News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by Vivtek on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @10:09AM (#2119911)
I honestly hadn't expected this outpouring of vitriol here against John Scalzi, of all people. The things I'm reading here - that he's "just jealous" or what have you - are frankly blowing my mind.

I thought his point was pretty clear: FB is rolling in cash and is the target of the latest 15-minute hype and 50 billion dollars of Goldman-Sachs paper valuation, but isn't really breaking new ground in providing the best possible platform for the Web, and he predicts that this will cause it to fail, like other non-ideal repackaging efforts in the past, because it is limited. And he has some experience in this, because he was an employee of AOL in the day.

And weirdly, here at HNN, of all places, I am witnessing a deluge of rabid Facebook fanboys, many of whom apparently think he's just an old fogie who doesn't understand the new generation. The world never ceases to amaze me.

EDIT: more words are always good, right?

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by al_james on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:45PM (#2120572)
I think the discussion is divided between two camps:

1) Those who can't imagine the point of a messaging (or indeed, any) system that does not have all the bells and whistles you can imagine or get using another system.

2) Those that realise that most people only use a very small subset of those features, and that everything else is just a potential cause of confusion. So, offering a messaging system that "does a few things, but does them well" will be an attractive proposition for many people.

It seems that these two camps can't see each other's points of view. The author of the article seems to acknowledge 2 but keeps coming back to 1.

"more words are always good, right"

No. Less words to say the same thing are normally much better, the rest is just noise.

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by Vivtek on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @01:12PM (#2120653)
No. Less words to say...

You are familiar with the concept of self-deprecating humor on your world, are you not?

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by smackfu on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:32AM (#2120278)
I think people are getting a little tired of blog posts that follow this pattern:

1. Argh, I will finally join Facebook even though I hate it.

2. OMG, I cannot believe that Facebook does something a way that I don't like.

3. Facebook sucks, I am quitting. You should too, obviously.

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by Vivtek on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:22PM (#2120482)
That's pretty much exactly what Scalzi's post wasn't.
Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by smackfu on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:40PM (#2120557)
I don't know, doesn't the BCC rant meet the 2nd point?
Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by apu on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:31PM (#2120525)
Shouldn't text be judged on its own merits, rather than who the author is?

And who is the author? I have no idea. But I do know from reading the article that he sounds bitter/jealous and a little bit clueless.

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by phlux on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @10:21AM (#2119955)
Umm, in case you haven't noticed, HN is full of FB echo-chamber fanbois who have a combined age still in the 2 digits.
Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by alexgartrell on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:24AM (#2120239)
I don't really think your snarky attitude is adding to the discussion, but, more than that, it's not even correct. The vast majority of replies here are decidedly anti facebook, and the ones that arent tend to be luke warm at best. Additionally, if you look at the front page over the last couple days, he popular facebook related articles have been very anti facebook.

I'm not trying to make any claims about face book's virtue (as a future facebook engineer, I doubt I would have much credibility anyway), but it is unfair to be so dismissive about people who might argue that it isn't completely awful, when they certainly aren't just part of hn groupthink (as you seem to have suggested.)

Re:Facebook is what happens to the Web when you hit it with ... by phlux on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @02:04PM (#2120817)
Fine, ill add some detail to my snarky comment. There is so much going on in the valley and in tech right now that frankly has all happened before. Given the market conditions now are far more ripe for all these services, which allows them to be made and more successful now.

The problem I see, and the point of my comment is that we truly aren't seeing too much that is new - but when a company comes along that is hyper successful and full of young talented engineers - people forget history.

That is fine - but I think people need to take a step back sometimes.

Point taken, however. (I'll take my own advice about taking a step back :) )