News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by Aloha on Thursday October 10, 2019 @06:46PM (#21219947)
The US isn't a closed market and can't effectively eject Apple from the market. While I disagree with the choice Apple made, it's a very rational one. Permanent removal from China would probably be worse for freedom in China over 20 years, and massively worse for Apple in the short term.

No company should be expected to back or foment a revolution somewhere, from my perspective they're looking out for their own beet interest and the best interest of their customers.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by mortenjorck on Thursday October 10, 2019 @08:32PM (#21220529)
> Permanent removal from China would probably be worse for freedom in China over 20 years

If there is one myth that the past couple of weeks have conclusively debunked, it is the idealistic conceit that the presence of western businesses in the Chinese market will inevitably liberalize China.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by kelnos on Friday October 11, 2019 @02:21AM (#21222000)
Past couple of weeks? Developing China's economy and integrating it into world markets with the expectation that it would liberalize China has been a pipe dream for a good 30+ years now.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by inlined on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:20AM (#21221759)
I wonder if the backlash will form the opposite theory? Will people try to make the firewall bidirectional to prevent this type of global censorship?
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by eddieplan9 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @10:38PM (#21221066)
I honestly don't care when Apple complies with local law a la iCloud China. I think that is disappointing but completely reasonable, whether we agree with the law or not.

However, Hong Kong is a special administration region, and has historically enjoyed high level of judicial independence. When Apple takes the clue from a Chinese government newspaper - not even a legal request - and do the CCP's bidding proactively, it crosses a line. This is not compliance. This is self-censor.

You can argue that Hong Kong is part of China, and therefore Apple's operation in Hong Kong should comply with Chinese law. But what is next? China also claims sovereignty over Taiwan, will Apple self-censor Taiwanese App Store soon? Will Apple removes the Taiwanese flag from Taiwanese iOS users if China government demands so [1]?

It's also sad to see Apple pushes back on US government requests because they can, and kowtows to the Chinese governments without their having to even sending a take-down request! If one day Apple fires some employee because the Chinese government thinks he/she "hurt Chinese people's feeling" in a personal tweet [2], I will not be surprised!

[1] https://www.engadget.com/2019/10/09/apple-removes-taiwan-fla...

[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/nba/nba-statement-diff...

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by sushicat on Friday October 11, 2019 @02:28AM (#21222025)
Taiwan and Hong Kong are totally different cases.

Taiwan is an independent country, no matter Chinese gov admits it or not. It has their own government, laws, military etc.

Hong Kong is not, it’s only a special area belonging to China. When British handed it over to China years ago, China promised the situation will not change for 50 years. Although it’s a lie, it shows that China will have full control of HK eventually.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by kerkeslager on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:06AM (#21221477)
> Permanent removal from China would probably be worse for freedom in China over 20 years,

Huh?

> No company should be expected to back or foment a revolution somewhere, from my perspective they're looking out for their own beet interest and the best interest of their customers.

Profit is not an adequate moral compass. I deeply disagree that by forming a corporation, individuals who would otherwise have ethical obligations are somehow no longer obligated to behave ethically. You're literally claiming that it's okay to enable the violation of human rights for profit.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by Aloha on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:29AM (#21221792)
Removal of an app is not enabling the violation of human rights. Now if Apple turned over the name and address of every person who had the app, that'd be the enabling of violating human rights.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by kerkeslager on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:06AM (#21223506)
> Removal of an app is not enabling the violation of human rights. Now if Apple turned over the name and address of every person who had the app, that'd be the enabling of violating human rights.

This is the line you want to draw? "I didn't help them tear gas the protestors, I just made it harder for protestors to avoid being tear gassed?"

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by dkonofalski on Monday October 14, 2019 @11:48AM (#21249567)
That is an incredibly flawed statement. Apple's not the one putting any barricades up. The Chinese government is.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by computerex on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @12:31PM (#21260338)
No, it's Apple. The Chinese government is crying, and Apple, being the spineless company that it is, buckled under the slightest bit of pressure. Apple removed the app from their app store. Apple is in complete control of what apps are in there.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by scarface74 on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:34AM (#21223322)
Especially seeing the app doesn’t do anything that the website can’t do.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by kerkeslager on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:11AM (#21223527)
Did you visit the website? It's hella slow.

I imagine the app cached a lot of the map data locally and used a native renderer.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by scarface74 on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:07PM (#21226289)
Isn't that more of implementation detail? I've seen a few browser based game demos that work well on the iPhone and caching can also be done on mobile. While an app may be better for low end Android phones from an optimization standpoint, there are no "low end" iPhones that have been introduced since 2013 that wouldn't have a decent enough processor to handle a web based, optimized app.

