News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jasode on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:07PM (#21242610)
I don't remember where I read the following analysis (maybe from someone here on HN?) but it goes something like this...

Costco's membership fee (minimum is $60) has several benefits that the media don't like to talk about -- because it's unpleasant to mention it. The membership fee charged by Costco helps keep the riff-raff out. Although the cheapest Costco membership at $60/year looks like a trivial amount to middle-income people, even that tiny cost is enough to be an unreachable Mt Everest for the poorest segments of society. Therefore, the membership fee acts as a socially acceptable way to keep out the undesirables.

Often, you'll see a thread on reddit showing photos of "Walmart shoppers" with tube tops and loose pants with butt cracks showing. That's not the type of clientele that shops at Costco. Walmart also has a huge problem with shoplifting and employee theft (what the retail industry calls "shrinkage") and therefore, there's often a police car outside to arrest somebody. Costco's membership requirement is the hurdle that helps them avoid all that.

Costco makes money on the membership fees itself, but they also save money by not having to deal with shrinkage because their higher-income clientele has less problems.

The above advantages only adds to the other positives such as simpler logistics of ~4000 SKUs at Costco vs 40000 SKUs at Walmart.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by lotsofpulp on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:31PM (#21242771)
Sounds like an erroneous analysis to me. The cost of a $60 membership pales in comparison to the cost of the space needed to store bulk items, especially refrigerated, and the cost of travel to and from a Costco, which are not located in the poorest areas.

Most importantly, $60 cash upfront for a membership fee is nothing compared to all the cash you need to buy bulk items upfront. Is selling bulk items a way to keep "riff-raff" out?

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jasode on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:25PM (#21243162)
>Is selling bulk items a way to keep "riff-raff" out?

Yes, bulk size prices can act as a secondary filter but an interesting mechanism is the membership cards are checked at the door and physically keep people out whereas bulk prices (even if low-income people don't buy them) don't accomplish the exact same effect. Membership gatekeeping at the entrance keeps the undesired shoppers away from the loss leaders of cheap $2 hotdogs & pizza, and taking advantage of the various free samples of food demonstrated at the aisles without buying anything. The door-based gatekeeping (as opposed to bulk prices gatekeeping) also minimizes customer shoplifting, etc.

There are also multiple levels of what "bulk" supply is. Is it restaurant-sized bulk (e.g. a gargantuan 4-gallon tub of mayonnaise) -- or a more modest family-sized type of bulk (e.g. 35-cans of Costco brand Kirkland soda for $7.99). Walmart sells 20-can pack of Coke for $16.00.

There's a lot of stuff that Costco sells that poor families could buy. Their bread is very cheap and one can buy 1 loaf for $5.00 instead of buying in bulk. Another person mentioned Costco gasoline is often the cheapest in town and poor people could save money refilling their car there. Their Kirkland clothes are really inexpensive. I just bought a 6-pack of Kirkland tshirts for $12.97. Walmart sells 6-pack FruitLoom for $16.00. (I think you'll agree 6 count of tshirts is not a bulk supply.) However, to save $3.00 on tshirts in that one transaction and similar subsequent ones, one has to plan ahead and spend $60 upfront. If you look at businesses for poor people like cash checking services, payday loans, and "Buy Here Pay Here" used-car lots, a lot of low-income people really can't scrape together $60 and pay it now for the purpose of saving more than $60 in the future. Their budgeting is so day-to-day (literally "paycheck-to-paycheck") that they have to shop at Walmart which is often more expensive than Costco.

EDIT add for clarity: when you say ", $60 cash upfront for a membership fee is nothing compared to all the cash you need to buy bulk items upfront", you're using a middle-class income lens. E.g. I'm also middle class and I spend $7000/year at Costco which dwarfs the $60 membership fee. Yes, poor people can't spend that same way. Instead, I'm saying that poor people can spend much less (say ~$500/year) and still get more than $60 savings back without tying up lots of cash in bulk purchases like you and I would do.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by fortran77 on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:43PM (#21243300)
That's why my local Food Bank/ Community Services (Sunnyvale Community Services) likes cash donations. They then go and shop at Costco for many items for the poor--including essential clothing items.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by nickpsecurity on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:44PM (#21243739)
I'll add two other benefits:

1. Poor people can group up to split both the membership fee and bulk items. Especially things like soap or razors with big discounts.

