentralization, chunks of the constitution that nobody really puts in practice, etc. That wont happen in 2 days. But it can happen.
The whole US was founded on the idea of a right to self-determination. Without unilateral separation, it would still be part of England.
That’s the thing with revolutions. They are only ok if they work.
It seems that the holy right of self-determination does not apply if you are a native indian for some reason. Is even more strange if we think that indians comprised once the big majority of people living in that territory.
This shiny right does not apply also if you belong in the majority comprised by non-nationalist people living in Cataluña. Is strange that people so democratic and pacific didn't noticed that other people has rights also.
That also happened some centuries ago, what was politically acceptable or moral was quite different then. I’d like to think that we now have the political maturity to do this slowly, legally and peacefully if it needs to happen at all.
It was specifically left out of the Constitution, for a few complex reasons, but from a de facto / de jure perspective, was ambiguous at best, until decided by war.
Fun fact: British America was around 200 years old when it gained independence. Catalonia has been part of Spain (as opposed to an independent principality) for around 300 years.
Poor handling, and particularly heavy handed handling, turned those moderates with a valid grievance into revolutionaries, and secessionists. The East India company was trying to screw over both Britain and the American colonies in equal measure.
There probably is a modern lesson in there, which is what results from overly draconian response, and something something overly powerful corporations.
I bet that this land didn't arrived in a ship and was in the same place for a few millions of years at least. Spain has more than 300 years of history.
There are other kinds of contracts(marriage is a contract), where one of the partners can't just walk away from it with its share of the assets.
> There's people demanding a referendum (as seen in Scotland) you just put them in jail, problem solved.
It only seems a good example because it didn't pass. I bet it would be a worse-than-Brexit one if it had. The reality is that a country(a modern state) is built over a thousand of trade-offs that can't be just decided in a referendum.
I wish it would be that easy. I'm pretty tired of this mess.
Any criminal could just "vote" that what they did is legal. How would that work?
Sure, form opinions, ask for change, make it better if you and others see fit. You don't even have to follow he law. You just have to understand that if you break it you get punished. So as long as the law is there and you break it you are a criminal whether you believe in it or not.
What you said is exactly the kind of excuse any criminal would use: "I'm not guilty because I don't believe in that law". Which seems to match perfectly with the reasoning used in the dozens of comment you posted about this, alongside some bad examples and analogies that attempt to support it.
Facts we know (at least some of us, closer to the situation).
"What did you expect" is more loaded, as it also invokes political, and moral expectations, and can be misconstrued as "they got what they deserved" (as opposed to a neutral "they got what the law states").
And even the law can be bend, when there's a large public will -- e.g. the government is forced to reach a compromise, etc.
So, "secession is prohibited" is not enough to warrantee the current outcome.
As an example, dictatorship is also prohibited, but more than a few dictators or wannabe coup arranged for cosy non-jail deals when they were thrown out and democracy was restored...
The rest of Spaniards had been called all kind of nasty things from this people, from fascists to thiefs, pigs, dumbs, violators, abusers and even dirty people that does not wash themselves.
Not to mention the reverse David-Star that where in fact the yellow ribbons. You don't wear it, you're harassed and called traitor and botifler. Friends of my parents, elder people that could suffer an infart, were assaulted with some people entering in their bus, crying slogans, calling them fascists and harassing them pushing banners and yellow ribbons under their nose. All of this just because they were in a holiday in the wrong part of the country and had commit the crime to hire a local bus to make an excursion. The driver didn't even tried to stop they.
Journalists doing their job were trown bottles with piss and water in direct. All in the name of peace.
Entire families are angry and split today because this snakes and child-emperors wanted to suck-suck-suck even more money
See the newspaper archives.
You could say the same things are said from the 'other side' of the debate, I'm sure people say all these things from both sides, you cannot control everyone on such a big movements/issues. What I'm sure is that I haven't seen any leader say all that adjectives to anyone.
"Not to mention the anti-David-Star that where in fact the yellow ribbons".
Well... 'anti-david-star' what a nice way to describe the same ribbons (with different color) that people wear on the world cancer day.
The independence movement has always talked about the State/Government not letting people decide. It's not about hating someone because they think different than you. It's about an exercise of democracy.