I don't believe that more people -- especially on HN -- are focusing less on the web as a means to get around the "wall garden" than focusing on sideloading.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by bcrosby95 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @06:56PM (#21220028)
> Permanent removal from China would probably be worse for freedom in China over 20 years,

I'm curious about how you came to this conclusion.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by derefr on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:05PM (#21220100)
For one thing, pretty much every Android device made for the Chinese market has had its OS adulterated in some way, at OEM build time, at the behest of the Chinese government. Whereas, Chinese resellers can't really adulterate an iPhone's OS; there's just the one OS image (per model), signed and sealed by Apple, and if China wants to put a rootkit on it, they'd have to convince Apple to put it into that same base-image where any random security researcher (outside of China's reach to quash publication) might find it.

(And yes, either way the phone's baseband will be adulterated by Chinese ISPs at the government's behest, but modern smartphones isolate themselves from their baseband pretty well, so this only matters if you're using your phone as a phone [calling/texting], instead of as a tablet with a data modem.)

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by SiVal on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:35PM (#21220286)
No point in debating the details of which tech is more secure or what is encrypted or adulterated or whatever. Apple has made it clear that they will make sure the Chinese gov't gets what it wants. Even in a supposedly "autonomous" Hong Kong, China complains and Apple submits--flags, apps, speech, whatever. No need to even go to court, and certainly no point.

So Apple has made it clear that if China wants something, the tech details won't matter. "Oh, I'm sorry, we don't have that information to give you." "Well, start keeping it from now on, but don't tell them, because telling them would offend us, and you don't want that...."

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by taylodl on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:31AM (#21224715)
"So Apple has made it clear that if China wants something, the tech details won't matter."

This is an interesting statement and has important implications here in the United States as well: who's the bigger entity? The Multinational Megacorporation or the Country? Who dictates terms to whom? If a company wishes to do business in a country shouldn't they be expected to follow their laws? We need to be very careful in how we answer this question because we're at risk of losing our own democracy to a corporatacracy.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by millstone on Thursday October 10, 2019 @09:31PM (#21220784)
It's not "whatever." Apple has removed emoji and an app; they don't provide the government with backdoors or biometric data. There really is a line.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by bluesix on Thursday October 10, 2019 @10:17PM (#21220980)
Apple's iCloud servers for Chinese users are located in China, run by a Chinese tech service provider and provides them with the keys - as stipulated by the Chinese government. Of course the government has access to the data.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by corodra on Thursday October 10, 2019 @10:12PM (#21220951)
https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne...

2018:

"The iPhone maker’s latest Transparency Report reveals it received 32,342 demands from governments around the world to access 163,823 devices, with 80 per cent of the requests granted."

Come on, seriously? This is what they ADMIT to worldwide.

Here's on China: https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/cn.html

Again, what they admit to. And that's only on the second half of 2018. With all their regular anti-consumer practices on hardware, you're really going to imagine they're champions of individual freedoms and privacy?

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by jakelazaroff on Thursday October 10, 2019 @09:39PM (#21220824)
Why do you think there's a line? What is that based on?
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by sneak on Thursday October 10, 2019 @10:52PM (#21221129)
iCloud is backdoored at the server for all users in China.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by insulanus on Thursday October 10, 2019 @09:47PM (#21220849)
Well, you're pretty close here.

Yes, the iPhone has the best secure enclave.

However, there is nothing stopping Apple from making separate builds with extra "features" for the Chinese market, and installing them. Same keys, OS version chosen by region. Boom. Chinese version acceptable to Chinese government, rest of the world secure. Easy.

From my experience in this area, I would expect the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology to accept nothing less.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by Aperocky on Thursday October 10, 2019 @06:58PM (#21220043)
Because they would be replaced by local Chinese companies.

Are you saying that would have no effect on freedom for the users?

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by untog on Thursday October 10, 2019 @08:33PM (#21220535)
If Apple capitulates to every demand the Chinese government makes then perhaps there isn’t much of a difference.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by millstone on Thursday October 10, 2019 @09:34PM (#21220801)
Right. But of course the Chinese government has asked Apple for a backdoor, and (to our knowledge) Apple has not provided that. So long as that's true, an iPhone really is one of the most secure option for Chinese residents.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by fooker on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:11AM (#21221498)
> (to our knowledge)

This is really the key phrase here. What we know for sure is: Google and Facebook services do not work in China while Apple and Microsoft's do.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by _-___________-_ on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:56AM (#21223154)
Apple is open about the fact that their cloud services are operated by a Chinese company in China. No Chinese company has the option of refusing government demands for access to information. Therefore, at least the cloud services should be considered backdoored.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by virgilp on Friday October 11, 2019 @01:13AM (#21221728)
Actually, to our knowledge, they provided exactly that.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by awat on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:01PM (#21220066)
Agreed, not to hijack, but I fail to see the that $ORG not being at the table Vs. them constantly redefining morality for their actions to be at the table to be a less worse outcome.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by Aloha on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:06PM (#21220109)
I think the act of them being at the table is more likely to move the needle on the Chinese side.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by rdlecler1 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:43PM (#21220315)
Let’s call it what it is: bribery and corruption. It’s under the guise of market access, but it’s effectively still a payout by a government to do that you’re told. Apple wants to have it both ways, we are a moral authority in the US where we don’t have to worry about government interference but because we want access to the China market we’ll do whatever the government tells us to do. How much more dependent does China need to be before China can control other behavior it doesn’t like.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by freeopinion on Thursday October 10, 2019 @11:52PM (#21221421)
> they're looking out for their own beet [sic] interest and the best interest of their customers

I'm sure you think you just explained this, but it completely escaped me. How is yanking this app in the best interest of their customers?