2. Costco also makes healthier stuff available at low cost that you might not match per ounce or whatever elsewhere. The Grow Right Orange Juice (2-pack), mix of rice/amaranyh/eyc (5-pack), and Go Organic Detergent are examples in our household. This will appeal to working-class and up mostly but some poor people still get some healthy stuff. Esp for kids or folks that are sick. Aldi is first choice, though, since remodel added tons of healthier stuff.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by sunstone on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:11PM (#21243501)
Slight clarification, I'm pretty sure you can eat at the hotdog bar without a membership.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jasode on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:18PM (#21243544)
Yes, a recent reddit thread[0] says it varies on location. Some Costcos have hot dog food court outside instead of inside. And for the food courts inside, some stores' staff check for a membership card, and some don't.

[0] https://old.reddit.com/r/Costco/comments/9bvjea/can_i_get_a_...

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by Scoundreller on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:23PM (#21243577)
In a lot of places, their pharmacy isn't allowed to require a membership, so just say that and they'll let you in the store.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jnellis on Sunday October 13, 2019 @07:16PM (#21243940)
It's a federal law, so its all places (in America.)
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by neltnerb on Sunday October 13, 2019 @11:22PM (#21245021)
You can go to the liquor store at the one near Boston as well, though their prices are worse than several of the dedicated liquor stores down the street.

I've known people to go there as an after practice group activity to talk and eat incredibly cheap food. I wonder if they actually do lose money, their selection is so limited and the amount sold so high. I bet they make a small profit.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by thaumasiotes on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:29AM (#21245957)
> bulk size prices can act as a secondary filter but an interesting mechanism is the membership cards are checked at the door and physically keep people out whereas bulk prices (even if low-income people don't buy them) don't accomplish the exact same effect.

But this is untrue. Costco doesn't check membership at the door. That would block you from purchasing things that don't require membership.

They check membership at the cash register. Anyone and everyone is free to walk inside.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jasode on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:22AM (#21246145)
>Costco doesn't check membership at the door. That would block you from purchasing things that don't require membership.

The 3 Costcos in my area all have staff checking for membership cards right at the door.

Yes, if one knows the "life hacks" such as the pharmacy hack, the liquor law hack, the "I'm picking up contact lenses at the eye center for my friend" hack, and lastly, the "I want to browse the store before I buy a membership" hack, the staff will let you through.

Apparently, all the above hacks are enough psychological friction and/or are not well-known that Costco has much less volume of problem shoppers than Walmart.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by thaumasiotes on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:28PM (#21253086)
This is good evidence that the membership checks provide value to customers by keeping the riffraff away.

It's terrible evidence that the membership requirement provides any such value. Those checks are independent of the requirement -- as you acknowledge, the guards at the door are not even empowered to turn you away if you want to go in. (That said, I'll repeat that at my Costco, there is no check at the door.)

In a better world, Costco could admit that the "membership checks" are actually there to keep the tone of the store at a certain level, not to check membership. It'd be more convenient for everyone, and also more honest.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by beagle3 on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:37AM (#21246206)
Last time I was in a costco in maryland they most certainly did check membership at the door. Maybe it varies by store/region.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by loco5niner on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:32PM (#21250061)
> Costco doesn't check membership at the door.

Every Costco I've been to does. at least 7+ locations across Oregon and Washington

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by labster on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:15PM (#21243097)
Poor people are the people that have to drive everywhere, so I don't think location has much to do with it.

Costco in Ventura County has two stores: the one in the rich area in Simi Valley, and the one in a (relatively speaking) poor area in Oxnard. The Simi store is half empty, while the Oxnard store has one of the highest sales in the entire chain.

I actually don't know if the $60 keeps anyone out. I think it's just pure profit, and an inducement for customers to return so they "get what they pay for." People are terrible at thinking about sunk costs, you know.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by macintux on Sunday October 13, 2019 @09:51PM (#21244664)
> Poor people are the people that have to drive everywhere

I don’t know what this means. I assume that’s a regional difference.

I live in an area where there are a lot of people who have to walk or rely on an incredibly unreliable and slow bus system. They’re not going to make a trip 5+ miles to the nearest Costco, especially since they’d have to walk half a mile to/from the bus stop and try to manage those bulk goods along the way.

Not to mention the fact that our bus system is mostly hub and spoke, so the bus trip would take 2-3 hours each way.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by labster on Monday October 14, 2019 @12:18AM (#21245240)
Sorry, SoCalian here. Everyone has a car. If you’re rich you can afford to live close to your job. If you’re poor you have to drive to work over an hour each way. If you’re homeless you live in your car. Buses exist, but no one knows where they came from or why they exist.