Please do not dare try again to take us for idiots. We are not talking of anonymous people, we are talking of all main independentist leaders acting as victims and light beings whereas saying things like those of spaniards:
"Scavengers, vipers, hyenas. Beasts with human form, however, that distil hate. A disturbed, nauseating hatred, like moldy dentures, against everything the tongue represents. They are here among us. They are disgusted by any expression of Catalanness... Beasts have names and surnames. We all know somebody"
Not, is not the nazi party in 1933, is President Torra spreading love in 2012.
Another example:
"Mrs. María Llanos de Luna devotes more time to her hairstyles than to the culture of the country where she lives... No, it is not natural to speak Spanish in Catalonia"
Not to mention this silly 2010 video from CIU party: "Spain steals from us". Has been 10 years hearing this victimism all the time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QdyOSgbIVY
If you had being harassed for not-bearing a cancer ribbon, please don't hesitate to tell us your experience.
(hum, just see now that "infart" is not an english word, heart attack is the correct term)
(and it feels weird to put UK up there as a positive example with regards to mature handling of elections..)
Regarding stonewalling, they already have a much bigger representation than what their relative headcount would guarantee. It’s just that the rest of Spain, and more than half of Catalonia, don’t want the second richest region to leave with all the wealth that we all together have concentrated there throughout the years.
Edit: Your reference is talking about rebellion. Not relevant?
To my understanding, a German judge ruled that there are no corresponding laws in practice. The ones considered to be similar by the letter are handled differently: the German highest court has put a much higher hurdle to their application then the Spanish court did.
And much less in the "they should expect that it might result in violence, when we send our armed riot police in" kind of violence, but the "people will use violence against people because of their religion/skin/sexuality/..." kind.
As I understand it, it was never even considered and thrown out right away.
It's hard to find anything very close to sedición, particularly given that I've understood that the Spanish Supreme Court has now found that threat of force or violence was not involved, apparently (?) basing their decision on the very broad sounding "outside of legal means" part. Please correct me if I'm mistaken.
This is a lie, only the cops were violent.
E: If you think I'm wrong then post evidence and a bitcoin address, I'll gladly pay you $500 if you can show substantial evidence that there was violence involved. You won't be able to.
Compare those clips to these https://spanishpolice.github.io/
This was your original claim. You are implicitely withdrawing it and moving the goalpost to "evidence of substantial violence"(which is ok, but it was so easy to rebate in its original form that couldn't resist). BTW, states have the monopoly of violence which makes the comparison complicated to asses to anyone who believes in representative democracy and the separation of powers(policemen were trying to execute a court order, no less and no more).
You can keep your 500$, I already knew you were bluffing.
Regarding the issue you are bringing. Yes, the police intervention was a massive clusterfuck. It was impossible to stop the so called "referendum" without the complete cooperation of catalan police and the civil guard and national police cops were sent to an impossible mission. Some of them misbehave, probably out of frustration and fear/anger. This is something a policemen should never do.
If that's your point I could agree.
Maybe in theory. But looking at American civil war, Russian war in Chechenia, and others, in practice it certainly isn't so.
No one is arguing whether what they are doing is legal or not, we are arguing whether it's right or wrong.
My parents and other family members that grew under Franco warned everyone that this is how the Spain would react, so again, not that we didn't know.
And they did it anyway.
The trial was highly questionable, starting on how the judge was appointed (breaking default procedure), continuing with the lack of memory of all Spanish governmental officials, and ending with not letting the defenses show videos that directly contradicted the sworn deposition of armed forces. This will all be revisited in the European Tribunal for Human Rights, of course, and Spain will get a slap in the hand and Europe will move on.
Technically speaking, as you say, they could have been charged with disobedience, as there was no violence, but you would rather have a death sentence for treason, I see...
These decisions smell like they might end up before the Court as well. If found in violation, for sake of consistency at least, personally I think the EU Commission should take a serious look whether this should elicit a rule of law review akin to that applied to Poland and Hungary. (Note: I'm not saying this is necessarily as serious.)
Sight. And there they go again... with their obvious lies and stupid statements that don't resist two minutes of research.
And who are "they"? I'm no one particularly invested in this hassle.
They were. However, they were all acquitted of that charge (called 'rebellion' in Spain).
“The first duty of a revolutionary is to get away with it.” ― Abbie Hoffman, Steal This Book
I mean... Not in practice.
Just ask the US or Russian states.
So it goes.
The USSR recognized the independence of those Baltic states (after military control of the situation failed) on 6 September 1991 and disappeared a few weeks later. Not the best example of orderly and and amicable secession, I think.