Let's break "their customers" into 3 groups:

1. Protestors in HK. It clearly isn't in their best interest . So not those customers, right?

2. Non-protestors in China (including HK). You're argument is that this way they can still enjoy Apple products? Even though those products can no longer be trusted not to betray them to any whim of a hostile government?

3. Customers outside China. The argument here seems to be that Apple makes lots of money in China and that an Apple that makes tons of money in China and outside of China is better for non-Chinese customers than an Apple that makes tons of money outside of China but not inside of China.

This third group and justification is the most interesting to me. I stipulate that I have put words in your mouth. So let me take those words out of your mouth and just say this is the only way I can make sense of what you wrote.

When I follow this train of thought the only way I can see it being true is if Apple's very existence is threatened if some other company were able to fill the void in China, then leverage that to gain so much market power outside of China that they could squash Apple. And even that alone doesn't make things worse for (former) Apple customers. The only way that would be worse is if this hypothetical competitor's products were actually worse than Apple's and only able to dominate the market because of the market power they enjoy due to Apple's absence in the Chinese market.

That is such a stretch that I feel your argument should be dismissed. Can you fill in the holes of my understanding to help me see things your way?

I think this is an extremely important discussion because it seems to be the mindset held by a lot of decision makers. Is the NBA worried that they will stop making many $millions if they don't expand into China? That is, not only will they not double or triple their profits; they will actually stop making money outside of China? Is Disney worried about this? Are Microsoft and Amazon? Is it a fight for survival? Or is it pure naked greed?

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by freeopinion on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:23AM (#21221549)
Perhaps it could be argued that Apple is completely dependent on manufacturing facilities within China and losing that access would indeed be lethal. Some of Apple's biggest competitors outside China recognized that risk a long time ago and moved to minimize it. Why has Apple left themselves so vulnerable? Is it the only way they could produce inexpensively enough to stay competitive? Or is it, again, pure naked greed?
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by layoutIfNeeded on Friday October 11, 2019 @05:24PM (#21228615)
>Is it the only way they could produce inexpensively enough to stay competitive?

I hope you’re joking.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by alexbecker on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:24AM (#21221555)
The argument as I understand it is that group 2 mostly does not care about being protected from their government or even agrees with the government's actions, and they get to benefit from continued access to Apple's superior products. I'm not endorsing this argument, but it's not prima facie crazy.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by bobthepanda on Thursday October 10, 2019 @06:59PM (#21220049)
How would permanent removal be worse? iMessage is not magically more free than other messaging apps available in China.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by scarface74 on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:32AM (#21223316)
No, but the US can make it hard for certain companies by imposing tariffs that hurt certain industries and “investigating” companies that get on the wrong side. Do you think a Democratic administration would target companies run by the “liberal elite” or that a Republican administration would go after churches that are supporting political candidates?
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by curt15 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @06:58PM (#21220046)
>Permanent removal from China would probably be worse for freedom in China over 20 years

How does Apple advance freedom in China?

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by millstone on Thursday October 10, 2019 @09:41PM (#21220830)
Spyware is routinely found preinstalled on Chinese branded phones, and Chinese border guards will install spyware on tourists' Android phones. iPhone users are much better protected from this stuff.

1: https://www.cyberscoop.com/android-malware-china-huawei-zte-...

2: https://9to5mac.com/2019/07/03/spyware/

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by CogitoCogito on Thursday October 10, 2019 @11:29PM (#21221303)
Spyware is also found in iOS in China via iMessage so what’s your point?
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by sushicat on Friday October 11, 2019 @02:39AM (#21222075)
If we don’t talk about zero day vulnerability, which may be used by government to spy citizens, iMessage is end to end encrypted and secure.

Chinese local chat app like WeChat, or customized Android from Xiaomi or Huawei, they have back doors, which allow Chinese gov access data directly.

Spyware from unintentional vulnerability vs. intentional back doors are different.

Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by _-___________-_ on Friday October 11, 2019 @06:58AM (#21223169)
If your phone is backed up to iCloud, and your phone (or iCloud account, it's not clear) has the region set to China, then your messages are most likely accessible by the Chinese government, because Apple's cloud services are operated by a Chinese company in China, and Chinese companies don't have the option of resisting information requests from the government.
Re:Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up by Aloha on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:04PM (#21220090)
I'm presuming a local company would be even more willing to bend than Apple is, and would do so more often.