(Please don’t argue exceptions, I’m being reductionist on purpose)

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by _delirium on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:07AM (#21246345)
The exceptions are only rare if you're not poor! Car ownership is near 100% among affluent people, but drops to around 50% in the lowest income quintile. Which is why the LA bus system that "nobody" rides has 800,000 daily riders.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by neltnerb on Sunday October 13, 2019 @11:26PM (#21245034)
My experience is that even with the most awful transit system it is possible to make group trips with multiple families together with one card using one person's car. Even in a city with no transit at all surely you can find someone once a month willing to drive in exchange for free access to the lower prices on stuff, it's just common sense. Now Costco versus other options is hard to say, but their prices on certain things are hard to beat.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by albedoa on Monday October 14, 2019 @01:07AM (#21245406)
> I don’t know what this means. I assume that’s a regional difference.

The rest of your post describes a region where I would expect that statement to be particularly true. Does everyone live conveniently near their work, or are your low-income jobs forgiving of your incredibly unreliable and slow bus system? Either of those would stand out more as a regional difference.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by pixl97 on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:57PM (#21242977)
>selling bulk items a way to keep "riff-raff" out?

It depends, but in many areas with extreme poverty and drug use there are businesses that break apart packages and sell single items, even when it is a violation of the law, such as single cigarettes

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by twothamendment on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:11PM (#21243065)
They weren't riff-raff, but one of my neighbors who was on a tight budget couldn't afford to shop there because buying in bulk meant laying out a lot of cash at once. They were convinced they wanted to buy bulk staples and save, so the went rice and beans for a month so they could save up for a Costco trip. They claim they save quite a bit buying at Costco, but those bulk prices can indeed be a hurdle.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:17PM (#21243108)
Also, the vast majority of retail shrinkage is employee theft; if CostCo has a big advantage there, it's it's better-paid employees, more than higher-income customers.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by jasode on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:32PM (#21243206)
>Also, the vast majority of retail shrinkage is employee theft;

I did a cursory google on this and of the 5 random sources I looked at, they said the majority of shrinkage is customer shoplifting. Did you come across something reputable that concluded differently?

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by rficcaglia on Sunday October 13, 2019 @10:19PM (#21244771)
I dunno about majority internal vs shoplifting but I saw a Kroger internal report once that ~2% revenues lost annually to “loss”. It was not broken down by category, but it was the preface to a 4 hour presentation on employee loss prevention techniques, so I’m connecting dots...
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by Danieru on Monday October 14, 2019 @01:05AM (#21245400)
Remembering my chats with loss prevention at Walmart while I worked there: by volume customers are the worst overall, but employee theft are the worst per person. Thus catching one employee thief represents several thousand in losses. Meanwhile customer theft is dealt with in a more bulk-like fashion.

Left unchecked employee theft can scale. Think of a cashier skimming cash, or customer service person colluding with a friend to return junk. Both customer and employee theft require stoppage, but employees are tough because they are trusted by default.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by unlinked_dll on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:39PM (#21242821)
This sounds like BS unless you have numbers. Shopping at Costco is like riding the NYC subway - it's a cross section of society from all income levels.

Costco saves people hundreds to thousands of dollars a year both in time and price. Shopping there isn't exactly a luxury experience.

I'd guess the fact you need to enter with a photo ID and they keep records on everyone entering/leaving with their names and addresses attached is a much bigger factor at loss prevention.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by agentdrtran on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:11PM (#21243062)
> Shopping at Costco is like riding the NYC subway - it's a cross section of society from all income levels.

The linked article says this isn't true.

"Unlike other discount chain customers, the majority of these cardholders are largely affluent ($100k+ income) and college-educated"

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by unlinked_dll on Sunday October 13, 2019 @09:44PM (#21244640)
It's also uncited. There are a few other articles that say the same thing (or more accurately, paraphrasing "the average customer at costco has a yearly income of $100k") and none of them are cited either.

I skimmed some investor documents/earnings call transcripts and couldn't find much discussion of what members are like from Costco themselves, just third parties.

I'm just a bit skeptical of that factoid. It smells funny.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by albedoa on Monday October 14, 2019 @01:18AM (#21245437)
CNBC cites 2017 data from Costco:

In 2017, the most recent year Costco has data for, the average household income of the Costco member was $92,236.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/22/hooked-how-costco-turns-cust...

Regardless of your threshold for reliability, I would be much more interested in anything that demonstrates your claim that Costco is "a cross section of society from all income levels".

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by albedoa on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:06PM (#21301927)
crickets
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by youeseh on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:19PM (#21242690)
Costco also has security personnel that work hard to prevent shoplifting - from people walking around, to the people by the exit who crosscheck the receipts with what they see in the cart.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by timClicks on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:26PM (#21242737)
Naturally, but defense in depth.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by ProfessorLayton on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:08PM (#21243044)
When I was working in retail during college, they made it very clear that most shrinkage actually comes from employees and not shoppers. Employees with bags were searched by loss prevention on their way out of the store, and we were required to use a separate entrance/exit than shoppers.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by bradleyankrom on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:43PM (#21242866)
Would add that people buying in the quantities offered at Costco are likely to live in a place that’s large enough to accommodate storing those items.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by madengr on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:10PM (#21243058)
True, for this family of 4. We buy the big pack of Scott toilet paper, and store it amongst 4 bathrooms; same for tissues, both 2x a year. Paper towels in the garage, along with detergent and bleach. Bulk meat in a small deep freeze. A $6 bag of garlic lasts for months, but just toss it even if it’s only 1/2 used, as that would buy you 6 bulbs at the normal grocer.
[dead]
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by vl on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:00PM (#21244187)
Typical modern American house has at least 3 bathrooms: downstairs, upstairs master bedroom for parents, upstairs shared for kids. Downstairs ”in-law” room with private bathroom or washer/dryer closet with toilet gives you fourth.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by shostack on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:37PM (#21243683)
Which is frustrating in places the Bay Area. Even if you can afford and benefit from Costco and buying in bulk, it's not easy to find space to store a single trip's worth of stuff in the tiny homes out here.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by noitsnot on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:41PM (#21242847)
Low income families won't pay anything extra to shop at stores like Costco, BJ's, etc, nevermind $60, which seems high. I imagine they can't afford to buy in bulk, to begin with.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by chiph on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:58PM (#21242981)
If they qualify, they ought to get the Costco credit card (there are lower credit limits available). I typically make a $250+ profit each year, even after paying $120 for the executive membership.

I usually split some purchases with friends, like the Kirkland microwave popcorn. It will go bad before I can eat it all, but split it 3 or 4 ways, and it's not wasted.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by 1123581321 on Monday October 14, 2019 @02:05AM (#21245621)
Sam’s Club has similar clientele to Walmart and more shrinkage issues (I spend time regularly in all three stores.) The Costco difference is about the types of products that are sold, the locations, the brand, and the quality/wage of the employees, not the membership fee.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by sjg007 on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:05PM (#21243475)
It's also hard to walk out with a 75" tv or a giant flat of tomato soup..
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by Scoundreller on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:25PM (#21243594)
I guess the membership makes it harder to use a cloned credit card too.

Not impossible (just signup for a membership), but that's a barrier carders wouldn't want to bother with.

Especially since carders don't care about price, just time and risk.

And the Costco parking lot is the last place I would want to include in a getaway.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by lttlrck on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:33PM (#21242785)
I’d imagine the high average per item cost has the same filtering effect.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by trianglem on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:40PM (#21242835)
I disagree. $60 a year is so low it's not prohibitive to any segment of American society.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by axus on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:03PM (#21243010)
If it cost $60 to vote, it would rightly be called voter suppression.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by hunterloftis on Monday October 14, 2019 @01:32AM (#21245489)
An unmarried minimum-wage worker working 40 hours/week will net about $1,085/month, so $60 would consume 11% of their biweekly paycheck.

I don't know about you, but dropping 11% of my paycheck on a membership card would certainly be a barrier for me.

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by trianglem on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:40PM (#21251962)
It is $60/yr, not per month. It's less than $5 a month.
Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by hunterloftis on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:51PM (#21252757)
I know. And I wouldn't drop 11% of my paycheck in a single month on a yearlong membership to anything.

“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.

Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.

But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.

This was the Captain Samuel Vimes 'Boots' theory of socioeconomic unfairness.”

Re:Costco gained a cult following by breaking every rule of ... by hogFeast on Sunday October 13, 2019 @04:17PM (#21242681)
Another point is that paying upfront for something means you have to use it.

I remember when I joined a real cult. It cost $5k just to join, and another $5k to advance a level. So when you are down $20k and someone asks you to move to the Brazilian rainforest to live in a mud hut...well, you can't really say no. Remember: you can fly to Brazil, just don't enter the cave.